your definition loses your purported binary classification when examined through rigor
> (a) it makes copies of itself
what about those forms of life that are unable to procreate, or choose to abstain? also 'copies' is ambiguous: see (b);
> (b) the copies inherit traits from the original
seems an unecessary condition.. if one is to accept the first than this is redundant, also it is confusing because you say 'inherit traits' and 'copies', a copy should inherit all traits, so which are we talking about? copies or trait inheriting progeny? if 'copies' is intentional what about forms of life unable to make exact copies of itself, like humanity?
> (c) the traits are subject to variation/mutation
if 'variation/mutation' is random one possibility would need to be completely foregoing the 'variation/mutation'
if 'variation/mutation' is deterministic then are there deterministic models of 'variation/mutation' that you would leave out of your definition for life?
(d) the success of the copies at making further copies depends on those traits which are inherited, then evolution must occur
what about life that fails in its own ability to continue to evolve but heavily affords other life to evolve further.. i'm thinking something like wheat that is scientifically controlled in its evolution because we forced its evolution to a sweet spot that for years helped humanity to evolve as we wanted
surely we must include mules in life.
Always test your definition against fire and crystals.
Crystals: Do not mutate, or if by some twisting of definition you say they do (e.g. defects are propagated through the lattice), the success of propagation doesn't depend on the inherited traits.
Having said that, the long term stability of that path is definitely debatable!
It doesn't. Evolution is indeed a greedy algorithm, and cannot plan.
EDIT: I'm confused about the downvotes. To be really concrete, the swimmers in Darwin Pond[1] seem to me to satisfy all of OP's criteria for life. Do they not?
If (a) it makes copies of itself, (b) the copies inherit traits from the original, (c) the traits are subject to variation/mutation, and (d) the success of the copies at making further copies depends on those traits which are inherited, then evolution must occur.
Every other definition seems to me over-complex and ad-hoc; like specific things we have noticed which tend to be true about most life on Earth, but which might not be true for special cases, or for some other hypothetical extraterrestrial life which we might discover someday.
This definition is an unambiguous binary classifier, and it seems to correctly categorize everything we would intuitively call "alive". (Also, under this definition, viruses are unambiguously life).