None of them are particularly original, they're all just variations of the same thing. Fundamentally there's little difference between Maple and Dominoes Pizza delivery.
Surely it would be a no-brainer to do delivery only, and optimize for that. Select a few cuisines, get great chefs to develop recipes that anyone can be trained to execute flawlessly, set up locations strategically situated to minimize delivery time/distance. It might not end up being Michelin-star-quality food, but then none of the places I order deliver from are, either.
As a consumer, my biggest problems with delivery are speed and quality. Places I order from routinely take 60+ minutes to deliver, even if they're close by. Quality is the bigger problem, and I suspect a lot of people feel the same.
A delivery-only restaurant still needs to deal with hiring staff, sourcing product, health inspections, purchase and maintenance of equipment, etc. That's before the whole delivery thing comes into the picture. If you want fast service, you have to scale up the staff and get some decent logistics in place.
I suspect this would only be profitable via automation. But that will probably happen soon.
But heck, I was just a delivery boy, and lots of people really loved the idea. I'm sure we'll see more delivery startups, and maybe they'll be great, having learned from Maple.
If you think of it as a trilemma between quality, speed and price, it's unlikely you'll ever find a service that can meet your needs because when a competitor shows up, "worse is better" kicks in.
Want a sandwich at noon? That's $7. Want it at 3pm? That's $4. Want us to drop everything and get it to you in 15 minutes? That's an extra $2.
If a startup wants to leverage technology, its founders should approach Dominoes, not try to become a competitor of Dominoes while trying to do something with delivery. Domonoes will crush them like an annoying bug they are.
Sometimes I wonder if the VC world is the worst possible combination, rewarding merely the false promise of short term impact, as opposed to genuinely worthwhile but perhaps completely unprofitable RnD.
Besides, how many "actual" innovations were profitable at an early stage? I take issue with the entire concept of splitting "actual" innovations from attempted innovations, because all successful innovations began as attempts.
There's a couple of reasons people like that don't partner with someone who is able to raise the capital more easily, but the most pronounced i've heard was that they don't want to buy into the dishonest-"fake it till you make it" culture that surrounds VC.
Companies that don’t play the VC game are harder work but totally possible (and potentially more rewarding) but the VC game requires those “hustlers” because that’s the VC’s expectations.
When thousands of startups with terrible ideas get funded, it floods the market with tons of new products that users don't get any value from. Eventually they get category fatigue and just start blocking out trying anything new. Even if you've got something innovative that you can build yourself, people still need to try it for it to catch on. That's easier when there are few other products vying for attention and users are actively looking for something new.
Fortunately, I think the last mania ended around 2015. Trump has sucked all of the oxygen out of the collective zeitgeist since mid-2016, so hopefully by 2018 people will be sick of being angry at their leaders and looking for small, concrete ways to improve their lives.
When you have lots of unprofitable "businesses" chasing after the same limited pool of resources using their big bags of monopoly money, the business environment becomes toxic to fragile, new organisms.
What would you say might put us on the path to getting better in the long term, and what does better mean exactly? The system we have right now is designed to waste large amounts of money, it will never get better by itself. Won't VCs always seek lower risk, and go for the best ideas they can find that have some chance of working? It seems we could always look at the biggest failures and call it easy money, rip the ideas apart as stupid, regardless of how much actual innovation is there.
Is it fair to characterize the business plan of Maple or Sprig to deliver food at a loss? I assume the idea was to make a profit eventually, but being able to deliver quality on 15 minutes notice can only work on a huge scale.
The risk may actually not be that high due to the liquidation preferences and the inflated prices and hype may actually be promoted by the VCs themselves so they can offload at high prices. The most important factor for this pump and dump is the founders personality.
Crypto ICOs eliminate much of this potential as whilst in the VC model the investor needs to be thinking pump-and-dump. In crypto, every buyer must be thinking this. Ironically due to the hype in cryptocurrencies the hype may be so widespread that this does indeed happen despite it being able to completely upset the funding model. (That large capital requires impressing specific keyholders)
The easy money in tech right now is harmful, as it crowds out actual innovation. But I don't see it getting better anytime soon.