Yes piece of mind is worth that, and I can attach a number to that to, we've had a car that was maintained regularly and broke down, cost of tow + taxi to go to the rental place, rental (we need a minivan => expensive) was close to 1 K CAD. Kia warranty comes with 24 h emergency. We will have an older car once the kids are out (or possibly live somewhere we don't need a car), but today I'm happy to pay this.
F.ex. adding something like this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11879869
Buying a super complicated engine with high reliability is a different risk than buying a simpler engine that has lower reliability, but that can be repaired much more cheaply.
As you admit, it's for piece of mind. Because I can't imagine something like that happening to you every year if you owned a used car.
Let's be upfront and frank about it. You will pay more for the added convenience. You really should put a number on it to get an idea.
I bought my car 6 years ago for $9000. It was an 8 year old car, but with low miles. In the last 6 years, I've paid $2100 in repairs and maintenance (includes changing oil, tires, etc). So a total of $11,100 in 6 years. My car is worth $2900 now. So a loss of $8200 in 6 years. That's $1367 per year.
How much will your car depreciate in 6 years?
If I compare it with a top of the line Subaru Forester, that depreciated at least $8K in the first two years.
Your situation may be good - I'm not sure. But unless you really run the numbers, you'll never know. People always do hand waving rationalizations in their hand. Don't. Get a spreadsheet and run the numbers.
Not saying paying a lot for peace of mind is a bad idea. That's for you to decide.