Let's be upfront and frank about it. You will pay more for the added convenience. You really should put a number on it to get an idea.
I bought my car 6 years ago for $9000. It was an 8 year old car, but with low miles. In the last 6 years, I've paid $2100 in repairs and maintenance (includes changing oil, tires, etc). So a total of $11,100 in 6 years. My car is worth $2900 now. So a loss of $8200 in 6 years. That's $1367 per year.
How much will your car depreciate in 6 years?
If I compare it with a top of the line Subaru Forester, that depreciated at least $8K in the first two years.
Your situation may be good - I'm not sure. But unless you really run the numbers, you'll never know. People always do hand waving rationalizations in their hand. Don't. Get a spreadsheet and run the numbers.
Not saying paying a lot for peace of mind is a bad idea. That's for you to decide.
Yes piece of mind is worth that, and I can attach a number to that to, we've had a car that was maintained regularly and broke down, cost of tow + taxi to go to the rental place, rental (we need a minivan => expensive) was close to 1 K CAD. Kia warranty comes with 24 h emergency. We will have an older car once the kids are out (or possibly live somewhere we don't need a car), but today I'm happy to pay this.
F.ex. adding something like this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11879869
Buying a super complicated engine with high reliability is a different risk than buying a simpler engine that has lower reliability, but that can be repaired much more cheaply.
As you admit, it's for piece of mind. Because I can't imagine something like that happening to you every year if you owned a used car.
Why? The sliding door roller system is garbage and breaks semi-annually. (@$900/per incident) Biggest issue the Pilot is a poor quality key cylinder system that was a recall in several 1999-2004 models, but not the Pilot.
I heard 7 years in Europe. Is it true in the US too?
I wonder why 5 years only in Canada!
Buy a brand that is fully guaranteed for 5 years. We sell them at 4 to 5 years old. This completely kills the repair budget.
Buy vehicles 6 months to 1 year old. That one brand we buy (like most but not all brands) doesn't depreciate linearly, and depreciate the most the first year. So this reduce the depreciation budget significantly.
The only difference in the consumable budget, compared to a 10 year old car is that we pay a lot for insurance (full vs 3rd party only).
The plus of our strategy is that an accident does not change our budgets, which it would in OP's case, as they might have to increase repair (assuming 3rd p ins) or force them to buy their next vehicle early, throwing out some of their calculations.