As norms change within a group, those who hold beliefs outside the Overton Window can become afraid to express those beliefs, and that leads to people simply not even comprehending another group's views. How did Trump get elected president? Why didn't we see it coming? This is what the people in my Manhattan office were thinking the day after the election. On the other hand, family members from Nebraska were laughing and asking how the coastal elite "didn't get it". We aren't talking because we can't disagree without falling out with each other.
I expect the same is true of sexual norms, dating norms, social norms, norms about drugs and alcohol, etc.
Generationally, the Snapchat generation probably has no idea what those growing up in the 1940s believed, and those who were teenagers during the American sexual revolution of the 1960s would probably be surprised by the way teens date and have sex today. We have vague ideas and notions but how many of us have had 30+ min conversations about these topics with people who are from a far off generation?
No one communicates and I believe historians of the future will feel it's an enormous tragedy that we don't have better surveys and public records of personal beliefs in areas that are controversial or highly personal. And more than just 'what do you believe', but 'what are the circumstances that led you to have those beliefs, what were the consequences around your actions that influenced those beliefs', etc.
I would also add that this institutionalization largely deprives youth of contact with adult role models, forcing them to figure out many things by themselves or from TV or the Internet. And models or advice which can be found there are various and not always provided with disclaimers regarding their accuracy and scope of applicability.
This breaks the most major way children have historically found their vocation: by asking people a few years older than them, who already have some small proficiency in the subject, to show them how to get into the subject. And, as well, being that mentor later on.
Some school systems try to recreate this effect with clubs, but clubs are broken at the most important point—the transition from elementary to high-school. It's the kids before the transition and the kinds after it that are most in need of this mentorship interaction, and there's no system in place to give it to them.
And this also breaks socialization: every year of children is now its own isolated cohort, with isolated social norms, entirely unmoved by what older or younger children would think of those actions. This is basically 90% of why "kids are terrible" in the Western school system: kids don't learn social norms from parents, but rather expect to read them on the faces of slightly-older kids reacting to their behavior. If there are no slightly-older kids (as in a uniform-age classroom), then there's nobody the kids trust there, who also has the maturity to disapprove. And there's no slightly-younger kids they feel responsible for behaving in front of.
To me it seems pretty obvious that this entire discussion is the product of trying to navigate powerful and ineradicable biological and evolutionary processes in a culture that thinks it has outgrown them (but hasn't and never will).
I don't know what the answer to this problem is, but I can guarantee that it will eventually lead to fewer women being hired in male dominated companies, and vice versa. Companies always lean toward taking on fewer liabilities, and given the "lunch is sexual harassment" atmosphere of today, these extreme overreactions to often well-intended conduct will turn into a classic case of winning the battle and losing the war.
It's incredible the victim complex so many people seem to have. We go through a bunch of news stories of people bluntly sexually harassing people they work with, and the takeaway is "lunch as sexual harassment atmosphere".
"Sexual harassment is sexual harassment" is the current atmosphere...
Although you make a good point, I'm not sure if I would have done it if she reported to me.
but managers should really be able to have one-on-one lunches with their employees. humanizing (not sexualizing) the relationship is important.
Do these people not do one-on-ones?
We Americans have always been said to be puritanical. Originally, this was based on religious morality adopted by society. Now, it seems to be based on the constant overhanging fear of men as potential abusers. (Is a constant overhanging fear of men as abusers much different than a constant overhanging fear of brown people as potential criminals? There are statistics to support both.) As a victim of sexual abuse as a teen, I'm well aware of the potential for bad things to happen out of the view of society. However, the frequency with which weird intentions have been erroneously ascribed to me strikes me as a bit off kilter. I've even watched a woman weirdly freak out on me and ascribe such things to me for doing and saying absolutely nothing.
One thing you pick up, if you read enough history, is that people ascribe clandestine evils to people as a means of aggression or attack. The Salem witch trials had an economic/resource allocation basis. (Resource allocation problems bring out the worst in people. Jared Diamond's analysis of Rwanda is another example.) There's also a history of women of higher status using such accusations as a means of "punching down" on men of lower socioeconomic status, often across racial lines. Such accusations are particularly potent for being lurid. In mentioning this, I'm not trying to imply that all accusations are weaponized false accusations. What I am saying is that human nature just as much applies to both men and women, both the good and the bad.
So what to do, if you live in a world that simultaneously contains innocent people, clandestine evils, and the opportunistic false accusation of clandestine evil? The solution lies in a society that emphasizes openness, truth, and the protection of the individual. The presupposition that someone is prone to do something based on an inherent trait is particularly dehumanizing. It's just as epistemically bankrupt and dehumanizing to presuppose bad intentions to someone on the basis of sex as it is to presuppose bad intentions to someone on the basis of their race, their religion, their sexual orientation, or their place of national origin.
We call out countries that would throw individuals under the bus for their purposes. We should also call out ideologies that advocate throwing individuals under the bus for their purposes. (The protection of the individual is, after all, the foundation of liberal values.)
(P.S. You can tell if someone is too far gone as an ideologue if you set a trap for their presuppositions, and they can't help but blunder into it.)
This might just very well be because in the former age bracket, the women are still very young and are not quite experienced in how to handle and deflect unwanted male attention. Older women on the other hand, have been through a lifetime of this and thus may be a lot more comfortable knowing that they know how to be safe and handle inappropriate behavior better.
> “If I couldn’t meet with my boss one on one, I don’t get that face time to show what I can do to get that next promotion”
That's a fascinating perspective.
> Any rule about avoiding meetings that applied only to one sex, even if unspoken, would most likely be illegal,
But rules that applied without regard to sex would be legal.
Note that, for all their flaws, heterosexual single-sex workplaces do cleanly avoid the problem of mixing sex with work.
Practically impossible, unless you've developed actual gaydar[1]. Joking aside, you can't actually guarantee that unless you're talking about very small companies. Give me a company of 50 single-sex people, and there's probably at least one LGBT person there.
[1] In which case I look forward to your forthcoming HN post.
Since the “problem of mixing sex with work” extends to work-related contacts that are not employed by the same employers, but who are (or are employed by) customers, suppliers, or other business partners of the firm, it is not at all true that an exclusively heterosexual single-sex workplace avoids the problem, unless all workplaces and their direct customers, etc., are exclusively heterosexual and of the same single sex.
A study conducted for the New York Times study shows that Americans, especially women, have quite negative views of being alone with members of the opposite sex. Only 29% of women consider having a drink alone with a man who is not their spouse to be appropriate behavior, and only 63% think a one-on-one workplace meeting is appropriate. Some trends are surprising: when it comes to dinner, 60-70% of women 18-29 view it as inappropriate, but only 30% of women 55+.
I'm not sure what the takeaway is. To me it seems like the product of a culture that has trouble drawing appropriate boundaries between romantic and other contexts. Perhaps it is an outgrowth of the fact that people are basically institutionalized from ages 13-22. School is all consuming--it's where you "work," where you socialize, where you pursue romantic relationships. When people get out into the "real world," they have little experience with all the myriad difference social contexts of ordinary life, and see the workplace as a similar environment.