I don't closely follow that story and I haven't seen your sources, but in general a 5% marginal increase in buyers can completely transform a market.
Do foreign purchases have an impact on the market? Sure. Would the market still be crazy overheated and ready to collapse without foreign purchases? I'd bet it would.
edit: just looked at the stats. Metro Vancouver was at about 12.5% of sales, and Richmond was at nearly 25% of sales before they put in the foreign buyers tax.
https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2011/02/24/hong_kong_asi...
"There is one Canadian citizen in every 13 households in Hong Kong, says a new survey by Vancouver-based Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada. About 300,000 Canadian citizens are living and working in the metropolitan city and 8 per cent of households there reported to have at least one Canadian over the age of 18 among them." "Only 16 per cent of the Canadians surveyed considered Canada as their home “all the time,” while 37 per cent said “never.” Worse, 35 per cent said they would “almost never” or “never” consider returning to Canada."
Some more interesting anecdotes can be found in threads like these, such as:
"I've had a number of them come into my dental office. They all get their kids on the Healthy Smiles program which pays for dental care for children of low income families in Ontario. They claim they're low income so they qualify for it and they roll up to their appointments in brand new Lexus' and Audi's. Not only are they pricing Canadians out of real estate but they're abusing the social security system." https://www.reddit.com/r/canada/comments/5krd4n/canada_overw...
Canada serves two purposes:
- free education and healthcare
- escape plan if the sh*t starts to hit the fan at home
And it's the perfect country for abuse due to a culture of extreme politically correctness. (e.g.: Citizens of Chinese ethnicity won't be audited as it could be perceived as being racist):
http://vancouversun.com/opinion/columnists/douglas-todd-cana...
http://vancouversun.com/opinion/columnists/douglas-todd-vanc...
You can hardly even get any truth from social media any more, /r/Vancouver moderators will ban you if you post anything implying any wrongdoing may be happening. /r/Canada still seems to allow it, for now.
95% of purchasers were Canadian citizens or permanent residents. Low interest rates and willingness to take on a lot of debt is what drove the bubble in Canada.