News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Antisocial Coding: My Year at GitHub by ivraatiems on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:18PM (#14704294)
Do you think this person is unusual in her communication style? She posted the complete text of the "problem" comment. If you got that message from a colleague, would you consider it unacceptable? Why or why not? If yes, what could she have said that would have made it OK?

How would you answer her core question of whether or not the comment she made is appropriate?

Re:Antisocial Coding: My Year at GitHub by fenwick67 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:45PM (#14704582)
Re-structure the question and switch gender out for cake flavors.

"What flavor of cake do you prefer? Chocolate, vanilla, or sheetcake?"

the feedback coming back as...

"'Sheetcake' is not a flavor. Sheetcake may be vanilla, chocolate, red velvet, lemon-poppyseed... If you want to know if a survey respondent likes sheetcake, you need to explicitly ask that question."

... it does seem kinda grating but not overtly so. It could have been nicer but also could have been more rude.

Re:Antisocial Coding: My Year at GitHub by ivraatiems on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:47PM (#14704602)
I completely agree. I know and have worked with many people who communicate that way. I'd probably prefer it if they didn't, but I also don't generally have a problem when they do. I would feel that the explanation was unnecessarily pedantic and perhaps the slightest bit disrespectful in its assumption that I didn't know what I was talking about, but I would assume that was unintentional. It's interesting that the reaction from this data scientist individual came back so extremely negative.
Re:Antisocial Coding: My Year at GitHub by sgt on Thursday July 06, 2017 @03:58AM (#14708824)
The more I think of it, this whole thing is like something out of Portlandia.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portlandia_(TV_series)

Re:Antisocial Coding: My Year at GitHub by Dirlewanger on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:29PM (#14704404)
I'm disgusted at her reflection that the question was transphobic, not that she commented on the difference. Whether the data scientist overreacted or not is irrelevant.
Re:Antisocial Coding: My Year at GitHub by ivraatiems on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:31PM (#14704433)
It's not irrelevant because it's the reason she was fired, and hence the reason the post exists. The fact that you disagree with her assertion about the question seems to be the irrelevant thing to me.
Re:Antisocial Coding: My Year at GitHub by Dirlewanger on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @02:00PM (#14704731)
No, it is irrelevant. The fact that the incident got her fired is a failing with GitHub's management and dearth of communication. Playing the victim card and shitting on the data scientist is misguided.
Re:Antisocial Coding: My Year at GitHub by ivraatiems on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @02:07PM (#14704790)
But it seems to me that if GitHub failed her in its practices, she was a victim. Why wouldn't she be?
Re:Antisocial Coding: My Year at GitHub by dcole2929 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:42PM (#14704556)
Calling a comment transphobic in no way implies that the speaker of that comment is transhpobic. It is a description of what's been said. The same way if someone was to say something that could possibly be construed as racist. If someone points that out and says hey that statement is racist, that's not calling that person racist. They might be. They might not, but that statement in and of itself implies no assertion on that actual person.

In short, calling the statement in question transphobic is correct.

Re:Antisocial Coding: My Year at GitHub by Sorreah on Thursday July 06, 2017 @02:08AM (#14708460)
>Calling a comment transphobic in no way implies that the speaker of that comment is transhpobic.

Then what does it imply, that the comment has a phobia of or holds hate for trans people?

If I call your post autistic, does that not imply I think less of you for making it?

Re:Antisocial Coding: My Year at GitHub by fenwick67 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:49PM (#14704622)
Intent is the difference between being transphobic and being ignorant. The survey question was ignorant.
Re:Antisocial Coding: My Year at GitHub by roguecoder on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @05:14PM (#14706168)
How silly it sounds to anthropomorphize the question that way should tell you that you are wrong in this case. A question doesn't have a brain to be ignorant with, nor does it have intentions of any sort: once someone has written it down, it just is.

In TDD, do we talk about a unit test succeeding because I intended for it to fail and it did? No, we say it failed because the actual result is red. I didn't fail, but the test sure did.

Intention doesn't change the impact of communication; if the intent doesn't match the actual outcome, what it means is that the author probably wanted to change it.