News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA Revives Plan to Put Nuclear Reactors on Mars by danpalmer on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @05:40AM (#14701029)
I disagree. Nuclear reactors have been very safe for a long time now, but between high profile incidents with old reactors, the link with nuclear weapons, and misinformation, the public perception is that they are unsafe.
Re:NASA Revives Plan to Put Nuclear Reactors on Mars by mikejb on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @09:23AM (#14702172)
"very safe" might be true (your interpretation of 'very' might vary), but it is a low chance/high price kind of thing. I live in Bavaria, and hunters here still need to take precautions due to Chernobyl, some 31 years later.
Re:NASA Revives Plan to Put Nuclear Reactors on Mars by DiThi on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @09:34AM (#14702237)
It's very safe if you don't disable safety systems put in place (like it was explicitly done in Chernobyl to do dangerous experiments, even though they labeled it as "routine tests"). And if you don't ignore many warnings given in the industry (like TEPCO ignoring many recommendations of raising their tsunami protection walls many years before the catastrophe, like other plants closer to the epicenter that were unaffected).

So the chance is much lower than people think, if plans have measures to avoid such corruptions. And that's not counting the many safer designs we have nowadays. Many plants today don't even need backup electricity to automatically shut down by themselves.

Re:NASA Revives Plan to Put Nuclear Reactors on Mars by mikejb on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @09:56AM (#14702394)
I fully agree that newer designs are safer, but ignoring the human factor in the equation is IMO not very reasonable. Without the human factor, driving a car is very safe. That argument is valid, but it doesn't reflect reality.
Re:NASA Revives Plan to Put Nuclear Reactors on Mars by DougWebb on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @10:24AM (#14702617)
Good engineers take the human factor into account and include backups in their designs to handle failure modes caused by the human factor.

What they can't do is work around politics or budgetary constraints which force trade-offs between safety and cost. Anything can be made as safe as necessary, if you're willing to pay for the redundancies.

When it comes to reactors on Earth, a very large proportion of the budget is diverted to bureaucratic paperwork, lobbying, and PR, which could instead be used to pay for additional safety measures.

Re:NASA Revives Plan to Put Nuclear Reactors on Mars by thehardsphere on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:54AM (#14703445)
There are some "human factor" problems that engineers cannot and should not be expected to resolve.

I mean, how can someone design a communist-proof nuclear reactor?

Re:NASA Revives Plan to Put Nuclear Reactors on Mars by striking on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:42PM (#14704554)
Make them pay to get in?
Re:NASA Revives Plan to Put Nuclear Reactors on Mars by thehardsphere on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @02:18PM (#14704879)
Wouldn't work. They know how to steal and can even make fiat currency outside of the free market context.

Not a bad idea though.

Re:NASA Revives Plan to Put Nuclear Reactors on Mars by danpalmer on Thursday July 06, 2017 @04:20AM (#14708889)
Sure, but that was a) 31 years ago, b) a reactor built without the safety standards we have now, and c) a reactor operated without the safety standards we have now.

As far as I understand, making a reactor built in the last 25 years go 'wrong' in any way like that is very difficult, and would take much more than negligence or incompetence.

Fukushima is an example of this – the reactor that had issues was over 50 years old, but all the modern ones were fine.