News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by dang on Monday July 03, 2017 @09:56PM (#14692937)
'Censorship' has become more pejorative than informative, but you're right that users are downvoting and flagging comments; I think pretty fairly. Wherever moderators have intervened (in any way that affects comment visibility), we've posted comments saying so. That goes for the previous threads too.

Not every kind of comment is welcome here. HN is trying for higher-quality discussion. (Trying and failing, of course. But we can always fail better.) Comments that destroy the possibility of higher-quality discussion should certainly be flagged—otherwise the community is hostage to every kind of trolling.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by Banthum on Monday July 03, 2017 @10:35PM (#14693101)
Every comment I've seen so far that has been dead or flagged down had these two properties:

1. Honestly attempting to contribute new information and views to the conversation, or asking new questions. 2. Opinion or assumptions would be considered immoral from a certain (currently dominant) point of view.

It seems pretty clear to me that "high-quality" is being conflated with "reinforces my moral convictions" or "upholds my tribal sacred values".

There should be an effort to push back against this (though it'd take a really deep commitment to free speech and against moral/tribal orthodoxy as a general principle). It seems unlikely but one can hope.

EDIT: Hilariously, I'm getting downvotes for this. There's an Inception joke in here somewhere.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by sillysaurus3 on Monday July 03, 2017 @10:52PM (#14693179)
HN isn't an ideological battleground. In general, it's for whatever gratifies intellectual curiosity. The flagged comments may have contributed information, but most of them share a common trait: they're incendiary.

The way to introduce a controversial idea on HN is to be substantive and neutral. It's not easy to do. People are generally passionate about their points of view, and I've been guilty of this myself. But the ideal is worth striving for.

In particular, complaining about downvotes is also against the rules. I did this the other day and regretted it; it unfairly catapulted my comment to the top of the thread due to the overcorrection, and by then it was too late to edit. It's better to let a comment stand or fall on its own merits, as difficult as that is.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by Banthum on Monday July 03, 2017 @11:21PM (#14693294)
>The way to introduce a controversial idea on HN is to be substantive and neutral.

I agree in principle. But standards should be applied the same way to all comments with regard to viewpoints.

What I'm seeing is that the same standards aren't being applied to different viewpoints.

An orthodox viewpoint can be written casually, unsourced, tinged with moral judgment, etc, and still get away unflagged and not downvoted. An unorthodox viewpoint will get ripped apart on the tiniest error, missing source, or mis-chosen wordage.

I understand people are tribal and some just want to suppress dissent and maintain the power of their orthodoxy. But I also hope a place like HN can rise above such tribalism.

(regarding downvote complaints I don't disagree with the general policy.. if you're referring to my comment you replied to here I didn't intend to complain, only to point out the irony and perhaps try to cue some downvoters to consider what they're doing from a further remove).

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by sillysaurus3 on Monday July 03, 2017 @11:34PM (#14693354)
You can see the content of flagged comments by going into your profile settings and turning on the [showdead] option. Currently there are 26 flagged comments, so to pick a few random ones:

"By that standard, the only way to never do anything inappropriate is to never do anything."

"It's interesting that you construct a whole evil persona for someone..."

"When your worth is defined solely by how horny you make the opposite sex..."

"I cannot understand why sexual harassment takes such a toll on women. I've been sexually harassed by other men before, and somehow it wasn't as big of a problem..."

I didn't cherry-pick the above examples; they were just the first few that showed up with Command-F [flagged]. "Incendiary" is still probably the best way to describe these comments, which is why they're flagged. The other reason is shallowness on a controversial topic, which usually leads to flamewars.

If you see a comment that breaks a specific guideline in https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html then you're encouraged to flag it. (You need a certain amount of karma to see the flag button.) The main reason that the comments you mention aren't flagged is usually because they don't violate any of the guidelines. The system isn't perfect, but it seems to work remarkably well given the size of HN's audience.

Regarding talking about downvotes, I understand and can relate to the point of view. To clarify, I didn't mean anything by the word "complain." The reason to avoid mentioning "downvotes" at all is because (a) talking about downvotes spawns low-quality subthreads almost instantly, and (b) it gives your comment an unfair advantage. HN's voting system fluctuates wildly thanks to the diversity of the people that now have the privilege of downvoting, but in general, high-quality substantive comments tend to rise.

If you want to give a few examples of comments you feel were unfairly flagged, or unflagged comments that you feel break the guidelines, I'd be happy to chat about those. (We're currently in a flagged subthread, so there's no harm in continuing our conversation.)

EDIT: To address one specific point more thoroughly:

An orthodox viewpoint can be written casually, unsourced, tinged with moral judgment, etc, and still get away unflagged and not downvoted. An unorthodox viewpoint will get ripped apart on the tiniest error, missing source, or mis-chosen wordage.

Unorthodox, controversial viewpoints are indeed held to a higher standard, but the reason is because it fosters better conversation. For these, HN is optimized for substantive-but-neutral. Deviating from either axis tends to produce flamewars of the worst caliber.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by tnone on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @10:12AM (#14695974)
On this topic, it absolutely is. Whenever these threads happen, they go one way or the other.

If the all-genders-equal, non-feminist side swings the discussion, the entire thread disappears off the front page, inexplicably sitting at position 500+ with no flagged indicator. The lambdaconf debacle comes to mind, but it's hardly the only example.

If the feminist, women-are-victims-side swings the discussion, the thread is left up, full of moral chastising, with a graveyard of flagged comments serving as a warning to the evil dissenters.

On this topic, HN is unquestionably biased from the top, and the pretense otherwise is laughably non-credible and deluded.

Furthermore, while meta-complaining is against the rules, this rule is again only enforced against those who question the party line, not those lamenting the amount of immoral thought on display.

The bigger message being sent is obvious though: men, don't bother apologizing for your missteps or character flaws. Forgiveness is not coming.

If a woman got drunk at a guy's house, and was being insistent upon being shown the door, throwing it in her face would be considered cold and insensitive.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by greglindahl on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @02:30PM (#14697466)
You might want to check your definitions -- feminism is the belief that all genders should be treated equally.
Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by Banthum on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @04:45PM (#14705938)
In feminism's the "motte and bailey" belief structure, that's the motte (the thing people say when challenged).

It's not the bailey (the thing people actually want to say and do) though.

One example of the bailey in action: http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-06-30/bilnd-recruitment-tria...

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by hyperdunc on Monday July 03, 2017 @11:29PM (#14693329)
Not every flagged comment has been flagged undeservedly, but some of them have.

I agree that there is a trend on HN where comments that go against the "moral convictions" or politics of the majority are flagged. It's disappointing to see this happening.

Flagging a poorly worded or clearly incendiary comment is fair. That's not what has happened to some of the comments for this article. I hesitate to call it censorship, but it comes close.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @12:17AM (#14693516)
Would you mind listing some examples of flagged comments that you feel don't break the guidelines?
Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by whiddershins on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @01:36AM (#14693761)
I feel that my two comments, although tone deaf, possibly misguided, and certainly not well worded, were good faith comments that did not overtly violate guidelines.

I've never had my comments on hn flagged before and can't help but think I wandered into a minefield. Nearly half of the top level comments on this thread are flagged. If you include the ones that are downvoted into oblivion it is fully half at the time of this writing.

Is that because this article is beset by trolls, or because the conversation is being stifled?

Hard to say. But I know my intention was good faith.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @02:21AM (#14693907)
I think you're referring to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14692957.

This was a tough one. I ultimately decided not to vouch it, and I'd like to try to explain why. It doesn't have anything to do with the content or my own feelings on the matter, but rather the way in which the idea was presented.

I agree that it was in good faith, and it was also substantive. But it's not really neutral:

"But seriously? Do I live in an alternate reality where drunk people do all sorts of borderline illegal inappropriate stuff on a regular basis?"

"It may seem insensitive, but I am being pragmatic: whether or not something "haunts" you has as much to do with your way of framing an event and your attitude towards trauma as the actual event. Just because someone else did something wrong is no reason to carry it with you for years."

I can only describe my own perspective on the comment, which may not represent everyone else's. But the reason that I feel the flag is deserved is that even though the comment is written in good faith, it presents your side as clearly correct. The implication is that if anyone disagrees with you, they must be mistaken.

The phrasing "Do I live in an alternate reality...?" sets up the reader to want to disagree with you. It's argumentative rather than pensive. It's entirely possible that your life experiences are an outlier rather than representative. E.g. I agree that drunk people tend to do risky things, but in my own life, my friends manage to restrain themselves pretty well. I'm probably the outlier rather than you, but the point is that framing the argument as can't-possibly-be-wrong is poisonous to thoughtful conversation.

That leads to the other issue, which is that it blames the victim of harassment for feeling harassed. It's certainly possible that whether you're harmed by an incident is a matter of perspective, but it's not automatically up to the victim to fortify themselves. If someone is legitimately distraught over an incident, they'll carry that with them in ways that alter their future behavior to their own detriment. The core difference is the betrayal of someone you trusted and respected: if you're harassed by someone on the street, you can shrug it off. If someone you respect tries to force you into a corner and plant their lips on you, you're going to freak out and wonder how many other people in power are secretly this way, and how you could possibly be so naive to think they weren't. That sort of betrayal can stay with you for years.

So it's not that your comment was mistaken, but rather the nature of your phrasing tends to exclude thoughtful replies from forming, combined with the fact that the topic itself is extremely controversial. It's very difficult to react well to someone who both blames the victim and sets up an argument as if their life experiences are representative of the norm. (But I totally agree with you that it was written in good faith! I was just trying to explain some of the reasons why it got flagged, not call you out on anything.)

One thing that helped me in this regard was to phrase my controversial ideas as questions. "Drunk people tend to do reckless things. Would it be a good idea to cut him some slack in this case?" is far more likely to generate thoughtful comments than "Drunk people do reckless things. I can't believe that we're not cutting him some slack."

Hope this helps clarify a bit. The overall point is that if you put a lot of conversational passion into your side of the argument, this typically causes the other side to give an equally passionate rebuttal. But that's just another name for a flamewar. That's why it's better to be dispassionate yet substantive.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by whiddershins on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @02:42AM (#14693999)
I think your feedback is great.

Also, I wasn't meaning to imply anyone should cut someone slack for behaving poorly while drunk. I was saying drunk people can be a menace, kinda like muggers. But although I've been mugged it doesn't exactly haunt me so much as make me cautious in certain situations. But whatever maybe my whole idea was stupid.

But why was my subsequent comment also flagged. And now I'm getting downvoted for pointing out that the user first flagging, and then commenting violates HN guidelines which clearly state not to do that. This feels completely out of control.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @03:17AM (#14694146)
I wouldn't read too much into it. When users see a flagged comment, they're more inclined to flag subsequent comments of the same tone. Saying that you didn't read half the reply didn't really help matters, plus it was very energetic overall. Energy tends to be met with energy in the opposite direction, which tends to spark flamewars.

In general though, it's better to email [email protected] with concerns about the site rather than comment about it. They're very responsive.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by whiddershins on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @03:52AM (#14694268)
I did email them, and I do appreciate your feedback. At this point my concern is understanding flagging criteria and your analysis of my tone was helpful.

This comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14693085

Was not in the same tone and was flagged. It was an overtly conciliatory comment. When that comment was flagged, followed by the flagging user ignoring guidelines, I stopped debating.

There's a problem here that goes beyond my comments per se.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by pvg on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @10:12AM (#14695971)
That comment was eminently flaggable for being unrelated meta-discussion - it's mostly about you, has nothing to do with the post and is bound to generate a pointless meta-thread. The guidelines and endless moderation comments specifically ask you not to do this.
Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by whiddershins on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @10:34AM (#14696083)
Fair enough.
Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by panic on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @04:04AM (#14694311)
FWIW, I didn't flag that particular comment (I "vouched" for it, in fact, as well as for your reply).
Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by whiddershins on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @10:30AM (#14696063)
This has been a massive miscommunication then.

When you wrote "that's why I flagged the comments" it didn't occur to me that you meant both the comments you were referring to: mine and khazhoux's.

Instead I misinterpreted that as both of my comments.

Which frustrated me because I felt my second comment was not similar to the first, and then I couldn't understand why you continued the discussion on a comment you had just flagged.

Now that I see what went on, I do appreciate you sharing your view as to why you flagged the first one and think it's basically all good from my pov.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by nikcub on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @01:13AM (#14693678)
edit: nevermind, its back on the frontpage

<commented that this story shouldn't be flagged off the front page>

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by dang on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @02:36AM (#14693975)
I don't think it was off the front page. Minor point, but people make so many sensitive comments to us about this kind of thing that it seems worth clarifying.
[dead]
Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by thaumaturgy on Monday July 03, 2017 @10:27PM (#14693070)
Trying to re-frame a discussion about the victimization of women to include offhand comments about men is not just off-topic but insensitive too. In the general case, you can't do that in any discussion where tensions are high without either doing it deftly and articulately or being quickly shouted down.
Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by ryandrake on Monday July 03, 2017 @10:29PM (#14693079)
Out of all the topics that come up from time to time on HN, this one is pretty much unique in that there is strictly one point of view acceptable to put forward, and every other one is guaranteed to get you instantly flag-killed under the guise of "wanting high quality discussion". If I valued my Internet Points, I'd just steer clear of these altogether and go click through to a React vs. Angular discussion instead.
Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by dang on Monday July 03, 2017 @11:33PM (#14693348)
That's not true at all, as anyone who skims through the last few days' threads on the topic can easily see.

The one thing that ideologically committed HN readers all seem to agree on is that the community is full of (and the mods secretly in league with) their enemies. If you were in my shoes I bet you'd find it as surreal as I do how consistently we get hit with this critique from all sides. The sincerity of these claims is similar in all cases, but obviously they can't all be right because their interpretations are opposite.

I don't think 'we must be doing things right if all sides are criticizing us like that'; that's a bad argument because the truth doesn't average out that way. I do think that perceptions of the HN community and moderation are dominated by cognitive bias in way that makes it hard to have a clear conversation, and also that this criticism will be made at approximately the same rate regardless of what we do.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by ryandrake on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @12:25AM (#14693536)
Hey, dang, I agree mods in any public forum have a thankless job, and there will always be people assuming you're part of whatever conspiracy they think exists to censor them--it goes with the territory. You guys do your best to keep this place troll-free, and because of that, HN seems to be, for most topics, one of the last bastions of civil discussions left on the net. I'm sure it's why a lot of us keep coming back, so thank you.

My point was, whenever you have that mix of 1. an emotionally charged topic, 2. strong, existing community norms, and 3. a public, linear (up + down = 0) voting/flagging system, you're bound to get the results we're seeing in this discussion: comments that reinforce the community's norms being promoted and comments that don't being demoted. This shouldn't surprise anyone who's been on the Internet for more than a few days. Reasonable people can debate the normal run-of-the-mill HN topics, but ones like these don't seem to have much room.

Anyway, I wasn't planning to continue this discussion, but since you provided a thoughtful reply I figured I owed an attempt to do the same.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by dang on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @02:01AM (#14693838)
That's a good analysis but somehow you (seem to?) end up at the wrong conclusion that the community has a single norm about this. What I see is a deeply divided community. The hopeful aspect (maybe) is that it's (perhaps) inching its way into more substantive discussion across those divides. That's a capacity the community has to build extremely slowly. The flagging phenomena that people are observing in recent threads are both a sign of this and integral to it.

There are exceptions, but most of the comments being flagged contain some element that is destructive of thoughtful conversation. Having those be marked as beyond the community's tolerance—and I mean 'tolerance' literally, as in, 'more than this will cause the nervous system to go into overwhelm'—is critical to de-escalating the remainder of the discussion enough that people can disagree without ceasing to hear each other.

The important thing to realize is that most flagged comments are not being flagged purely because of the point of view they express. In most cases they add a little extra something—or maybe a lot of extra something—and there are other, unflagged comments that express similar points of view, just more thoughtfully. In most cases, if the flagged commenter got calm enough to explain their point of view more neutrally, the odds of getting flagged would be less. (Inveterate trolling is also a thing, of course, but rarer.) They're welcome to do that and rejoin the land of the living at any time.

It does tend to require some work of self-reflection, though, to avoid getting flagged straightaway again. Most elements that result in flags are things the commenter was unaware of, but which land rather abrasively with the reader. The work is to develop some awareness of what those things are and then avoid them. For bonus points one can consciously replace them with something indicating respect for the opposing point of view or person. That can often be something quite small.

It is true that the ideological distribution of the flagged comments is skewed, but that's a separate question. And there are flagged and moderated comments on every side of the issue.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by Zikes on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @01:52AM (#14693812)
Maybe the flagging/downvoting system should be revisited, then. It seems like dissenting opinions are simply downvoted rather than challenged out in the open, as they should be. This means that discussions turn into a single-sided affair, as the other side simply flag kills their dissenters until only one opinion is visible.

I don't mind downvotes much, but it's hard to feel like I'm contributing to a worthwhile discussion if my responses are hidden and my ability to reply is removed.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by dang on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @02:00AM (#14693835)
I'm not sure what to tell you because we have such wildly differing perceptions. The threads I'm seeing have a lot of different points of view in them—fundamentally disparate points of view with tons of disagreement.
Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by Zikes on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @02:12AM (#14693873)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14693109 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14692712

These are entirely reasonable statements, and they're flagged. Not just downvoted, flagged. Censored. Removed from the discussion.

That's my only problem right now. I understand user comment flagging is useful in lieu of moderation, but I'm personally seeing myself silenced persistently in this discussion and it's extremely discouraging.

In at least one instance, I've even been told that directly challenging a sexist call to action is "off-topic" and "insensitive".

This is all happening on an article that is a direct result of sexism being repressed in the industry. Should I just wait a few years for the sexism to fester, then make a blog post of my own once the damage has already been done? Because that seems to be the only acceptable way to express myself here.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by dang on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @05:38PM (#14698467)
Ok, I've now had time to look at those comments and they're not 'entirely reasonable'; they contain elements that many people could reasonably object to and indeed flag as inflammatory.

To pick the most obvious, you use the word 'sexism' in a contentious way that is bound to land with many readers as trolling—and you didn't just do that once, you dropped it in numerous times. That's the sort of thing that leads to the feeling that the reasonable aspects of your comment are just a pretext, while the subtext is gratuitous provocation. I don't think you did that on purpose, but your claim that people were flagging 'entirely reasonable' comments arbitrarily is inaccurate. Just to be clear, my point isn't about the correct meaning of 'sexism'—it's that if you throw explosive footballs around, however unintentionally, your comment becomes subject to flagging for the sake of a non-flamewar discussion.

Many commenters are blind to the things in their comments that land objectionably with others. They're much (much!) too quick to conclude that the fault is all on the other side, that my 'entirely reasonable' comment is unjustly suppressed, and so on. If you want to get out of that loop you need to take a deeper, more reflective look at your own expressions. Then you can find ways to express your substantive point of view that aren't accidentally bound up with things that produce troll effects and you can participate in a (hopefully) higher-quality discussion.

As I mentioned upthread (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14693838) flagging provides an important service by making a distinction between gratuitously provocative comments and the ones that express similar points of view more thoughtfully. The actual effect in the threads is to make substantive discussion between opposing points of view possible, because otherwise the flamebait would be overwhelming. Indeed it has been so impossible in the past that it's rather astonishing to see it beginning to happen, i.e. people beginning to hear each other and offer at least tentative respect across division lines. That would definitely not be happening if the more inflammatory comments weren't being flagged.

Re:Shedding Light on the “Black Box of Inappropriateness” by grey-area on Tuesday July 04, 2017 @04:47AM (#14694490)
I'll second dang in saying this is not true (thanks dang for the moderation by the way, it really does help, even if no-one agrees with every decision). Here's an example of a viewpoint you probably think of as part of the orthodoxy being voted down and flagged:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14677258

There definitely is not only one viewpoint allowed on these threads, with others flagged or voted down.

The threads attract more flagging and up/down voting wars than usual, but the votes are not all one way, and frankly if anything I think the comments on HN on these threads are pretty male dominated and hostile to the women concerned, plenty of those comments are allowed to stand.