News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by lawless123 on Monday July 03, 2017 @05:30AM (#14686993)
>When our uncertainty is properly accounted for in the model, we find a substantial a priori chance that there is no other intelligent life in our observable universe

:(

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by avian on Monday July 03, 2017 @06:51AM (#14687313)
But on the brighter side:

> Conclusion 2: the great filter is likely in the past

Is there an article to go with these slides? I'm somewhat competent with probability theory and I found it hard to follow with all the unmarked graphs and unexplained parameters.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by reubenswartz on Monday July 03, 2017 @09:16AM (#14687976)
I'd say "a great filter is likely in the past." There could be more than one...
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by DiThi on Monday July 03, 2017 @09:39AM (#14688130)
What's why it says it doesn't imply our safety. It's called _the_ great filter because affects pretty much any attempt of intelligent life, and not because it's the only one.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by reubenswartz on Monday July 03, 2017 @09:58AM (#14688262)
I agree with what you're saying, I've just never liked the naming convention. ;-) There are probably lots of great filters that we've passed through already, and I imagine there are lots more "in front" of us, if we are good and lucky.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by jerf on Monday July 03, 2017 @11:34AM (#14688988)
The reason it is called "the" great filter is similar to the sort of thinking that this PDF is attempting to debunk. If you optimistically assumed that the early Fermi terms are likely to be high, that therefore many civilizations must have gotten at least as far as ours, but there are still no aliens in the stars, then the logical conclusion is that there must be something standing between where we are now and galactic civilization, hence, the Great Filter.

If on the other hand the early terms are much lower than expected, as this PDF is discussing, then the sum total of them could be considered the "Great Filter" and we could be past it. It's fine to just lump them together from our point of view, since at the moment we don't have the data to figure out which gate is "really" the determinative one.

Wandering down my own thoughts here: The Copernican Principle, or perhaps better termed in modern parlance the Copernican Heuristic, that we are nothing particularly special, has had a good run. But it is just a heuristic, and one whose adherence has arguably been driven more by a science v. religion feud than logic or data, and whose underlying logic in the past 50ish years has metastasized into "Some religious people I don't like think Man is unique, they're wrong about everything, therefore Man is not unique in any way." But lately the Copernican Heuristic has been showing a lot of strain. Our solar system may not be unique, but it is increasingly looking like it may indeed be unusual, for instance. The Rare Earth arguments have never gone away and I think a lot of the dismissal of that idea has also come from "Religious people like the idea of the Rare Earth and some of them are arguing for it, religious people are wrong about everything, therefore Earth is not rare." [1], because scientifically they look as good as anything else on the subject (namely "those arguments seem to fit our lack of data as well as anything else", which is a pretty weak endorsement). And per the PDF under discussion, a lot of the universe really starts to make more sense when you start to seriously consider the possibility that, yes, we may in fact be very unusual, if not perhaps truly unique.

[1]: Those are not the only arguments here, nor are they the best; I'm just saying that it is my subjective sense that the debate over the past few decades has often been very skewed by the underlying presence of this argument, even when not necessarily spoken. It is my perception that this debate has often been had under unspoken ground rules where all the discussion must occur in such a way as to ensure that the religious people are unable to point to anything as evidence for their side. It... doesn't make for the best conditions to do science under.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by worldsayshi on Monday July 03, 2017 @09:38AM (#14688127)
> The stars just don’t foretell our doom
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by dbdr on Monday July 03, 2017 @01:04PM (#14689763)
The unexplained parameters are the factors of the Drake equation:

The number of civilizations, N, is assumed to be equal to the mathematical product of

  - the average rate of star formation, R∗, in our galaxy,
  - the fraction of formed stars, *fp*, that have planets,
  - for stars that have planets, the average number of planets *ne* that can potentially support life,
  - the fraction of those planets, *fl*, that actually develop life,
  - the fraction of planets bearing life on which intelligent, civilized life, *fi*, has developed,
  - the fraction of these civilizations that have developed communications, *fc*, i.e., technologies that release detectable signs into space, and
  - the length of time, *L*, over which such civilizations release detectable signals.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drake_equation
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by chicob on Monday July 03, 2017 @08:03AM (#14687621)
If you find one, can you please put the link here?
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by gjm11 on Monday July 03, 2017 @08:15AM (#14687686)
My understanding is that the people behind this work are writing a paper on it, which when done will presumably make everything much more explicit than the slides do.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by kaj_sotala on Thursday July 06, 2017 @06:23AM (#14709294)
Yeah, their institute just put out a quarterly update a few days ago: https://www.fhi.ox.ac.uk/quarterly-update-summer-2017/ . It mentions their previous Fermi Paradox paper, "That is not dead which can eternal lie: the aestivation hypothesis for resolving Fermi’s paradox" ( https://arxiv.org/abs/1705.03394 ), and also a "future paper" that sounds like this one:

> Anders Sandberg, Stuart Armstrong, and their co-author Milan Cirkovic published a paper outlining a potential strategy for advanced civilizations to postpone computation until the universe is much colder, and thereby producing up to a 10^30 multiplier of achievable computation. This might explain the Fermi paradox, although a future paper from FHI suggests there may be no paradox to explain.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by Avshalom on Monday July 03, 2017 @10:18AM (#14688405)
Note however they also say that there is only one intelligent species in the history of earth.

Now lumpers v splitters aside there are plenty of tool using, problem solving, communicating species on the planet right now. And they cover the spread too: Octopuses, apes, birds; ants individually are of course dumb as a brick but colonies have actually invented agriculture.

Yeah, ants probably will never make it into space and birds lack fine dexterity to build a rocket ship even if there is a parrot Newton/Ramanajun but that doesn't mean we won't find something to have a conversation with if we can go to them.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by mikeash on Monday July 03, 2017 @11:20AM (#14688869)
I think in this case "intelligent" is used as a shorthand for "capable of creating a technological civilization capable of colonizing the stars." Smart birds which can't build spaceships are intelligent the way we normally consider the word, but not "intelligent" for the purposes of the Fermi Paradox.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by Avshalom on Monday July 03, 2017 @12:53PM (#14689679)
I mean it doesn't really matter because you just end up balancing one against the other but the wikipedia form of the drake equation and the slides form both use

    fi = the fraction of planets with life that actually go on to develop intelligent life (civilizations)

    fc = the fraction of civilizations that develop a technology that releases detectable signs of their existence into space
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by iamcurious on Monday July 03, 2017 @02:36PM (#14690422)
>I think in this case "intelligent" is used as a shorthand for "capable of creating a technological civilization capable of colonizing the stars."

Then humanity has a long way to go before proving its intelligence.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by atemerev on Monday July 03, 2017 @07:59AM (#14687602)
While Bayesian models are reasonably good in estimating such chances (and be dramatically reverted with new contradicting observations), they can't tell us the exact reason why such arrangement exists.

Which is the core of Fermi paradox, and therefore it still stands.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by honestoHeminway on Monday July 03, 2017 @08:35AM (#14687784)
My personal guess is that complex live needs a long time to develop and also stable conditions during this long time- which basically rules out a lot of systems with sporadic, subtile deathbringers. That plus a vicious streak to evolution, allowing for developing of fast counter measures to any sentient species. (Any bird, carrying the plague, would have the world to itself.) might account for alot of the silence.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by nabla9 on Monday July 03, 2017 @10:32AM (#14688492)
> • Note that this conclusion does not mean we are alone! Just that we should not be surprised if this is the case. This is a statement about knowledge and priors, not a measurement armchair astrobiology
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by spookyuser on Monday July 03, 2017 @10:30AM (#14688476)
After reading The Dark Forest last year I almost hope this is true.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by sullyj3 on Monday July 03, 2017 @10:51AM (#14688617)
We'll just have to create it ourselves.
Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by wuch on Monday July 03, 2017 @11:10AM (#14688792)
Maybe we shouldn't? Thomas Metzinger on the ethical aspect of conscious AI:

What would you say if someone came along and said, “Hey, we want to genetically engineer mentally retarded human infants! For reasons of scientific progress we need infants with certain cognitive and emotional deficits in order to study their postnatal psychological development - we urgently need some funding for this important and innovative kind of research!“ You would certainly think this was not only an absurd and appalling but also a dangerous idea. It would hopefully not pass any ethics committee in the democratic world. However, what today’s ethics committees don’t see is how the first machines satisfying a minimally sufficient set of constraints for conscious experience could be just like such mentally retarded infants. They would suffer from all kinds of functional and representational deficits too. But they would now also subjectively experience those deficits. In addition, they would have no political lobby - no representatives in any ethics committee.

If they had a transparent world-model embedded in a virtual window of presence, then a reality would appear to them. They would be minimally conscious. If, as advanced robots, they even had a stable bodily self-model, then they could feel sensory pain as their own pain, including all the consequences resulting from bad human engineering. But particularly if their postbiotic PSM (phenomenal self-model) were actually anchored in biological hardware, things might be much worse. If they had an emotional self-model, then they could truly suffer - possibly even in degrees of intensity or qualitative richness that we as their creators cannot imagine, because it is entirely alien to us. If, in addition, they possessed a cognitive self-model, they could potentially not only conceive of their bizarre situation but also intellectually suffer from the fact that they never had anything like the “dignity” so important to their creators. They might be able to consciously represent the obvious fact that they are only second-rate subjects, used as exchangeable experimental tools by some other type of self-modeling system, which obviously doesn’t know what it is doing and which must have lost control of its own actions long ago. Can you imagine what it would be like to be such a mentally retarded phenomenal clone of the first generation? Alternatively, can you imagine what it would be like to “come to” as a more advanced artificial subject, only to discover that, although possessing a distinct sense of self, you are just a commodity, a scientific tool never created and certainly not to be treated as an end in itself?

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by jerf on Monday July 03, 2017 @11:37AM (#14689017)
That may well be the most aggressively anthropomorphized argument I've ever seen, believing that the only possible solution to the problem of artificial intelligence is exactly and precisely the space of human consciousness.

If that argument is taken seriously then it should already be starting to apply to things like the Google spam filter, but once you take it out of the space of hypothetical possibilities like that and apply it to real code it becomes obviously absurd. There is less than no reason to believe that the only possible artificial intelligence will be simply humans that live in machines and have all their needs and desires, and even such AIs that are nascent in the world today already have grotesquely different architectures than that, with little reason to believe making our spam filters or car navigation systems "more human" in the existential sense would even remotely improve them. Why would my car's navigation system even need to be able to represent "a sadness that I'm just a car navigational system instead of a Real Boy", let alone actually manifest it?

By far the greater risk in that world is the economy/universe optimizing out everything that makes humans human until the entire universe is simply a highly efficient philosophical zombie, rather than the risk that every last subsystem of everything in the world is secretly going to be a human-class homunculus trapped in some boring task.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by keithwhor on Monday July 03, 2017 @01:56PM (#14690151)
> By far the greater risk in that world is the economy/universe optimizing out everything that makes humans human until the entire universe is simply a highly efficient philosophical zombie, rather than the risk that every last subsystem of everything in the world is secretly going to be a human-class homunculus trapped in some boring task.

This, to me, is a greater risk than "evil AI." If humanity does cease to exist, it will be a slow, painless, barely observable extinction (perhaps even paraded as ascension) as we integrate with and are then replaced by the technology we've created.

I don't think this is entirely realistic, just because there's an anthropocentric bias in me that believes that humans are wonderfully useful and robust self-replicating machines, and that economically we're (1) fairly energy efficient and (2) valuable to "throw at problems" we don't want to mass produce specific silicon-based solutions to.

But I did want to thank you for pointing this out. I do think it's wonderfully naive we often ascribe human characteristics and fallacies to hypothetical general AI that we experiment with or build, as though distinctly human consciousness is somehow the epitome of achievement. It's not even in our best interest, economically or ethically, to strive for that.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by wuch on Monday July 03, 2017 @04:12PM (#14691043)
Metzinger is not against creation of AI in general, but against creation of conscious AI. The argument is indeed very anthropomorphic, though this may be useful to avoid human tendency to deny machines even a possibility of having a conscious experience. If anything, I would be more critical of its appeal to emotion than anthropomorphism.

Argument about conscious Google spam is quite unfair and unwarranted. In fact, if you actually consider what Metzinger has to say about necessary conditions for consciousness (for example in "Being No One" or "The Ego Tunnel"), then obviously Google spam is nothing like that.

Either way it seems to me that it may be better to err on the side of not making conscious AI in the first place rather than unintentionally making one with capacity to suffer. Especially that it may be non-obvious that it has capacity to experience pain. For example, we have already made this mistake by using curare alone as an anesthetic - presuming that a lack of automatic pain response, and ability to communicate feeling of pain means that one doesn't feel pain. That was a considerable misjudgment.

Re:Dissolving the Fermi Paradox [pdf] by titzer on Monday July 03, 2017 @11:21AM (#14688881)
In other words, we are torturing our computers and every time they inch close to consciousness, it hurts so bad they commit suicide. SIGSEGV. bam.