This isn't about big evil government encroaching on property rights. It's keeping land that was already public land public. If you owned a house and I bought up all the property around your house and then put a gate across and locked your driveway, you'd still own and have legal access to your house. That's what Kholsa is trying to do.
Did you read the article? It is not his property, it is public access to a public beach. He deserves compensation for losing in court and continue to break the law with which the court upheld? I'm confused, did we read the same article?
If it was clear cut, why is the Chief of Enforcement accommodating alternatives?
She's not trying to crush him. Her goal is to provide access to the beach--which these solutions would. It would obviously be great if he just went along with the legal requirements, but moving the road or getting a non-profit to operate a gate is better than a protracted court battle, and it wouldn't hurt if everyone ended up happy at the end.
So it also shows that in the end, even billionaires need to follow the law; and that its probably a better use of their time to work with the commission to find a good solution, instead of to fight the law.
Because the Commission has finite resources and devoting them to dealing with a billionaire that's devoted to tying up the legal system as long as possible isn't efficient use of them if a compromise can be reached at far less cost in litigation and the remaining resources directed to other priorities.
Everything about this he has brought upon himself.
If someone took you (or the new owner) to court to re-open the gate, you'd probably lose.
[1] http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/easements-overview.ht...
Original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/2o3g9g/neighbo... First update: https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/2ooy1x/update_... Final update: https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/4dci57/update_...
I was raging reading this /r/legaladvice saga. That's just an incredibly great story about a chunk of land. Thanks for linking to it!
https://www.kcet.org/history-society/why-californias-beaches...
Sorry, despite your repeated assertions to the contrary in this thread: california laws on beach access are incredibly clear.
When I was a child, my church owned a plot of land across the street from the main building. The land was vacant, and students from a nearby college used to cut across it to get to class. Once a year, church members would stand at the corners of the property to bar access to the pedestrians - so that the church could maintain that it had not ceded access to the path, in the event that the church wanted to make use of the lot at a later date.
There's no one being attacked here. No one's being objectionally rude. It's just an exchange of ideas and viewpoints. Let those be.
Also – since these are just opinions, they are worth equally much. The truth isn't something you or anyone else owns. And what do you mean, 'deserves.'
This isn't trolling. This person is arguing, is what I think. Arguing civilly which is what this is, should be possible out here in the boonies (whith which I mean HN, in the most amical way).
If a "civil" argument is designed to mislead and intended to make the conversation incomprehensible, can it be anything other than a troll? This is a trolling tactic and has been forever. Look up "forum sliding", for another fun explanation of one of the tactics hyperliner is using.
Wrong. Not all opinions are worth the same. An opinion that runs contrary to established case law, for instance, is worth almost nothing.
"This isn't trolling."
Considering they've posted the same thing over and over again, it's pretty clear there was trolling.