News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I might be a complete failure (after 8 years of work) by dmfdmf on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:46PM (#1466431)
I agree. Disparaging speculation as "zero-sum" and therefore inherently bad is non-sense. In almost all mature industries such as grocery stores, auto sales, lumber, appliances, etc., any individual seller's gain is some other seller's loss. So what? They are providing a valuable service and if profitable in the long-run are doing so at lowest cost, highest value to their customers.

Financial speculation has a long history of being disparaged by various anti-capitalist demagogues. Speculation is a zero-sum activity between speculators but, from an economy-wide perspective, speculators nevertheless perform a valuable function in the dissemination of new information and the formation of prices. This latter function is why it is so hard -- the identification of an arbitrage opportunity and acting in the markets to make profits means that price differentials fade away and thus the potential for profits. A speculator has to continually find new opportunities in order to make money over the long term.

Re:I might be a complete failure (after 8 years of work) by jeromec on Sunday June 27, 2010 @07:37PM (#1466527)
> Speculation is a zero-sum activity between speculators

I agree.

> any individual seller's gain is some other seller's loss

I disagree. A farmer can sell to a grocer and both can gain.

Re:I might be a complete failure (after 8 years of work) by chc on Sunday June 27, 2010 @08:49PM (#1466652)
I think you don't disagree. The grocer is not in a seller in the same ecosystem as the farmer. The grocer is one of the external people who benefits from the zero-sum game the farmers are playing.
Re:I might be a complete failure (after 8 years of work) by wooster on Monday June 28, 2010 @03:17AM (#1467329)
Farming is pretty much the opposite of a zero sum game.
Re:I might be a complete failure (after 8 years of work) by chc on Monday June 28, 2010 @01:06PM (#1468547)
The growing part isn't, but the selling part can be seen that way in the right conditions. I agree, though, it isn't the example I would have chosen.
Re:I might be a complete failure (after 8 years of work) by shasta on Sunday June 27, 2010 @10:56PM (#1466899)
> any individual seller's gain is some other seller's loss.

How do you figure? Generally, the way one seller beats out another is by providing some combination of increased value or decreased cost.

Re:I might be a complete failure (after 8 years of work) by dmfdmf on Monday June 28, 2010 @03:44PM (#1469182)
In a mature market sellers are competing for a fixed number of customers. For example, a grocery store that wants to increase sales (above local population growth) must "steal" customers from its competitors. So my gain of a customer constitutes your loss of a customer, i.e. zero sum. Sellers achieve this (take customers from competitors) by offering higher value and/or decreased costs as I also mentioned.