News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by borisk on Sunday June 27, 2010 @05:55PM (#1466326)
Does it really matter? Most people can believe in witches, intelligent design and what not while doing their jobs good enough. Europe, Far East, Russia trust science way more, but it doesn't seem to lead to any significant advantage.
Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by MichaelSalib on Sunday June 27, 2010 @07:18PM (#1466499)
Do you believe that there are public policy questions whose answers depend on science AND are very important? If so, then it should matter a very great deal.

In other words, if you're the kind of person who believes that either climate change is no big deal or that there is nothing that humans can do about it, then it doesn't matter at all. Alternatively, if you think climate change is a big deal and that humans can do something about it, then public understanding of science matters because altering it might kill/save a few hundred million people. Do you think the lives of a few hundred million human beings matter?

Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by derefr on Sunday June 27, 2010 @09:18PM (#1466727)
If there's something everyone needs to do, no amount of education will saturate the population to the point that everyone required to do it, does it. Some people just don't care outside of the here and now, unless they're made to care with a carrot or a stick. You need to have a law either punishing them for not doing it, or rewarding them for doing it (i.e. carbon-neutral business tax credits) for them to pay attention. (And even then, some people still won't care, or will willfully skirt the law. Hopefully this number will be negligible enough to allow the law to still have its intended effect.)

Don't think of it as a big, scary, nebulous concept like "justice", though. Call it what it is: game design. The body of law is the game that every citizen of a country is always playing, and like any game, you can encourage paths to be followed, and choices to be made, by putting variable-scheduled rewards and increasing "justified" challenges along those paths.

The only people who need to understand the "public policy questions", in a world where public policy is set up as law, are the legislators (the "game designers"). This is simply an argument for better-educated legislators, not a better-educated populace.

Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by MichaelSalib on Sunday June 27, 2010 @09:31PM (#1466755)
I don't think this is something that "everyone needs to do"...I mean, there will always be substantial numbers of people who believe the earth is flat, the stars control our destinies, etc. Talk of reaching everyone seems like a distraction.

The real issue is that if 30-60% of the population thinks climate change is bunk, there's no way to make them care with carrots and sticks because opposing them becomes politically difficult.

The only people who need to understand the "public policy questions", in a world where public policy is set up as law, are the legislators (the "game designers"). This is simply an argument for better-educated legislators, not a better-educated populace.

I don't think this is true at all. Legislators do not have absolute freedom to legislate, even on topics for which the public is ignorant. Such topics can be demagogued which means that they're politically toxic to legislators, even for legislators that understand the issues completely.

If I'm a legislator who is convinced that climate change is a huge problem but I also know that most of my constituents don't believe that, then I'd better not vote for a carbon tax or else I'll lose the next election. Those incentives remain true no matter how much I understand the public policy. It is true that we don't need everyone to fully understand all public policy, but we do need a decent fraction of the population to understand the big issues well enough to make addressing them politically feasible.

Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by anthonyb on Sunday June 27, 2010 @09:29PM (#1466752)
Except that we live in a democracy, where people vote for the legislators who they think will do the better job. When the populace believe in stupid things, you'll get legislators who pander to that, while ignoring the important stuff.
Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by derefr on Sunday June 27, 2010 @09:37PM (#1466771)
Sort of. We don't vote for legislators based on their beliefs or knowledge-bases, we vote for legislators based on a combination of status moves, group affiliations, and physical characteristics that have more in common with mate selection than anything else. What legislators pander to while looking to get elected, has little to do with what laws they end up actually passing.

There's no real correlation between what the populace believes, and what its elected representatives believe. (Well, there would be if we were all purely rational beings who hadn't invented lying and adhered to Aumann's agreement theorem...) In algorithmic terms—this isn't a hill-climbing heuristic, where you'll eventually optimize toward politicians that believe something in particular; it's a random search.

Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by anthonyb on Sunday June 27, 2010 @09:43PM (#1466788)
Not true. Here in Australia, our Prime Minister just got the boot, in part because he backed down over an emissions trading scheme and lost popular support. So it's not entirely random, although there's also internal power-broking and lobbying from third parties like the mining sector to blame.
Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by MichaelSalib on Sunday June 27, 2010 @09:56PM (#1466804)
There's no real correlation between what the populace believes, and what its elected representatives believe.

Maybe, maybe not. But there is a very real correlation between what the populace believes and what laws legislators can vote for without ruining their chances for reelection. Legislators who vote for things that the majority of their constituents find to be completely absurd tend not to be reelected.

Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by alanh on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:47PM (#1466437)
For one: Scientific illiteracy → Biblical literalism & religious fundamentalism → Prop 8, the Texas school board, citizens voting as proxies for religious leaders

Relevant to the article, herd immunity is compromised by those misinformed about vaccine safety.

Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by sidww2 on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:10PM (#1466355)
I'm not so sure. If we are talking about the advantage in terms of the advantage in enhancing scientific knowledge, then certainly things have changed since WWII but pre-WWII, if my knowledge of history is correct, the majority of advances in theoretical science and mathematics happened in Europe. Even today a large number of scientists working in America are foreign-born. Now I don't know how much people trusted science and the scientific consensus in Europe vs America back then but I wouldn't be surprised if Europe was more progressive back then either.
Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by jswinghammer on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:14PM (#1466363)
Couldn't agree more.

I've never really understood why anyone cares about who believes what when it comes to topics in science. You can't advance in a career in the sciences without accepting on some terms evolution by means of natural selection so who cares if a bunch of people don't agree?

I'm sort of amazed at the arrogance on display by those who seem bent on making sure everyone agrees with them. It seems like we would be served well by some degree of skepticism of the bishops and the scientific establishment (in all areas). It seems like the more we know the more we lose sight of what we still don't know and don't proceed with much humility.

For my part I'm skeptical of the claims of biologists, mainstream economists, climatologists, and those who offer financial advice. I don't take a strong position on evolution one way or another because the outcome doesn't affect me in any way. I might get made fun of behind my back for doubting these people but that's fine by me.

I also didn't take any losses in the latest stock market crash because I saw it coming three years ahead of time and was safely in cash waiting for the market to figure out what I already knew. I take strong positions on economics because the outcome can really affect me and my family. I might be wrong of course but at least I'm going in with my eyes open.

Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by ewjordan on Sunday June 27, 2010 @07:35PM (#1466525)
I don't take a strong position on evolution one way or another because the outcome doesn't affect me in any way.

You're just fine with having the next generation of schoolkids taught that "God Did It (or maybe aliens)" is the only acceptable explanation for the origin of life, then? Because this fight started with religious zealots trying to prosecute teachers for going against scripture, and it's hard to have any doubt that the clowns pushing Intelligent Design would do something similar if people stopped smacking them down. It might not matter to you whether evolution is right or not, but that's not what the fight is about - the fight is about whether or not scientists should have to poll the idiocracy and make sure they won't offend them before reporting their findings.

And yes, I'm arguing slippery slope, maybe - but the argument in favor of worry is a lot more compelling when we've just finished clawing our way up from the bottom.

It seems like the more we know the more we lose sight of what we still don't know and don't proceed with much humility.

Absolutely. And with climate science, I'd tend to agree with you, we don't know all that much and might want to be careful about how much we trust the preliminary findings - the data appears to be messy, incomplete, and difficult to work with, and the field started out so highly politicized that it's hard to know who to trust.

Evolution, on the other hand, is not even in the same ballpark - evidence is plentiful, it all agrees with the theory, and consensus is overwhelming (and one big difference between bio and climate science is that biologists don't tend to go into biology because of political leanings, so there's far less selection bias amongst researchers).

Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by jswinghammer on Sunday June 27, 2010 @09:58PM (#1466807)
I think that I am fine with that because I'm not sure it matters. The truth is the truth and it has a nasty habit of winning out even if it takes hundreds of years. Theories and ideas go into and out of favor over time. The battle between rationalism and empiricism has raged basically nonstop since Aristotle and continues today with each side gaining and losing ground with each generation of thinkers.

I'm amazed by the continuing influence of Marx and other socialist philosophers even though we have theories rooted in Platonic arguments and empirical observation that are fairly one sided in their analysis of the subject. It disturbs me greatly that schools teach Keynesian economics and that Paul Krugman has more distribution than what a blog would provide him. I'm disturbed by the success of the Neocons and their apparent love for war.

All that being said I move on with my life. I realize that the best I can is argue my case and if I fail then that's fine. Ideas aren't as important as life and the people in it.

Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by FlemishBeeCycle on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:48PM (#1466439)
I don't think this is arrogance, no one is lacking in humility and skepticism. It is more a matter that any and every claim need not be treated with the same sort of gravity as a rigorously investigated subject. The scientists in question are most likely dismissive of people purposefully ignoring evidence that does not fit into their world/political views rather than view points rooted in scientific data.

It is absolutely important to care what others' think when it comes to topics in science. We live in a society, and others' views and ideas unfortunately will most likely impact people other than themselves. People are free to be as ignorant as they want in isolation, but the moment they start affecting policy, we should care.

Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by Jach on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:36PM (#1466411)
Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by jswinghammer on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:45PM (#1466427)
Seems like the argument here is that because this person can't mind his own business I need to hear about it. Not sure about anyone else but my life is complicated enough without me taking on the problems of other people who aren't asking for my help in the first place.
Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by blahedo on Sunday June 27, 2010 @06:47PM (#1466436)
> You can't advance in a career in the sciences without accepting on some terms evolution by means of natural selection so who cares if a bunch of people don't agree?

Because we're afraid that that could change.

Re:If scientists want to educate the public, they should sta... by nzmsv on Sunday June 27, 2010 @08:45PM (#1466643)
> Europe, Far East, Russia trust science way more

They do?