Giving engineers free peanuts (so they don't walk out of the building to by some) is hardly a perk.
Which hospital / medical systems give great perks to doctors ?
There are plenty of sectors that have nice offices with snacks and drinks, by the way.
It's always better to invest in growth than to fake it by shaving the budget. When human niceties start getting pared away, it's a sign that growth opportunities aren't working out.
Free drinks are incredibly cheap compared to buying the same results through paying higher salaries. Losing them is a sign that the company cares more about fitting into the herd than being effective, which has to be a bad sign.
Bear in mind that, most programmers do not get paid overtime, and are expected to work like horses. The reason freebies are sacred rights are because those are, in part, the unofficial payment for working in such conditions.
For what is worth I'm in Japan so YMMV but I think this generally applies anywhere: if you switch from overtime-exempt to a hourly contract and keep working the same hours, your base monthly salary + overtime pay will be (in average) the same as your current salary.
The catch is "in average". Most corps will avoid having you do overtime if they have to pay extra for it, and conversely will try to switch off-hours support work to salaried employees. So you might end up working less hours and earning less as a contractor -- and sometimes that's what you want anyway. In other cases workers manage to game the system; in some orgs I know the contractors work longer hours than most non-manager salaried employees.
I think this is a very different statement than "it doesn't have to be a bad sign". Leaving aside the question other people addressed of whether freebies are good business, the fact of the matter is that they're currently commonplace. If a company gets rid of those benefits without a clear trigger (like an acquisition by someone more corporate, or C-level turnover), the question to ask is why?
Is it likely that the executives who previously offered freebies attended a leadership seminar and decided it would be more professional to take them away? Or is it more likely that the trajectory is bad, and snacks looked like a responsible first target for budget cuts?
The question here isn't "what's a responsible first cut for a struggling company?" On that point, I agree, cutting snacks before staff is probably a sensible business decision. The question is "what's a warning sign that the company is struggling and you don't know it?" I think empirically, cutting freebies without a clear cause is definitely a sign of poor health.
When you step back and analyze the business mechanics, which is to say your cost to run the business versus the revenue that business generates, in terms of personnel cost from most to least expensive is 'salary + overtime', 'salary + snacks', 'salary'. In many ways snacks are the 'open plan' equivalent of cost management.
That said, I don't think there is ever 'one thing' that says "Hmm, we might be dying." often it is a combination of things. From a startup perspective founders leaving (especially if they are replaced by someone completely out of the blue), delays on new projects, failing to replace people who have left and were doing good work. All good signs.
He said it is absurd how cheap you can buy employee loyalty with free snacks and soda.
Even at a 100 person company, they were spending ~$600 / week on snacks but when you factored in that developers cost $30+ / hr alone, you are buying time for such a low price.
You are literally giving a developer $2 for $15+ of their time. That is even discounting the price of keeping them in the same brain space and some possible cross-team germination.
Employee discounts in retail are usually within company margins for sales and they are limited (e.g. $1,000 purchases per year or so). If the margin doesn't cover these discounts or the system is abused they will get reduced/removed. Likewise, if a startup thinks these $100 per month are better spent elsewhere perhaps they are just being financially responsible.
I don't think removing or reducing these benefits is a sign of poor health. I think it's more a sign of turning into a proper business (which needs to answer to the people who put the money to buy all these drinks in the first place), which isn't for everyone, but it doesn't _have_ to be a bad sign.
I do agree with the second part. The attrition rate is definitely something to keep tabs on, but it's important to know why people are leaving.