News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by thephyber on Monday June 26, 2017 @07:56PM (#14641446)
While it doesn't sound like a bad proposal and could probably get a strong majority of votes in some alternate dimension, the party in power will never allow this to make it to the floor of the House for a vote.[1]

The more cynical I become, the more I think the party in power doesn't actually want to solve any problems, they only want to focus on wedge issues to ensure they can use {rage, fear, some other emotion} to keep their party constituents engaged enough to vote but not enough to hold their feet to the fire on getting things done. Incumbents in Congress still have 95%+ re-election rates and in 2010 when those rates dipped, Congress was remarkably less productive than usual.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hastert_Rule

Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by dvt on Monday June 26, 2017 @08:13PM (#14641522)
> the party in power will never allow this to make it to the floor of the House for a vote

The implication here is that the Democrats don't gerrymander. This is patently false. The Democrats are just pissed that the Republicans did a massively better job at it in the past decade.

In many ways, it was an arms race, and the Democrats chose not to focus on small and local districts and elections (instead, worrying about the "big picture"). As it turns out, politics trickles up, and small wins for Republicans eventually turned into big wins. To see a perfect exemplar of this, just look at Jon Ossoff's crushing loss last week.

There's an excellent NPR podcast about this very issue I listened to a few years ago.

Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by anarazel on Monday June 26, 2017 @10:56PM (#14642250)
> > > the party in power will never allow this to make it to the floor of the House for a vote

> The implication here is that the Democrats don't gerrymander. This is patently false.

I don't think that's really the implication. At the moment it is pretty clear that the GOP currently overall benefits more from gerrymandering [1]. And they are in power, despite having lost the popular vote [2]. The GOP has control over the WH and both chambers, it'd therefore be political suicide to change the system now in a way that'd hurt them.

> The Democrats are just pissed that the Republicans did a massively better job at it in the past decade.

They've obviously also gerrymandered, I fail to see what that has to do with OPs point? Are you really arguing that to be able to be against the concept of gerrymandering, you've to give up any chance of ever actually being able to do anything about it?

[1]: https://www.apnews.com/fa6478e10cda4e9cbd75380e705bd380 [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_presidential_ele...

Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by dvt on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @12:29AM (#14642584)
> Are you really arguing that to be able to be against the concept of gerrymandering, you've to give up any chance of ever actually being able to do anything about it?

Not really. I'm arguing that most (in all honesty, probably all) gerrymandering complaints by Democrats are sour grapes because they got outplayed. In fact, Delaney himself was "first elected in a gerrymandered district created specifically for him," according to @mobilefriendly's linked sources.

Gerrymandering is generally not that big of a deal and cracking down on it doesn't solve much, as populations are naturally segmented[1]. I will say that sometimes, gerrymandering is racially- or religiously-motivated (SCOTUS heard a case on this a few months ago IIRC), so it can be very problematic in a few edge cases.

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/12/01/ca...

Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by shitlord on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @12:36AM (#14642611)
> Gerrymandering is honestly not that big of a deal and cracking down on it doesn't solve much, as populations are naturally segmented[1].

Please provide more evidence for this claim. Just because it's true in CA doesn't necessarily mean it's true for the rest of the country.

Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by anarazel on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @12:48AM (#14642652)
> In fact, Delaney himself was "first elected in a gerrymandered district created specifically for him," according to @mobilefriendly's linked sources.

I fail to see how that's an argument for anything. Unless maybe, if you want to argue that Delaney is voting against his personal interest.

> Gerrymandering is generally not that big of a deal and cracking down on it doesn't solve much, as populations are naturally segmented[1]. > [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/12/01/ca....

That primarily seems to be an argument for it not being that a huge issue in CA. Or maybe that the mechanisms for redistricting weren't great in CA.

Given that a significant numbers of states have houses with significantly different party percentages than the popular vote suggests, this is a hard to understand argument.

Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by seanmcdirmid on Monday June 26, 2017 @09:55PM (#14641999)
California, New Jersey, and Washington state, big demotractic states, don't gerrymander by state law. California is a big state, and when they moved to a non partisan commission, the republicans picked up a few seats.

The only red states to also do this are Arizona and Idaho.

Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by devwastaken on Monday June 26, 2017 @08:16PM (#14641540)
I think they meant any party in power won't allow it, because partly how they get in power, is gerrymandering.
Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by noobermin on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @03:02AM (#14643040)
There's some merit to this. Chances are the democratic leadership won't let this through. Doesn't hurt to try though.
Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by jccalhoun on Monday June 26, 2017 @09:11PM (#14641809)
The party is power is whichever party happens to have more votes at any given time. Whoever is in power won't change it because it got them elected so why would they risk doing something that might take them out of power?
Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by anarazel on Monday June 26, 2017 @11:05PM (#14642281)
> The party is power is whichever party happens to have more votes at any given time.

That's really not true in the political system of the US, even without partisan gerrymandering. Given that the entire point of partisan gerrymandering is to enlarge the distance between popular vote and gained seats, I'm not sure what you're trying to say?

> Whoever is in power won't change it because it got them elected so why would they risk doing something that might take them out of power?

You can win the electoral college / house / senate / whatever, despite being disadvantaged via gerrymandering (arguably e.g. the case for Obama in 2012). So that's not generally true.

Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by lsaferite on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @08:43AM (#14644829)
> You can win the electoral college / house / senate / whatever, despite being disadvantaged via gerrymandering

Of course you can always still overcome gerrymandering with enough political momentum. Gerrymandering currently tips the scales slightly in the direction of one party or another. Fixing gerrymandering would level the playing field (in theory).

Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by tptacek on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @02:04PM (#14647694)
I liked every part of this comment up to "Jon Ossoff's crushing loss", which is crazymaking.

Unless I'm missing something very important, Ossoff was competing for a district that hadn't gone to a Republican by less than 20 points in the entire history of the district (it was redistricted sometime around ~2000).

Ossoff --- who is not a great candidate! --- took one of the most solidly Republican suburban districts in the country and turned it into a real horse race. What am I supposed to learn from that about Democratic strategic weakness?

Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by dvt on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @10:52PM (#14651376)
The fact that the Democrats outspent the Republicans by a factor of 7[1] and still lost. But that's exactly my point: the Democrats tried to manufacture a candidate in a time of dire need instead of first going for school boards, local municipalities, etc.

For what it's worth, Handel was a pretty terrible candidate too. Just goes to show how weak the Democratic strategists are. Obama won because he was an excellent candidate. Here's a novel idea for Democrats: get more awesome people to run for office.

[1] http://politics.blog.ajc.com/2017/06/19/the-race-for-georgia...

Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by tptacek on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @12:14AM (#14651639)
Read the story carefully. It's not a factor of 7, or even close to that. A larger proportion of Handel's support came from outside the campaign.
Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by afpx on Monday June 26, 2017 @10:54PM (#14642239)
Assuming the parent post hasn't been edited, it doesn't seem to say what you suggest it does (at least not by my reading).

So, before we succumb to knee-jerk reactions that continue the political dysfunction, can we all just put our energy and minds toward solutions? Revenge politics (they did it, so we will to! get them back!) hurts.

Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by jfoutz on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @12:54AM (#14642668)
Probably not, no. Tit for tat is optimal prisoners dilemma strategy.
Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by afpx on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @10:20AM (#14645601)
Interesting. But, prisoners dilemma assumes that there's an authority that is imposing rules and punishments. In democracy, we are the authority and we can change the rules.
Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by rpenm on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @02:43AM (#14642985)
Cooperation can be optimal for an infinitely repeated prisoner's dilemma depending on prisoner's time preference (discount factor).
Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by guelo on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @01:22AM (#14642763)
The actual history of this decade of gerrymandering is that in 2010 Republicans were able to use anti-Obama tea party energy to capture a bunch of state houses right before the census redistricting. Republicans used that opportunity to lock-in control of the House probably until 2020. It's really just an accident of history. If the pattern repeats itself anti-Trump anger could give Democrats control of more state houses and lock in the next decade of redistricting. But democrats have been less ruthless on these kinds of things. For example by bringing up anti gerymandering initiatives like this one right before they gain power. Also I think Republicans seem to have more capacity for playing strategic long moves, for example, outside conservative money funded a California ballot measure a few years ago that made California's redistricting nonpartisan, thus taking away from Democrats the biggest state where they control redistricting, probably taking away 5-10 seats that Democrats could gerymander for themselves next cycle.
Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by wand3r on Monday June 26, 2017 @10:10PM (#14642072)
I also caught some discussion about it on NPR. One argument, even as I am just as cynical as above poster; is that the Republicans did such a good job gerrymandering that best case they can keep their status quo and more than likely; they will be worse off. This was iirc because they balanced the demographics do well with their support base and any restructuring will actually hurt them. Based on the NPR bit which seemed to make a reasonable argument to me; an uniformed person, potentially they could back something like this.
Re:Delaney Introduces Bill to End Gerrymandering, Reform Ele... by j4kp07 on Tuesday June 27, 2017 @10:47AM (#14645859)
TL;DR The courts actually require states to intentionally create districts that have a majority population of minorities.

It's a difficult thing to manage. As a result of a Supreme Court ruling in regards to civil rights the states are not allowed to spread minority votes across district lines since it was determined that that doesn't give them a strong enough voice and doesn't allow them a united voice as well as the advancement of minority politicians in Congress.

States largely complied. But, as time has gone on people often believe that giving minorities their own districts actually hurts their political power because states put them all in their district, they get one politician and then the rest of the districts aren't a melting pot. So now there is a push to try to prevent states from districting based on racial lines, but the Supreme Court has already required them to do this. So it's a very fine balancing act the states have to go through, and in many cases they exploit the Supreme Court requirements/ruling to their political advantage.

And if you removed the racial districting you might actually lose minority representation in Congress in terms of number of minority Congressmen, which people don't want. So gerrymandering is this strange mix of affirmative action for Congress and political gamesmanship to protect a party's numbers in Congress.