When I was on Facebook I found that I was spending significantly more time chatting it up with my friends from college who are all over the country. Not that I don't want to keep in touch with them, but I'd rather be more social with people I can do things with.
Facebook gives you a social crutch. You have to get rid of it and create that gap to feel the need to fill it with something else.
Sunday school classes tend to be where the social aspects come from. We'll do a day at the lake or a get together for a meal and some activity.
We've gotten together with one or two other couples to get dinner and do an escape room, shoot targets at a guys farm, gotten the kids together to play. Even got invited to a dueling piano bar, which caught me by surprise since I assumed that would be frowned on. Turns out most grown adults are perfectly content to go have a drink, just not many.
If interests are fragmented, the number of people we both share interests with and are friends with within a given radius becomes smaller.
Facebook might help a bit for organizing events and maintaining existing ties but it also contributes to the dopamine rush above.
Some sort of ways to connect new people with one another within a local area could be helpful. I found Meetup interesting and useful but could be improved upon. I used to attend some events organized by WeWork and those felt more energized but still no real friendships emerged.
The only thing that really helped make new long-term friends for me was sharing a co-working space with people who had some interests in common.
Miss a couple weddings that way and see if you feel the same.
We're the kind of people who are _proudly_ not on Facebook, and not at all shy about it. The only social network worth a damn is LinkedIn, and only so long as they are useful in finding work.
This was just that Facebook's walled garden expanded to surround my erstwhile social circle, and once that happens, you maintain your presence in that circle on Facebook's terms or not at all.
I mean, I get that it's hard to believe what I'm saying can possibly be true. I wouldn't have believed it myself before I saw it happen! It sounds like something out of the kind of third-rate sf dystopia that fails to achieve much popularity even among genre fans. But here we are.
I think a better theory to support your point is that we tend to be less religious and therefore less community oriented. I don't really know if that holds up though. We have to be careful about romanticising the past, so yes longitudinal data and cultural comparisons would make these data more informative.
> How do we design technologies to help connect people in the real world and alleviate the problems?
Isn't the answer to this "Social Networks"? The market has spoken, Facebook is King. Every time there's conversations about the ills of Facebook there's always people pointing out that Facebook makes organising events a lot easier. That's definitely something I miss since getting off Facebook and moving to a new city.