- I don't know how old you are but both Clinton and Obama significantly increased taxes on the rich. Federal tax receipts as a % of GDP are fairly constant going back to WW2.
Economic inequality has collected a huge amount of capital into very few hands that ultimately don't seem to know how to apply it productively over the whole system.
I had a friend who ran a successful manufacturing company who was forced to shut down production... not because of competition or cost but because of the inability to get working capital. As the regional banks in our region got swallowed up, the local bankers who understood cyclical businesses went away.
1) we regulated that banks have access to capital (ie. we created the FED that will loan almost unlimited amounts to them. And of course we bailed out "too-big-to-fail")
2) we outlawed that banks loan money to anyone but the government, or very big companies. After all, since they always lost the money, we've imposed more and more rules about who they can lend to. (always lost it, I might add, by lending it to government or big companies when we're talking large amounts, but that is conveniently ignored of course).
Of course who they can lend it to means effectively not you or me.
These were world changing.
But now we're mostly done doing that and are now in the refinement stage on most technologies where we spend an enormous amount of effort to get, for example, 5% more fuel efficient airplanes. Physics is tough.
Maybe we'll have some sort of revolutionary breakthroughs in the future that lead to another era of rapid invention but until that happens we'll continue plodding along building a slightly more efficient world instead of a transformative one.
This is really just one hypothesis though. The real answer is that no one really knows for sure.
But I also somewhat discount that the rising difficulty level is really why more breakthroughs aren't happening, if that were the case one would see larger and larger accumulations of ventures committing capital and failing (or at least operating). I think the real reason is that not enough capital even tries to attack these problems because they're longer term and difficult to quantify the return. The irony is that I suspect that we get a smaller overall growth by routing capital to mostly knowable investment returns over a larger proportion going to "crazy" non-calculable investments. So, we end up waiting for the die-rolls to match up people like Elon Musk with sufficient fortunes for truly big advancements, and an economic system that mucks around with financial engineering instead of relentlessly and systematically advancing a wide range of real-world applied engineering on big problems.
By squeezing pennies out of lots of things, we miss the dollars that could make positive change.
Look at corporate IT as The gold standard of fail. We design complex systems to allow them to be sourced out (is ITIL/ITSM), and then are surprised when we have built a monstrosity that doesn't really work.
You see this type of thinking everywhere. I had an ancient popcorn popper called the "Whirly Pop" that I got in the 90s, which was basically an aluminum pan with a wood handle and metal gear for swirling popcorn on the stove. It recently broke and I bought a replacement -- a product inferior in every way with a plastic handle that will burn your hand, a plastic gear that will melt, and a metal pan and cover so thin that bent it while cleaning with a sponge.
This then results in the need for increased scale, increased productivity, and indeed, the need for innovation disappearing altogether.
Further, not being static does not mean it was ever meaningfully increased. The rate from 1982 was higher than either Clinton or Obama rates. And 1982 was below the rate from 1932 to 1981. Compare US GDP growth and a high top marginal rate seems to promote growth, though there are many ways to slice and dice these numbers.
2) I think we mostly agree here. There have definitely been meaningful changes both up and down (on the order of 20%) over the years depending on both economic and political changes. However, when you look over a 50 year timespan (everything post WW2 basically), you don't really see a meaningful longitudinal change. To me this refutes the OPs point about taxation being meaningfully different in the "olden days."
PS: IMO, a ~1 to 2% AMT on all wealth per year would be incredibly beneficial. But, there is currently about zero chances of that ever happening.
I can't seem to find a relevant graph on fred.stlouisfed.org though. :(
The tax burden has basically gone opposite of what you imply. For example, the top 10% paid 49% of taxes in 1980 and paid 70% in 2014. (http://www.ntu.org/foundation/page/who-pays-income-taxes) The "top marginal rate" means very little by itself. What matters is the effective rate which takes into account the credits/deductions that are allowed, the other lower tax rates, etc.
>...Compare US GDP growth and a high top marginal rate seems to promote growth,
Those high marginal rates of the 1950's did not bring in some giant windfall to the government or somehow promote growth of GDP. Most economists are opposed to very high marginal tax rates due to the inefficiencies they introduce - compensation being moved to non-salary, money wasted on CPAs, lawyers and lobbying congress for special deductions, dead weight losses for economic activity that isn't done, etc.
Further, the top marginal tax rate has little to do with the top 10% of all incomes.
PS: Yes, in theory they where a bad idea. However, in practice they seem to have been a net benefit. Either though reducing the rent seeking behavior of capital, or alternatively because the middle class's spending is mass producible. (You can scale iPhones, you can't scale 50,000+$ watches because they are not intended to be scaled.)
http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SI.DST.10TH.10?locations... http://www.oecd.org/els/soc/growingunequalincomedistribution...
>...Further, the top marginal tax rate has little to do with the top 10% of all incomes.
As I have tried to explain in the previous comment, the top marginal rate means very little.
>...Yes, in theory they where a bad idea. However, in practice they seem to have been a net benefit.
In reality, they were a bad idea. It should be a hint that you don't see mainstream economists suggesting we return to them. Politicians find them a good talking point since everyone likes the idea of someone else paying more taxes, but you don't see economists suggesting it.
>...Either though reducing the rent seeking behavior of capital, or alternatively because the middle class's spending is mass producible. (You can scale iPhones, you can't scale 50,000+$ watches because they are not intended to be scaled.)
How exactly does a confiscatory rate reduce the rent seeking behavior of capital - that seems like a different issue. In reality, high rates encourage money to be spent in non-productive ways to influence congress to carve out special tax deductions/credits. Enough loopholes were in the old tax code that some politically well connected wealthy people sometimes paid no taxes - this is why the AMT was created.
So, yes you can get rather different looking charts from what I said. But, honestly I don't feel like getting into a debate about this stuff.
As long as you don't have high capital gains tax or at least at the same level as income tax the wealth will keep flowing to the very rich. As richer you are the lesser tax you pay percentage wise on your wealth gain every year.China creates their own debt free money as needed. The U.S government must borrow it. You ever notice how economic pundits have been predicting an economic crash in China for the last 30 years that never seems to come? It's because the government just endlessly bails out the economy in a debt-free way that never sticks the taxpayers with the bill.
That's.... not how it works. USA consumers purchase lots of imports from China, which causes massive flows of capital from the USA to China. China uses these capital flows to purchase treasuries from the USA which (in part) funds the federal deficit.
At no point is China just "creating debt-free money".
The exact same thing happens in other countries with large trade surpluses. Part of the reason for the Greek crisis was that Germany exports a lot of goods to Greece. This capital flow drives down the price of money (the interest rate) in Frankfurt and drives up the price of money in Athens. The Germans, seeing that they could get 1% at home or 7% in Greece (in the early 00's) then used the capital flows to purchase securities in Greece, such as bonds, CDOs and CDSs.
I didn't say debt free dollars. Of course China can't create dollars. I meant debt-free RMB.
In the agricultural age, if you fucked up a harvest, you and your family could starve.
Before agriculture, if you fucked up a hunt, your whole kin-clan could starve.
Nowadays, if you fuck up the housing market, and millions of people go bankrupt, nothing gets broken enough to turn a concern into a crisis, so we never fix anything, and nothing ever changes.
To borrow your example: In agricultural age, if you fucked up harvest your family starves. Today, if you fuck up the housing market, thousand of families end up in bankrupcy, and tens of thousands of small investors loose their savings... but you do not personally know any of them, so you wont even feel shame when you cash-in that million dollar yearly bonus.
There's historic precedent for that kind of divorce between actions and consequences, and it is not pretty. There's a certain French doctor you should google: his name's Josheph Guillotin.
A better example would be the decision to go to war in Iraq. The people who made that decision didn't have to send their own children and they could enact large tax cuts for themselves in addition at the same time. So they got their war but didn't feel any consequence.
Which is what I expected to hint the the mention of Guillotin: the French Revolution. That did not happend because of social injustice. No human society has ever been 100% fair, -and probably none will, ever,- and most people is able to accept that without making a fuss about it. The problem with the Ancien Regime back then, -which is the same problem with financial elites nowadays,- is that they have become increasingly detached from the realities of their decisions for the rank and file, even to the point of cluelessness.
I'm not sure what analogy you are going for. Guillotin did not invent the guillotine, and only advertised it as a more humane way of execution. He was opposed to the death penalty.
(This is, of course, a gross oversimplification of a complex historical topic. Please feel free to correct me.)
The actual inventor of the guillotine is one Antoine Louis [1].
I think an intuitive grasp of this is why so many conservatives have a natural disdain for welfare. But I think their disdain for welfare at the individual level is misplaced. The isolation of the most powerful and largest scale systems from consequences at the macro level is a far larger problem than the isolation of individuals from consequences at the micro level. Welfare can indeed become addictive and lead to a "welfare class," but these are largely powerless and relatively poor people who may be somewhat of a burden on society but do little damage otherwise. The real danger is a rich powerful professional welfare class that makes big ugly mistakes and is isolated from the consequences of these by power and abundance.
The real active harm comes when you get a professional class that does very bad things. These can be mistakes, like the total collapse of the economy in 2008, or they can be intentional crimes. Either way if there are no consequences then no correction gets applied and the problem gets worse.
A large scale wealthy civilization can absorb a tremendous amount of official incompetence and misconduct.
[1] https://steveblank.com/secret-history/
Uber is going to fail. The F35 is going to fail. Throwing good money after bad will stave off that day of reckoning but then only make it a worse accounting.
It reminds me of the sci fi novels Dread Empire's Fall, in which the galactic civilization's ship fleet has never fought a battle in thousands of years, so nobody can actually know how to do it, and they don't know if a certain tactic, ship, etc is really a failure or not.
A different source ("Armies South, Armies North" by Alan Axelrod, also author of the more compellingly-named "Generals South, Generals North") provides more detail, including names: Winfield Scott, William Harney, David Twiggs, and John Wool. This and other sources also include Joseph Johnston, then quartermaster general of the US Army, as a fifth general. There were also two more brevetted generals: Albert Johnston (no relation to Joseph) and Newman Clarke.
Maj. Gen. Winfield Scott (the commanding general of the US Army) was 74 years old and indeed unable to ride a horse. However, all seven of the generals had seen combat. In particular, four served in the War of 1812, all served in the Mexican-American War, and all served in the Indian Wars. With the exception of Joseph Johnston, all of them even served in war as generals (at least brevet, but usually full).
If we were to engage in universal welfare, we'd remove a false feedback signal and allow ourselves to focus on what actually creates value rather than what pays rent, food, essential health care and education.
I don't think there is much debate that not giving people access to those things is bad. But we seem strangely averse to just making them part of the core of our society.
A high rate / corp tax rate that's proportional to an objective inequality measure?
Trouble is taxation is avoided but it is the only thing that really stings.
What? The size of gov't has only increased over time. That's money being pulled out of the economy through taxes. If anything redistribution has drastically increased over time.
That money goes straight back into the economy.
My comment was taxation is higher now than it's ever been.
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S
Let's see your data?
Wealthy people don't think outside the box enough, they just invest money with their friends who are probably already wealthy themselves. This widens the class gap and is bad for the economy.
then throw in we are bombarded every day continuously to buy this,buy that, go here, do that. We get told every day of wonderful stuff available for pennies or dollars a day. we have tv shows and advertisements implying status for owning certain products.
besides managing their money we fail to teach kids in school just how well marketing manipulates them into believing what is needed to have them spend money.
still regulation has become the go to tool to prevent competition and when that doesn't work the fear of exploitation of the poor or under privileged is brought to the foreground.
the simple fact is we have too much government for it to be effective for the regular person, it only serves those who can afford to operate on its level
And what's the solution? Deregulation? Wouldn't that just make consumers even more vulnerable to the predations of the powerful? In fact, it seems that powerful interests generally lobby for more regulation, not less, so I'm not really sure what your point is here.
And your statement about "too much government" is vague and abstract. How exactly is "too much government" contributing to wealth and power inequality. Historically, it has been government intervention that has acted as a counterweight to concentrated power.
In fact, people who have been complaining about too much government became influential in public policy about the EXACT time a lot of these trends in wealth inequality started (the late 1970s).
Sorry to be so critical, but I think a major contributor to our problems is people who make blanket statements about that are vague and imprecise and do not articulate any real policy goals.
Another example is how LA Sanitation continued to charge myself and thousands of other apartment dwellers the monthly flat rate, despite our landlord hiring a private service, and the fact that the city collected our cans and the city trucks didn't collect trash. They refused to refund my money, citing a City Council Resolution on the matter. The city was eventually sued and this policy was repealed. If I refused to pay, since DWP does the billing for Sanitation, my electrical service would have been terminated.
Don't even get me started on CA's solution to Sacramento's refusal to curtail spending by passing a $.20/gallon gasoline tax. CA residents already pay more gas tax than most other states.
And last but certainly not least, CA Senate Bill 18/2017 which thankfully was crushed by activists. This "Children's Bill of Rights" did not increase safety nor the welfare of children in general. It did however insinuate the State of California as your child's new parent, whilst mandating a new level of services to be provided by the billionaire author of the bill, Jim Steyer (Common Sense Media). Funded by your tax dollars, of course.
How do you figure? Between 1936 and 1989, the tax rate for the top income bracket varied between 63% and 91%.
A progressive tax rate is one that increases as the taxable amount increases.
So, I could be missing something, but I don't see how your post addresses my response. Saying it's meaningless doesn't change the definition of a progressive tax rate.
In the olden days, the main force balancing this was taxation. Even if you look at it as a purely zero-sum game, any money paid by the very wealthy had to go somewhere, and that somewhere was the masses. This didn't sit right with the very wealthy and they rigged the system to such a degree that I've never seen an appreciable tax increase in my lifetime, even in the face of trillion dollar deficits and the loss of the middle class in the US. Mathematically, trickle-down economics has given us just exactly the system it was designed to. I mourn for the millions (billions) of people left out, but for whatever reason a lot of people don’t even see them.
Maybe the great problem of our time is ignorance..