News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crony capitalism may be cannibalizing productive capitali... by Retric on Friday June 23, 2017 @02:23PM (#14621423)
First that graph shows a huge range of rates. Just 2000 vs 2004 is a 22% drop, but even that's just federal rates. Total government spending is the only meaningful metric when state, local, and federal funds are all taken out of your paycheck.

Further, not being static does not mean it was ever meaningfully increased. The rate from 1982 was higher than either Clinton or Obama rates. And 1982 was below the rate from 1932 to 1981. Compare US GDP growth and a high top marginal rate seems to promote growth, though there are many ways to slice and dice these numbers.

Re:Crony capitalism may be cannibalizing productive capitali... by harryh on Friday June 23, 2017 @02:28PM (#14621473)
1) I expect that if we included state and local taxes the story would be much the same, though I don't have a graph handy. You could be right I suppose.

2) I think we mostly agree here. There have definitely been meaningful changes both up and down (on the order of 20%) over the years depending on both economic and political changes. However, when you look over a 50 year timespan (everything post WW2 basically), you don't really see a meaningful longitudinal change. To me this refutes the OPs point about taxation being meaningfully different in the "olden days."

Re:Crony capitalism may be cannibalizing productive capitali... by Retric on Friday June 23, 2017 @02:35PM (#14621537)
2) He was not talking about total recites. And the top tax rates are a very different story: https://www.cch.com/WBOT2013/029IncomeTaxRates.asp

PS: IMO, a ~1 to 2% AMT on all wealth per year would be incredibly beneficial. But, there is currently about zero chances of that ever happening.

Re:Crony capitalism may be cannibalizing productive capitali... by harryh on Friday June 23, 2017 @02:47PM (#14621669)
My understanding is that those top marginal rates didn't matter as much as you might think because they mostly shifted forms of compensation. The data we'd really want to investigate this question is what % of taxes were paid by various income groups (top .1%, 1%, 5%, 10%) over time. See how much that share has changed with various policy changes.

I can't seem to find a relevant graph on fred.stlouisfed.org though. :(

Re:Crony capitalism may be cannibalizing productive capitali... by opo on Friday June 23, 2017 @09:53PM (#14624000)
ntu.org has some recent data. In general, federal income tax has gotten more progressive since the 50s. For example, the top 10% paid 49% of taxes in 1980 and paid 70% in 2014. http://www.ntu.org/foundation/page/who-pays-income-taxes
Re:Crony capitalism may be cannibalizing productive capitali... by opo on Friday June 23, 2017 @06:34PM (#14623273)
>...Further, not being static does not mean it was ever meaningfully increased.

The tax burden has basically gone opposite of what you imply. For example, the top 10% paid 49% of taxes in 1980 and paid 70% in 2014. (http://www.ntu.org/foundation/page/who-pays-income-taxes) The "top marginal rate" means very little by itself. What matters is the effective rate which takes into account the credits/deductions that are allowed, the other lower tax rates, etc.

>...Compare US GDP growth and a high top marginal rate seems to promote growth,

Those high marginal rates of the 1950's did not bring in some giant windfall to the government or somehow promote growth of GDP. Most economists are opposed to very high marginal tax rates due to the inefficiencies they introduce - compensation being moved to non-salary, money wasted on CPAs, lawyers and lobbying congress for special deductions, dead weight losses for economic activity that isn't done, etc.

Re:Crony capitalism may be cannibalizing productive capitali... by Retric on Friday June 23, 2017 @07:00PM (#14623389)
Top 10% made 20% of all income in 1980, they now make 50% of all income. So, going up to 70% is actually a drop in their tax rates.

Further, the top marginal tax rate has little to do with the top 10% of all incomes.

PS: Yes, in theory they where a bad idea. However, in practice they seem to have been a net benefit. Either though reducing the rent seeking behavior of capital, or alternatively because the middle class's spending is mass producible. (You can scale iPhones, you can't scale 50,000+$ watches because they are not intended to be scaled.)

Re:Crony capitalism may be cannibalizing productive capitali... by opo on Friday June 23, 2017 @07:46PM (#14623593)
What is the source of your data? According to the world bank and the OECD, from 1986 to now the income share held by the top 10% has been in a range from 27 - 31%.

http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SI.DST.10TH.10?locations... http://www.oecd.org/els/soc/growingunequalincomedistribution...

>...Further, the top marginal tax rate has little to do with the top 10% of all incomes.

As I have tried to explain in the previous comment, the top marginal rate means very little.

>...Yes, in theory they where a bad idea. However, in practice they seem to have been a net benefit.

In reality, they were a bad idea. It should be a hint that you don't see mainstream economists suggesting we return to them. Politicians find them a good talking point since everyone likes the idea of someone else paying more taxes, but you don't see economists suggesting it.

>...Either though reducing the rent seeking behavior of capital, or alternatively because the middle class's spending is mass producible. (You can scale iPhones, you can't scale 50,000+$ watches because they are not intended to be scaled.)

How exactly does a confiscatory rate reduce the rent seeking behavior of capital - that seems like a different issue. In reality, high rates encourage money to be spent in non-productive ways to influence congress to carve out special tax deductions/credits. Enough loopholes were in the old tax code that some politically well connected wealthy people sometimes paid no taxes - this is why the AMT was created.

Re:Crony capitalism may be cannibalizing productive capitali... by Retric on Friday June 23, 2017 @08:40PM (#14623780)
If you want to debate the numbers, there are 4 big options. Do you use households or individuals? Do you include capital gains or just realized income. Who do you exclude from the measurements ex: military, prison population, etc? And do you look at pre or post tax numbers?

So, yes you can get rather different looking charts from what I said. But, honestly I don't feel like getting into a debate about this stuff.