I'm using NoScript since I barely escaped from being infected by quite sophisticated malware few years ago.
Innocent site (local public transport) had had injected single malicious line into its content management system (most probably after untargeted "fishing for vulnerabilities" botnet scan). This one line was JavaScript include which in turn triggered series of jumps to servers all over the world (mostly China and Russia).
In the process, multiple layers of heavily obfuscated JS code were both loading hidden frames loaded with ads (presumably for click / impressions fraud) and trying to load hidden PDF embeds which contained a payload of hidden executables for infecting your local computer (exploiting Acrobat Reader security holes).
I only found out because Acrobat is such huge resource hog that I noticed and managed to kill it in a task manager before it finished loading.
I was using up-to-date Firefox and up-to-date antivirus AND I had disabled Acrobat plugin.
Upon inspection, malicious code appeared to be cross-platform and multi-target, using vendor specific JS extension. I remember besides Acrobat it was also targeting Silverlight (and this was in time when it was very new technology).
[1] http://entertainment.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=629659&...
The list goes on and on, sure you can do most of these without javascript, but by that point I've moved on and blacklisted your site.
Is it better to be overly secure, or underly secure?
You do realize that due to a patent ruling a few years ago, these days almost all Flash content is placed after load with JavaScript to circumvent ActiveX's click-to-interact restriction. How often are you able to enable only Flash to view your content?
My general policy is: if I'm linked to an article, I should be able to read it without enabling JS. If I'm linked to a video, I should be able to watch it only enabling the Flash plugin. If these assumptions are violated I become offended and I usually press Back, unless I have a very good reason to need to see that content.
I am not offended by web applications which require Javascript, as long as they're linked to by a source I trust.
I won't enable Javascript for domains which I know only serve ads. I also won't enable Javascript if I think I'm on a "sketchy" page -- a page which I believe might have malicious code.