News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by jacquesm on Saturday June 17, 2017 @09:32AM (#14575827)
What a terrible waste. Especially in Kazakhstan that money could have had some serious positive impact if spent wisely.
Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by vbezhenar on Saturday June 17, 2017 @10:06AM (#14575947)
There's a joke in Kazakhstan: Wanna see your pension? Visit Expo.

Nazarbaev wants to promote Kazakhstan as one of the regional leaders. May be it'll yield some benefits in the future. But right now many citizens share your view.

Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by jacquesm on Saturday June 17, 2017 @10:59AM (#14576157)
That echos the sentiment many Romanians have towards the palace in Bucharest.

The city considered tearing it down but it turned out even that was too expensive so now - reluctantly - they are using it for some government functions. It's super inefficient though, the energy bill alone is monstrous, especially in the winter.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palace_of_the_Parliament

Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by joshlemer on Saturday June 17, 2017 @12:41PM (#14576576)
Couldn't parts of it be turned into condo's or offices? Wouldn't it be a pretty iconic (desirable) place to live/work?
Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by jacquesm on Saturday June 17, 2017 @01:11PM (#14576697)
Well, approximately 70% of it is still empty so I'm sure they'll welcome your bid :)
Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by Jedd on Saturday June 17, 2017 @09:39AM (#14575844)
The same could be said of almost anywhere, and almost any public event that is more for show than for benefit.

EDIT: I agree with jacquesm's sentiment ... but I feel we are too forgiving of these kinds of wasteful spends when they're in our own backyards.

Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by gcb0 on Saturday June 17, 2017 @09:53AM (#14575898)
like Olympics, f1, world cup, TED, etc etc.

it was 5bi spent for entertainment. Just like lots of other billions are everywhere in the world.

just because it was in a country you perceive as poor and failed it shocks you.

yeah, it probably had corruption and half that money disappeared, just like on the rich events I listed above.

But, this is the same mentality that demonize food stamps and social programs for the poor in your rich country that are not 100% focused on making those poor people complacent and effective workers.

(ps: "you" used as in the undefined plural subject form. I don't know the person I'm replying :)

Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by Jedd on Saturday June 17, 2017 @09:59AM (#14575920)
> like Olympics, f1, world cup, TED, etc etc.

It's disingenuous to claim that I lump those in the same category.

Let's focus on my 'more for show than for benefit' qualification.

> it was 5bi spent for entertainment. Just like lots of other billions are everywhere in the world.

Do you mean 'just like other billions everywhere else spent on entertainment' or 'just like other billions everywhere else spent'. I'm not sure you're accurately reflecting my views by suggesting that I think entertainment has equal value to non-entertainment activities.

> just because it was in a country you perceive as poor and failed it shocks you.

Yeah, so stop right there.

I was working for the treasury department for NSW at the time that we were gearing up for the Sydney Olympics (later re-branded the NSW Olympics (later re-branded, as funding was sought further up the chain, as the Australian Olympics). There's nothing imperial, us-or-them, poor-vs-rich country about this. Take that particular card off the table.

> But, this is the same mentality that demonize food stamps and social programs for the poor in your rich country that are not 100% focused on making those poor people complacent and effective workers.

It really, really, is not.

Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by gcb0 on Saturday June 17, 2017 @10:08AM (#14575950)
you kind of proved my point. I do lump all those events in the same bag and my point was that most people fail to see it and see the ones they like as culturally enriching and the ones they don't fancy as waste.

the only problem on the article's event was lack of public. but I bet lots of local people wanted to go but lacked the means. just like the Olympics. but it doesn't show much because the Olympics manages to import rich foreigners just fine.

Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by totalZero on Saturday June 17, 2017 @10:36AM (#14576063)
How did anyone prove your point? You are just repeating yourself to claim that there are two voices in agreement.
Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by Jedd on Saturday June 17, 2017 @10:14AM (#14575974)
> you kind of proved my point.

That was not my intent.

> I do lump all those events in the same bag and my point was that most people fail to see it and see the ones they like as culturally enriching and the ones they don't fancy as waste.

Are you genuinely suggesting TFA describes a non-wasteful event?

Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by Cyph0n on Saturday June 17, 2017 @01:01PM (#14576658)
Care to elaborate why you think Expo is less beneficial than the events listed in the comment you replied to?
Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by Jedd on Saturday June 17, 2017 @09:07PM (#14578471)
There are more than two categories. Grading the set objectively seems infeasible, and not very useful. I've lived in two cities as they hosted Olympics, but didn't attend either. I've been to a world expo. I've not been to a world cup or an F1 event (though I once worked in an office overlooking the F1).

I think this Expo was a waste of resources. I suspect most TED conferences are not. I understand that Olympics, World Cup, F1 are highly lucrative for a handful of people, but typically a net negative for the host city / state. The corruption associated with at least two of those three is legendary, and well documented. If you would prefer to separate 'the event' from 'the corruption involved in the event', then good luck with that.

Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by Bakary on Saturday June 17, 2017 @12:06PM (#14576434)
The point is more along the lines that the money was grossly misspent in this particular case, not that it being spent on entertainment is necessarily bad. Had the Expo been a massive success, it would still have arguably been a waste, but not a tragic one.

Here the failure is especially glaring since the secondary goal of the event is to make the nation look dynamic and well managed.

Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by hkmurakami on Saturday June 17, 2017 @12:30PM (#14576534)
Or even public financing of NFL stadiums.
Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by jacquesm on Saturday June 17, 2017 @10:42AM (#14576089)
On Kazakhstan's GDP it is a huge amount.
Re:Kazakhstan built a futuristic city to host Expo 2017, but... by Jedd on Saturday June 17, 2017 @11:02AM (#14576170)
Undeniably.

Also undeniably, there's an abundance of complicated financial analyses, and emotional responses, to these kinds of events.

My mention of the Sydney 2000 Olympics was on point -- official figures peg it at somewhere north of $2b, but official figures hide all the infrastructure spend that wasn't formally attributed to the Olympics. You can probably take that figure upwards by close to an order of magnitude in terms of real costs / set back to the local economy. Other Olympics have exhibited similar effects, with Barcelona being perhaps the perfect storm (it's undeniably complicated, with many infrastructure projects bundled into that event, but conservative estimates suggest it was around 12 years to pay that event off).

I don't doubt that there's a hugely convoluted and complex arrangement with various players in Kazakhstan and BIE, with precious little chance of an accurate summary of the financials for the event ever coming to light.