News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by rchi on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @11:45PM (#1457255)
I doubt that Obama (with his intellect) genuinely believes that this policy will help the economy at all.

Disappointing on so many levels.

Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by djcapelis on Thursday June 24, 2010 @12:05AM (#1457286)
Why do you think smart people can't make stupid decisions now and again?

I doubt he's getting full and accurate data and I doubt he's really had time to spend on the issue that this needs given the other major issues that need to be dealt with.

Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by patrickk on Thursday June 24, 2010 @05:04AM (#1457649)
Two words: Special Interests.

He's probably only getting one side of the story, as the anti-piracy lobby has the money, power and influence to be able to bend the ear of those high up enough to make a difference. Spend enough time listening to one side of the debate, and you have the VP eventually making dumb comments like the Tiffany's quote.

Richard Stallman probably would probably not clear White House security checks (joke)

Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by edanm on Thursday June 24, 2010 @03:54AM (#1457571)
You know, there's the off chance that: 1. He is smart. 2. As the President of the United States, he is getting all the data he needs. 3. You're the one who's wrong.

I'm not saying it's necessarily true, but it sounds a little funny to say "yeah he's either stupid or ignorant" about someone who is very likely neither. It's possible he just disagrees with you, despite being smart and knowledgeable.

Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by djcapelis on Wednesday June 30, 2010 @08:17AM (#1474585)
Of course that's a possibility.

I merely stated my own personal doubt that inside the echo chamber he was seeing the same things we see and that alone could explain the decision.

I didn't say that was the only possibility. I just mentioned it was the one I thought most likely.

I think it's always important to remember smart people can make stupid decisions based on flawed data. I was reminding the poster I was replying to about this possibility.

I did not actually say that Obama necessarily did this here. Though I do think it likely actually... but it's hard to tell, I don't have lunch with the guy.

Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by loewenskind on Thursday June 24, 2010 @06:00AM (#1457718)
It doesn't have to be one of:

a) Stupid b) Ignorant c) Wrong

It is most likely that Obama has different motivations then we do so his "right" is different than ours.

Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by edanm on Thursday June 24, 2010 @10:59AM (#1458177)
Yep, that definitely seems more likely than him being stupid or ignorant.
Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by cmelbye on Thursday June 24, 2010 @01:56AM (#1457408)
As the President of the United States, he would have the power to stop this policy from being put in motion. If he had the intellect, he would realize that this is a bad idea and he would stop it. At this rate, he'll doing as much bad as McCain does to the Internet in my opinion.
Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by nailer on Thursday June 24, 2010 @03:15AM (#1457527)
Saying 'if he was smart, he wouldn't stop piracy' begs the question why taking creative works without permission isn't worth stopping.
Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by loewenskind on Thursday June 24, 2010 @06:08AM (#1457726)
It would be worth stopping or slowing, but putting someone in jail? How does that help anything? Destroy someone's life over a download?

Plus, letting the Music/Movie industry keep things as they are is slowing progression. If the government is going to get involved in this they need to also insure that new (i.e. online) competition is allowed in on media distribution. The existing players have a monopoly on it, and a monopoly is something that provably hurts the economy.

Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by nailer on Thursday June 24, 2010 @06:28AM (#1457747)
> Destroy someone's life over a download?

The law isn't proposing to destroy lives of casual downloaders. They'll get a fine at most - which is what all legislation I've ever seen does. Jail is inevitably reserved for more organized networks.

> Plus, letting the Music/Movie industry keep things going as they are

Piracy also affects the software industry and independent artists. Like me, like the other guy in this link that had his worked nicked, like our Bingo Card Guy. Piracy doesn't distinguish between good people and bad people. It's about getting things you want without paying for them.

There is no pirate site that refuses to steal from indie artists, ethical companies, or OSS contributors.

New online competition is media distribution is allowed! My company sells it works directly, so do heaps of independent artists. Nobody from other companies or the government can stop us selling work online.

Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by loewenskind on Thursday June 24, 2010 @09:37AM (#1457999)
Great, so I can get the latest Holywood blockbuster online from you for $3 instead of have to walk to the back of a Walmart and pay $20?
Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by nailer on Thursday June 24, 2010 @09:59AM (#1458040)
No. I don't make it, so I don't determine the price. That doesn't mean you have the right to steal it.
Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by loewenskind on Thursday June 24, 2010 @10:12AM (#1458067)
My point is; the model is wrong. An expensive, outdated method is being used because distribution of these movies is controlled by a small established group with deep pockets. I don't imagine the producers like the situation, nor the stars of the movie. They would probably make more if they could just release their film online instead of paying a middle man to package it up and ship it around.

If the government is going to step in and try to stop piracy, fine. I want to live in a world where I can write an application and become financially independent from it (and without having to give it away and get paid for support, yuck!). But they also have to address this issue that these old, but rich companies are hurting the economy by insisting on being inefficient middle men that customers don't care about and probably not creators of the content either.

Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by nailer on Thursday June 24, 2010 @11:14AM (#1458204)
OK, it sounds as if we're both agreed about piracy being bad.

Re: control of distribution, for large budget films, unfortunately, the people who fund them want to limit the 0-day release to cinemas - as they find it's more profitable, which probably helps pay for all those special effects. Personally I don't mind - it's their movie.

Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by loewenskind on Friday June 25, 2010 @03:20AM (#1460228)
Yes, I definitely think it's bad. If we don't find a good way to deal with it (not eliminate, even physical goods sellers haven't achieved that, but bring down to more digestible levels) a lot of markets will eventually shrink drastically.

I can understand wanting to limit early releases while the film is still in the cinema. Fair enough, but personally I think after a suitable amount of time has passed the producers should release the films to digital channels (e.g. iTunes) themselves. I don't think the money distributors cream off the top makes anything better. In my ideal world distributors would be producing the DVD/CD/BlueRay disks for the very small (eventually) group of people who still want to consume that way. In other words, they would be by far the smallest group in the picture, not the biggest.

Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by huhtenberg on Thursday June 24, 2010 @01:02AM (#1457346)
I hope this is just a lip service to quieten the MPAA/RIAA lobbyists. At least to a larger degree it is. Perhaps some changes will be made to the legislation, but nothing as far reaching as "criminalizing p2p development" (whatever it is).
Re:Obama Administration Announces Massive Piracy Crackdown by chris11 on Thursday June 24, 2010 @03:56AM (#1457576)
This is more than lip service, Obama filled the DOJ with former RIAA lawyers. And Biden's always been pro-RIAA. It may be cynicism, but Biden's statement is really not surprising.

http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2009/04/obama-taps-fift/

http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-10024163-38.html