Inspection is one reason, so while the shelf toilet is getting less common, doctors and hospitals still tend to have them. Maybe that was a craze at one time, I don't really know a lot of people who inspect their stool -- or that of others, to dispel those South Park rumors...
It does have one added benefit: Reduced splash-back for #2. US toilets are really nasty in that regard, as the water level seems to be higher than in Europe.
And as My First American Toilet(tm) was in a hotel, I didn't feel like going all Super Mario on it anyway...
Did you try out any home toilets? (Knock knock - can I look at your toilet sir?)
I'm willing to put a ruler in mine, if you will.
And no, it wasn't a fancy hotel, it was a Holiday Inn Express. Since then, I staid in quite a few company apartments, been invited in a few homes etc. I didn't measure any water levels in Germany (or England, Greece, Italy...), either, so this isn't exactly scientific. But considering that I haven't seen that many toilet brushes here in Jersey (and NYC), you probably need a higher water level.
I bet it's different in states where wasting water is worse. And if I remember correctly, Dave Barry wrote quite a bit about water-saving toilets a couple of years back.
I don't think that's representative. All the houses I've been in had one. It's possible people just put them where they are not very visible.
It seemed like someone sat down and said to himself, "now how can I make this toilet worse? I know!"