Re:How Amazon Crushed the Union Movement (2014)
by frgtpsswrdlame on Friday June 16, 2017 @07:55AM
(#14568147)
If I own a plastic company I can easily write an agreement where, for example, Widget Co. agrees to buy only my plastic for some price. Now imagine a state legislature came in and said that Widget Co. can't write that, that Widget Co. always has to be open to buying plastic from other companies and that when we spend a bunch of time negotiating price and writing a contract, Widget Co. can just run that to a competitor and write a new for one cent less. That's obviously infringing on my ability to write contracts.
But then we do that exact thing when the product is labor and not plastic. Your freedom of association is on the macro level, as in you can go from firm to firm to firm and if that firm requires you to join the union you just keep moving, same as if that firm pays a low wage or has no health insurance or anything else.
Here is why this is incorrect.
It is illegal to fire someone for joining a union. This is a right that all workers have.
For the same reason that it is illegal to fire someone for joining a union, it should be illegal to fire someone for NOT joining a union.
So take you pick. If you want full freedom of association, sure, lets do that. You can make whatever contracts you want, but you can also be fired for it, (ie legalize firing people for joining a union). I think I would be happy with this outcome, to be honest.
But as long as union people are receiving this protection, NON-union people should receive the SAME protection.