Re:No correlation between headphone frequency response and r...
by Dylan16807 on Friday June 16, 2017 @04:55AM
(#14567516)
It's obvious from the title that frequency response is being used as a proxy for quality, and it's outright stated multiple times such as "assuming that the perceived audio quality is largely determined by the spectral magnitude response of headphones".
But it's a bad way to test frequency response. And don't pull out those weird undefined words when this was a discussion of important objective audio-quality measures being ignored.
Re:No correlation between headphone frequency response and r...
by betenoire on Friday June 16, 2017 @01:25PM
(#14570867)
I don't think it is obvious. I have headphones I use for mixing, because of the frequency response. I don't use them to listen to music. Quality depends on what you are measuring, and no one claims a perfect frequency response necessarily means it sounds good. Often the opposite, since we use those types of headphones to find the flaws. So to ME, it's obvious that this is NOT about being a proxy for quality, and I'm inclined to believe that it is about what it claims to be about.
Re:No correlation between headphone frequency response and r...
by Dylan16807 on Friday June 16, 2017 @01:39PM
(#14571026)
A sine sweep is still a very narrow and incomplete way to measure frequency response.
> it's obvious that this is NOT about being a proxy for quality
"Interestingly, sound quality does not seem to be a major attribute for purchase decisions."
"Root-mean square errors (RMSEs) were calculated across frequency for each headphone with respect to an assumed target curve to assess an objective quality metric."
"assuming that the perceived audio quality is largely determined by the spectral magnitude response of headphones"
Are you sure?
Humour me - what are some/any of the "bunch of things that should be measured" that were not, for a study titled "No correlation between headphone frequency response and retail price"?
I notice they also failed to test for "soundstage" "musicality" "warmth", or waterproofness, taste, and availability in a range of colours to suit your decor. Another "bunch of things" they didnt set out to test nor made any claims about.