News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:React v15.6.0 Released by amelius on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:52AM (#14553147)
I think you are greatly underestimating the value of developer good will.

> it's just a minimal amount of time to have their devs maintain a project page and accept public comments and changesets.

It's really a lot of work to maintain a project of this size, and all of its issues and documentation. I'm guessing it easily doubles the total amount of work.

> It makes their devs happier too, to think that they don't just work for FB, but also give something back to the community.

I would go further and say that these devs would be unhappy and question the meaning of their work without such projects.

> But for FB (...) React (...) is insignificant

Perhaps, perhaps not. But I am personally not supporting this any further, and doing my best not to be hypocritical by on the one hand criticizing Facebook and how they abuse their users in every conceivable way, and on the other hand applauding their open source efforts.

Re:React v15.6.0 Released by coldtea on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @11:13AM (#14553324)
>I think you are greatly underestimating the value of developer good will.

And I think that you greatly overestimating it.

Especially for a company like Facebook, whose business doesn't depend on developers anyway (even their "FB apps" platform is not such a big thing compared to FB core).

>It's really a lot of work to maintain a project of this size, and all of its issues and documentation. I'm guessing it easily doubles the total amount of work.

For a tiny team of a few devs, compared to the 1000s FB has on its payroll. Even if they spend like $1 million per year for just the "public open source" part of it, it's still peanuts.

>But I am personally not supporting this any further, and doing my best not to be hypocritical by on the one hand criticizing Facebook and how they abuse their users in every conceivable way, and on the other hand applauding their open source efforts.

Is that hypocritical though? Sounds more like calling something bad bad, and something good good, even if it comes from the same entity.

Which is something we should strive for maybe?

Re:React v15.6.0 Released by amelius on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @11:29AM (#14553433)
> Is that hypocritical though? Sounds more like calling something bad bad, and something good good, even if it comes from the same entity. Which is something we should strive for maybe?

I can answer that with simply: not if the good is reinforcing the bad.

Because then it is hypocritical by definition.