News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by yequalsx on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:12AM (#14552837)
Getting rid of unions will increase income inequality. Just compare for profit higher education with public higher education. The wages/benefits for workers former very much lag those of the latter. Private prisons pay way less too. But the people at the top get outsized pay. The cost savings to taxpayers are not sufficient to justify this inequity.
Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by pizzetta on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:19AM (#14552888)
Imagine if unions were strong and IT were unionized. How would you imagine the progress we've seen in information technology?

The impact on progress should not be discounted as an externality. Imagine if taxicabs or any livery service of any kind had to have a union member associated with it. Would autonomous cars make the same progress (for example, we can have autonomous subways/trains but they have to be "personned" due to pressure from unions). Or, imagine if we had them in research (drugs discovery) --the added bureaucracy researchers would have to manage and devote valuable time to.

I am not saying unionization is absolutely bad --they have brought good things about to workplace improvement, but they also have externalities we need to acknowledge.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by csydas on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:53AM (#14553156)
>Imagine if unions were strong and IT were unionized. How would you imagine the progress we've seen in information technology?

I'm not sure this is really a compelling point. Tech companies have made some cool stuff, but technology is also heavily driven by FOSS, which is not really driven by the same factors business are. Union or no union isn't really a question with FOSS, as these projects, many of which drive modern technology, were developed without traditional business incentives. Yes they're are businesses built around supporting open technology, but techs huge advances aren't driven only by companies. I think unionization would have less of an impact on tech advances than is being suggested.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by pizzetta on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:56AM (#14553189)
I could argue that if unions were strong and everyone had to belong to a union to participate in an economy the unions could see an advantage to controlling how you contribute to FOSS because your "free" contribution to FOSS impinges on the rights to another unionized worker's right to work. The FOSS developer would theoretically be undermining the union worker.
Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by csydas on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @11:29AM (#14553432)
Well, you certainly could, but that wasn't the argument presented or responded to. The argument you put forth was Technology's advancement was due to IT businesses, and what would the world be like if there were more Unions; but this is not really a sensible proposition because major technological advances, indeed the majority of which are driving the backbone of the world economy and technology as we know it, were developed without any of the incentives provided by a business structure. Union or not is irrelevant to such forces because they operate outside the realm of business.

The idea that FOSS would be quashed under a mandatory unionized economy is not what was being discussed, and I'm not sure of the relevance of such a theoretical world in the context of what was said. It's tangential at best.

What was being discussed, the advancement of technology as we've seen it, has happened independent of how employees are organized and employed. As long as there are inventive persons looking to try something new, there will be technological advancements.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by naravara on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @11:11AM (#14553304)
When unions are huge and cover large swathes of the workforce, they tend to be more focused on the long-term health of the industry/economy.

It’s when they’re small and parochial that they get really zealous about incumbency protection at the expense of everything else because they don’t have to balance competing interests the way you do when you have a bigger picture to worry about.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by _jal on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @11:48AM (#14553566)
I think there's an ordering problem. IT jobs have never faced union pressure because, in part, of massive, ongoing change and high wages.

Private prisons are not labs of innovation. "Innovation" in this context means maximining prison labor and cutting healthcare costs. Schools are similar - we don't know how to make them work better, but bullshit standardized testing and cutting wages isn't it.

I absolutely agree - not every work force should be unionized. I just wish folks would acknowledge that the titan-CEO/interchangeable wage-slave model is also leads to terrible outcomes in a number of industries.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by rainbowmverse on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:35AM (#14553013)
>> Imagine if unions were strong and IT were unionized. How would you imagine the progress we've seen in information technology?

We are a long way off from being able to say high technology has truly caused progress. Right now, it seems to do more harm than good. People in the tech industry are slowly coming to terms with their impact on the world outside their sphere of awareness, but that newfound conscientiousness hasn't translated into much change.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by pizzetta on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:41AM (#14553051)
I imagine the progress in microprocessors, photolithography, search, education, power generation, drugs discovery, communications, etc., etc., do have a measurable impact on progress of the species.

Imagine if tech were stuck where it was in even 1999. So many things possible today would not be possible (due to cost or unavailability).

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by ashark on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @11:10AM (#14553302)
> Imagine if tech were stuck where it was in even 1999. So many things possible today would not be possible (due to cost or unavailability).

Where tech directly touches my life, I wouldn't say today's tech makes me any happier or substantially improves my wellbeing over what 1999-level tech did. Worse in some ways. I do different stuff with 2017 tech than I would without it, but I doubt it's actually improving my life more than 1999 tech. I do have to remain up-to-date and immersed in it because it's an expectation of modern life and you'll drop out of what remains of shared culture and expectations of availability, et c if you don't (especially being a developer) but it's not per se especially appealing.

Self-driving cars (though I expect their benefit to largely be eaten up by race-to-the-bottom behavior or some form of rents capture, same as wide availability of personal automobiles mostly destroyed their time-saving benefits) and (even better) affordable, highly capable general-purpose housework robots would be a big deal for my quality of life, but we don't have those yet.

I'm sure industry and R&D applications of post-1999 tech improvements have been important, of course.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by mtdewcmu on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @12:15PM (#14553748)
The canonical counterexample to "who needs progress?" is medicine. I wouldn't want to be limited to the medical care from 1999 if all else is equal. Who needs to live with hepatitis C now that there's a cure?
Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by rainbowmverse on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:48AM (#14553116)
These things are good, but have so far been applied carelessly and unevenly. This is where my comment about conscientiousness comes in.

We need to start asking "For what purpose?" and "Who could this hurt?" more often. Packing more transistors into a CPU and working magic with algorithms to squeeze more out of them is not so good if it goes into a machine intended for surveillance and violating privacy, or to wipe out a million jobs because it can all be done by a few people now.

We can keep packing the transistors and working the magic, but it's going to keep doing a lot of damage if the people responsible don't think about the human impact.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by stale2002 on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @01:04PM (#14554113)
What are you talking about. Wiping out millions of jobs is a GOOD thing, not a bad thing.

I'd argue that it literally the entire point of technology.

"Destroying jobs" means that those people are freed up to do some else that is valuable and aren't wasting their time doing stuff that isn't worth anything to anybody.

Creating "jobs" is easy. Just implement a tax, and pay a bunch of people to dig holes and fill them up again.

Or do the modern equivalent of that and pay people to mess around with spreadsheets in an office and then throw away the spreadsheet.

At least that method of "job creation" is being honest.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by pizzetta on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:50AM (#14553136)
I wholeheartedly agree we spend much of our technology on both frivolous stuff and dangerous stuff (things that are detrimental to the wellbeing of people in general) -but the good offsets the negatives, I think.
Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:51AM (#14553145)
Anything can be used for good or evil. Its the wrong place to attack the problem - we can't live in the stone age because "somebody might misuse fire".
Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by rainbowmverse on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:55AM (#14553176)
Someone did invent the fire extinguisher and come up with Stop, Drop, and Roll, though. I'm not saying don't do new things. For example, Bandcamp giving me a way to download a list of people who've bought my music is like a fire extinguisher. If Bandcamp burns, I don't lose everything with it. That's conscientious of them. Most places that sell music don't offer that.
Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by crdoconnor on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @11:51AM (#14553592)
>Imagine if unions were strong and IT were unionized. How would you imagine the progress we've seen in information technology?

The following would likely happen:

* Wages would be higher, tech behemoth profits would be lower.

* Vastly more attention would be drawn to some of the worse outsourcing disasters (some of which are currently covered up).

* Those egregious IP agreements would be less common.

* Employee share options agreements would probably be fairer. Not like this: https://techcrunch.com/2011/06/26/skypes-worthless-employee-...

* Wage fixing cartels like this would be busted quicker: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...

>they also have externalities we need to acknowledge.

So acknowledge them?

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by stale2002 on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @01:14PM (#14554196)
Oooh how about these ones:

Your pay would be pegged to seniority, not ability to contribute. Better pay your dues, newbie. You don't deserve as much money as I do, solely because of your age.

You wouldn't be allowed to do anything outside your extremely limited job description. That's someone else's job, don't take it away from them! No more wearing many hats.

Unless you literally kill someone, you are immune from being fired. Irregardless if you suck and are holding the team back.

Find a good way to make your job more efficient? Sorry, you can't use that. It is not in your contract. And for that matter, doing things more efficiently means that there is less work to go around! Got to save jobs, by creating useless work!

Don't work too hard. You are making everyone else look bad! The contract says that we are only supposed to solve 1 bug a day.

You'd have to get some sort of union sponsored certification/significant barriers to entry, Because the union does not care about NEW workers. They want to keep them out so that they don't compete on wages with them. No more being a self taught engineer! No more switching to a different part of tech. You need a certification for that.

Collective bargaining means that you won't be able to negotiate on an individual basis. No matter how good at negotiating you are or if you could get 2-3X the pay, or if you think the union contract sucks.

Don't like the union? Too bad! You are forced to join it. Fuck you, you free rider! It doesn't matter if you believe that the union provides significant negatives, is corrupt, is destroying your industry and you shouldn't exist. Free rider! Free rider! Free rider!

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by crdoconnor on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @02:08PM (#14554685)
>Your pay would be pegged to seniority, not ability to contribute

That's pretty much how it works now. I've never had a boss who was able to accurately (or even non-accurately) gauge my productivity and I'll bet that unless your job is mind-numbing, you haven't either.

I've had bosses who have counted SLOC though and stupidly tried to use that to gauge my productivity.

Unions usually agree to formalize the existing peg to seniority so that the company doesn't use pay/promotion structure as a means to punish active union members.

>You wouldn't be allowed to do anything outside your extremely limited job description. That's someone else's job, don't take it away from them!

I'm strangely ok with my bosses not firing my coworker and then dumping all his work on me, which has happened to me.

>Find a good way to make your job more efficient? Sorry, you can't use that. It is not in your contract

This idea makes no sense to me. Furthermore, at a lot of the companies I've worked at, middle managers haven't given a damn about efficiency and they often purposefully reduced it so that they could increase their headcount (read: their power).

>Don't work too hard.

Am I supposed to be terrified of a company that makes me go home at a reasonable hour rather than implicitly pressuring me to stay at work until 10pm every night?

>The contract says that we are only supposed to solve 1 bug a day.

No it doesn't.

>You'd have to get some sort of union sponsored certification/significant barriers to entry, Because the union does not care about NEW workers.

Which may help separate some of the wheat from the chaff as it does with doctors. Are you in favor of this type of thing or would you prefer it was prevented?

http://www.edn.com/design/automotive/4423428/Toyota-s-killer...

>Collective bargaining means that you won't be able to negotiate on an individual basis.

Yes, and that means higher pay overall. Divide and conquer isn't good for you as an individual.

>No matter how good at negotiating you are

Didn't you just say that you thought pay should be linked to your ability to contribute? Why now are you so keen on "ability to negotiate"? Are you morally opposed to seeing my equally skilled friends earn as much as me because they don't drive a bargain quite as hard as I do?

>Don't like the union? Too bad! You are forced to join it. Fuck you, you free rider!

So are you pro-free rider?

You seem to be saying that individual agreements with the company are "good" but collective agreements with the company (which are used to eliminate said free riders) are "bad". Why are collective agreements intrinsically bad?

>It doesn't matter if you believe that the union provides significant negatives

It does, which is why unions are run on a democratic basis. On the other hand, did you vote for your boss? Thought not.

Unions serve as the only really reliable check on corrupt corporate power running roughshod over workers. Sometimes they are corrupt. That does not mean that eliminating them will improve your situation.

And, of course, if you really don't want to work for a unionized workplace you can go and work at a non-unionized workplace.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by stale2002 on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @03:51PM (#14555538)
" Why are collective agreements intrinsically bad?"

Because I should be able to do what I want, instead of being forced to go along with whatever stupid ideas the union chooses to do. It is called freedom of choice.

What if I want to negotiate for myself?

What if I want to wear multiple hats?

What if I want to work without getting a BS certification?

If I negotiate, and convince someone to hire me, then I can get all of these things.

We can agree and disagree about what makes a work environment good or bad. And thats fine. Just you do your thing, and I will do mine. If you don't like these things, then you can try to get a job that doesn't make you do them.

My relationship should be between me and my employer. I will negotiate all the things that I mentioned, and if the situation doesn't work out then I will vote with my feet and go somewhere else. Do not take away my right to free association.

Sure, fine, if you don't like doing those things, then you are free to join your own private organization and decide for yourself on how to do collective bargaining, and all that.

The problem with pro-union people is that they assume that their needs are the same as everyone else's needs. Different people want different things, and this whole "fight for the people" BS gets thrown out the window the moment you try and force me to join your org and force me to go along with stuff I don't agree with.

"And, of course, if you really don't want to work for a unionized workplace you can go and work at a non-unionized workplace."

Well, instead of doing this thing, I could just use the law to protect me. Forcing people to join unions is, thankfully, illegal in many states.

And, thankfully, unions are very unpopular among techies. So I am doing precisely that, and I will continue to fight against them in tech, precisely because I do not want our industry to be turned into one that does not value freedom of choice among employees, and forces different people into associations that they don't agree with.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by crdoconnor on Thursday June 15, 2017 @04:37AM (#14558759)
>Sure, fine, if you don't like doing those things, then you are free to join your own private organization and decide for yourself on how to do collective bargaining, and all that.

I'm struggling to see what your problem is. If you don't like the idea of democratic control over your workplace and the commensurately higher pay that goes with it you've always been free to go and work somewhere else where they let you "wear many hats".

It seems more like that you want to prevent others from doing it:

>Forcing people to join unions is, thankfully, illegal in many states.

i.e. you're thankful groups of people who negotiate with other groups of people and form voluntary agreements are prevented from doing so.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by stale2002 on Thursday June 15, 2017 @12:19PM (#14561766)
No, others can do all those things all they want.

They can get together with their groups of friends and bargain collectively. They just shouldn't be able to force me to bargain collectively along with them.

They can get together and form voluntary agreements. They just can't make me join their voluntary agreements or stop me from making my own agreements with anyone.

And we can see who gets the better deal.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by piva00 on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @11:51AM (#14553588)
I recommend looking up the union/labour movement model of Sweden. It's a three-way between unions, employers and government to get into agreements, doesn't seem to be hurting Swedish economy (nor its IT industry).
Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by arximboldi on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @12:08PM (#14553690)
> Imagine if unions were strong and IT were unionized. How would you imagine the progress we've seen in information technology?

I imagine less bullshit businesses selling air castles built on top of an exploitative operation. I imagine better democratic processes inside companies. I imagine using collective power to protect underrepresented groups instead of fighting against each other. A net benefit to society.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by blahblab on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @01:36PM (#14554396)
I don't have to imagine, I'm a unionized programmer. I've worked in private industry too and switching out an individual vs collective contract hasn't degraded my skills one iota.

I will say that Government is bureaucratic, but no more than any comparably sized corporation. Our only problem is that our shareholders are fucking morons.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by yequalsx on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:44AM (#14553083)
I think most groundbreaking research is government sponsored. A lot of it at universities which are unionized.

Instead of unions substitute the phrase "sane worker protections, pay, and rights". The U.S. is badly in need of better labor laws and much greater enforcement of those laws.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by pizzetta on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:47AM (#14553111)
>I think most groundbreaking research is government sponsored

And I think many of the researchers are the oft exploited grad students and the like who are not typically bound by union agreements --some staff and contractors may be unionized, but not most of the people doing the drudgery work that goes into research, at least in the US.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by BoiledCabbage on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @01:21PM (#14554260)
> Imagine if unions were strong and IT were unionized. How would you imagine the progress we've seen in information technology?

Unions would've collectively bargained and agreed not to work for companies that abuse H1-B visa farms. And this whole issue would've been resolved ages ago.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by pizzetta on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @02:33PM (#14554887)
I'll grant you that --but while that protects domestic workers it may hurt domestic industry in that some things would be cheaper to develop in locales with less unionization or simply lower labor costs.
[dead]
Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by sctb on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @02:25PM (#14554819)
Continuing to comment like this will get your account banned.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by Consultant32452 on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @12:53PM (#14554013)
It's important to apply context to this. A minimum wage, among other things, forces businesses to prejudice against lower skilled workers. If the minimum wage is negotiated by the union to $18/hr but you only produce $10/hr due to lack of experience, disability, below average IQ, or you went to a failing public school then you're simply unemployed. If we remove this contractual minimum wage, you're right, it would likely have some minimal impact for the people on the margins of having productivity sufficient to justify hiring them on the union's minimum wage. However, everyone below that level of productivity now has the potential for new jobs, and with those jobs comes skills training and economic mobility. Unions do marginally help their members, but they harm everyone below them on the economic ladder.
Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by pdeuchler on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @07:10PM (#14556755)
The incorrect assumption here is that people earn what value they produce. People actually earn (value_produced - profit + bargaining power). The reason for upping the minimum wage is all minimum wage worker unions have disappeared and an increase in the low skill labor market supply (mostly due to the loss of manufacturing in the US) have decimated bargaining power across the board. Plus, due to automation, a single say, McDonalds worker, "produces" much more value than his counterpart 20 years ago without commiserate increase in salary even accounting for a loss in bargaining power (i.e. the profit variable has shot up, meaning an unequal share in the benefits of the labor).

Of course, that's just the high level theory... using just common sense those same workers are going to be automated away entirely, if the wage is 20 cents or 20 dollars it doesn't matter. So we might as well force companies to compensate them in the short term for their impending unemployment.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by Consultant32452 on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @10:43PM (#14557560)
Two key things occurred during the time period you're talking about where wages stagnated in spite of massive increases in productivity growth. The first is that we actually started letting women get jobs. We increased the labor supply by nearly 40%. It's amazing that wages are not even lower than they are. The second thing that happened is that millions upon millions of unskilled immigrants crossed the border. This also, obviously significantly increased the pool of labor at the bottom of the economic ladder further suppressing wages.
Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by pravda on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @01:00PM (#14554081)
>Just compare for profit higher education with public higher education. The wages/benefits for workers former very much lag those of the latter.

And here appears the Broken Window Fallacy!

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @01:11PM (#14554162)
What exactly do you think is "broken" when a worker gets higher pay?

In the Broken Window Fallacy story, the total wealth in the system is decreased when the window is destroyed. In this example, no wealth is destroyed, it is just distributed differently. If you believe that wealth has a decreasing marginal utility as you become more wealthy, the more even distribution where the worker is paid more has a higher overall utility even though the total wealth is exactly the same.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by sharemywin on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @02:16PM (#14554758)
"decreasing marginal utility"

I know I'm bastardizing the meaning but it got me thinking about Elon Musk versus "prototypical lotto winner that loses everything" you could certainly argue that he is using his wealth(as well as others) to benefit society, ie. mars, electrification of transportation, etc.

Re:The Hidden Cost of Privatization by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @05:03PM (#14556106)
But if you count that then you also have to count the billionaires spending money lobbying to be allowed to continue pumping carbon into the atmosphere or for more bombs to be built. If you start using that method of calculating utility, I wouldn't be surprised if the marginal utility is actually negative at some point.