News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @02:08PM (#14539449)
Overall good post, but:

Yesterday, I had a wide-ranging Slack conversation with some very nice people who patiently allowed this privileged white male to repeatedly touch the third rail of diversity and inclusion. That conversation led me to the realizations in this post. I’ll thank them by not naming them, and by promising never to bring this up in their Slack channel again.

In other words, people openly hated on him for wanting to discuss something with them and get informed -- a white male in a position of power that few women or poc occupy. And all they can do is make him scared to bring it up again and act like the abuse they heaped upon him is some sort of privilege he didn't deserve or something.

Wow.

I am so sick of women and people of color being openly hateful to people who were born the "wrong" gender and color to be part of the unfortunate many. Hello? Whining about how "it isn't my job to explain this stuff to you!" instead of being all "OMG! An opportunity to have a useful conversation with a white male who is actually curious about how the so-called other half live!" is part of the problem, not part of the solution.

(Before you auto-downvote this on the assumption that I am some overprivileged asshole man, please note I am a woman.)

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Indy_Dh on Monday June 12, 2017 @02:23PM (#14539614)
This was brought up in a post below, but the first sentence is hard to decipher. I think "patiently allowed" here implies that they kindly answered his questions even though he was touching the third rail.

In other words he was afraid of being hated on for opening the dialogue, but the people on the Slack channel were fully willing to engage.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @02:40PM (#14539782)
I’ll thank them ... by promising never to bring this up in their Slack channel again.

That reads to me like "It was a shit show, I got the crap kicked out of me. I am trying to be PC." The patience part comes in where they attempted to answer his questions at all instead of merely dogpiling him with a mountain of hatred.

If they were genuinely that patient and kind, why is it described as "touching the third rail"? Genuinely patient and kind people don't make you feel like you are going to be electrocuted for broaching a topic.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by gr3yh47 on Monday June 12, 2017 @02:55PM (#14539950)
It reads to me like he knew it was an awkward conversation and out of gratitude would rather not subject them to that again.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @02:58PM (#14539986)
Funny, when I have productive conversations with men actually willing to listen to my side, it is such a rare and wonderful privilege that I am eager to repeat the experience. (This may explain my position on HN as the highest ranked woman here. Enough men genuinely engage me on difficult subjects, it is worth putting up with whatever crap goes along with it.)

Your interpretation in no way succeeds in changing mine.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by HelloMcFly on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:09PM (#14540097)
> Your interpretation in no way succeeds in changing mine.

It doesn't have to, as there is sufficient ambiguity in the writing to make either interpretation iron-clad. Yet I shared the same interpretation as the commenter you responded to, and was surprised by yours. I now see your perspective, though it rings less true to me.

Although, I do think it's borderline inarguable that you are reading too much into the personality traits of the Slack channel members (e.g., "hateful") with far too little information to justify the strength of the words. If those descriptions weren't intended for the Slack channel participants but more of a general comment, then that makes more sense.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:15PM (#14540142)
Although, I do think it's borderline inarguable that you are reading too much into the personality traits of the Slack channel members (e.g., "hateful") with far too little information to justify the strength of the words.

That is a misinterpretation of my remark. I have personally seen this firsthand over and over. My general remark that I am sick of seeing it does not attribute hatefulness per se to the discussion members. I still seriously doubt that it was a very warm fuzzy conversation. I think the author of the piece is being incredibly charitable.

Just look at how I am being attacked here to give you some inkling of how such conversations typically go. It is hard enough to get privileged white males to be genuinely respectful to each other in an internet conversation. That used to be kind of a given on HN, which deteriorated over time. I hope to see that sort of atmosphere return here -- it does seem to be improving -- but I hope it also includes the women in a way they never were before.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Paul-ish on Monday June 12, 2017 @04:49PM (#14541006)
Talking about what was said in the slack channel would distract readers from the main point he was trying to make in the post. If anything he should have said less, as it is clear some still want to discuss the slack channel more than his main point.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @04:58PM (#14541056)
I do a lot of blogging. I also get paid to do freelance work, often for business sites, where I get explicit instruction to say nothing negative. This is sometimes an incredibly challenging thing to do.

There was no gun to his head to comment on this discussion at all. He was under zero obligation to describe it as a slack channel or even an online discussion. He was under zero obligation to give what description of it he did. He could have easily said something incredibly generic about "Discussions I have been fortunate to be privy to suggest...."

The fact that he had to spend an entire paragraph not talking about the contents of the discussion and trying ever so hard to be PC while the pain of that discussion clearly bled through in his framing of his comments speaks to how not well it actually went. It is entirely possible to just say nothing about things you wish to say nothing about. I do that pretty often.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by alew1 on Monday June 12, 2017 @02:23PM (#14539607)
You're making a lot of assumptions for someone who hasn't seen that Slack conversation.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by erikpukinskis on Monday June 12, 2017 @04:44PM (#14540966)
Straw feminists are frightening.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @04:46PM (#14540981)
I don't self identify as a feminist. So if you mean me, you are in error.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by erikpukinskis on Monday June 12, 2017 @05:51PM (#14541415)
Straw feminists are fictional feminists that live in hypothetical situations like your parent's comment.

http://www.harkavagrant.com/?id=341

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @06:18PM (#14541577)
Well, I feel a tad lost (in terms of what you were intending with your remark), but count me educated. Thank you for the link.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by erikpukinskis on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @04:41PM (#14555950)
I was agreeing with you, and providing an emotional basis for your OP's attitude!
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Wednesday June 14, 2017 @04:47PM (#14555998)
Ah. Gotcha.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by kevinh on Monday June 12, 2017 @02:28PM (#14539670)
You got the opposite vibe from that paragraph than I did, but assuming you're correct about what happened:

Why should the onus be on the minority to be required to have a conversation with everyone who comes up to them and says something ignorant?

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @02:45PM (#14539836)
I am not talking about an onus on the minority to have a conversation with everyone who comes up to them and says something ignorant.

But the current openly hostile position that so many underprivileged people take shuts down real conversation. And it basically assumes that privileged peoples are supposed to somehow psychically know what their lives are like while they refuse to inform the people who are in the best position to make their lives better by being more informed. How on earth are white males supposed to learn what the lives and experiences of women and poc are like if no one will have a conversation with them? Do you think being openly hateful to them opens their minds and makes them more understanding? I don't.

FYI, I am not only a woman, I am the top ranked woman here. Maybe there is some correlation between my attitude and the in-roads I am making on HN.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by epmaybe on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:20PM (#14540186)
How does your rank on HN as a female matter for us to get your point? To me, the FYIs (which I have seen at least two of your comments in this thread) aren't letting your comments stand on their own merits.

For what it's worth, your point makes sense and I agree with it. However, it didn't seem like the author of the article had a hateful experience, so much as an awkward one.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by dragonwriter on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:26PM (#14540236)
> FYI, I am not only a woman, I am the top ranked woman here.

How do you know? I mean, it's not like HN profiles have mandatory gender field, and there are higher-ranked profiles than yours that don't link to external profiles or provide real names from which (risky) guesses can easily be made about gender, and whose comment/post history doesn't, on a quick review, give any direct indication of the user's gender.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:30PM (#14540276)
I spent some time gathering data because I was getting what seemed to me to be a fuckton of excess pushback for someone who was a big fat nobody with a paltry amount of karma. There is a quick and dirty summary of the data here:

http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2015/01/some-raw-dat...

I usually couch it in terms of "I appear to be the highest ranked openly female member here" because, no, there is no absolute way to know. But I have also been saying that for something over two years and, so far, no one has jumped up and said "Nope! HERE is a link to HNmembername who is openly female and outranks you!" Given that this is HN, I consider that fact to be probably strong evidence that no one knows of any openly female members who outrank me.

Of course, this does not preclude the possibility that there is a woman with more karma who is actively hiding her gender. But even if there is, that still makes my typical framing -- apparently highest ranked openly female member -- an accurate statement.

Edit: Just as an FYI, I upvoted you. It is a perfectly reasonable question to ask and the framing is perfectly reasonable. I don't know why people are downvoting you. That sucks. Meanwhile, some other comment that is being genuinely dismissive of me and the pertinence of my "rank" here is being upvoted. And that sucks even more.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by zepto on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:13PM (#14540128)
I don't think the openly hostile posture is good, nor do I think the general theories of social justice are doing much good anymore.

However you actually are saying that 'minorities' need to have conversations with ignorant people.

How understanding these ignorant people are is not a function of how 'minorities' respond to them - by which I mean that many people will not be able to have an open mind or become understanding even if they are treated like princes and princesses.

One effective way 'white males' can learn more is to find other white males who have successfully navigated this space and learn from them.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:22PM (#14540198)
Saying that such conversations are needed in the world in no way suggests that there is an onus on specific people to have them with every random asshole who blurts something awful. There is a difference.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by beat on Monday June 12, 2017 @04:03PM (#14540590)
The flip side (based on my observations as a white male who actively engages in social justice) is that many women and minorities are so utterly sick and tired of harassment and obliviousness from white men that they simply have no patience for the engagement anymore. I can't say I blame them. I tire of the fight too - and I know it's my privilege that allows me to retreat when I'm tired of it.

I really appreciate those who can stay active and upbeat when trying to educate the privileged, but I understand those who can't. I don't think I could.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @04:37PM (#14540906)
I tire of the fight too

I really appreciate those who can stay active and upbeat when trying to educate the privileged, but I understand those who can't. I don't think I could.

I am not looking for a fight. I am actively looking for a conversation, in good faith that is as respectful as possible from both sides, given that we are all human, we all have crappy days and stupid baggage and words on a screen are a very hard way to communicate. If I thought I was fighting some battle, I imagine I would tire of it too.

And that is kind of the entire point of all my comments here. You aren't required to go looking for a fight in order to try to make the world a better place. In fact, you are probably going to be more successful if you stop approaching it that way.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by zepto on Monday June 12, 2017 @07:35PM (#14541982)
So why did you start this by openly attacking women and PoC?

"I am so sick of women and people of color being openly hateful to people who were born the "wrong" gender and color to be part of the unfortunate many."

Seems like it's ok if you just slander and attack whole groups, but you aren't interested in a rebuttal which only attacks your statement and not your race or gender.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by beat on Tuesday June 13, 2017 @11:05AM (#14545293)
Sometimes, it's a conversation, and that's great. Sometimes, it's a battle.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by zepto on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:40PM (#14540357)
Sure - but lots of well meaning people calmly say awful things too, and it's no different to be on the receiving end - maybe even worse.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:46PM (#14540434)
And if they genuinely are well meaning, they are usually open to getting some push back. It isn't necessary to hate on people in order to inform them "Well, that isn't how it works if you are X."

One of the things that most opened my eyes to racism was when I was dealing with the DMV and it was incredibly frustrating. There seemed to be no means whatsoever to fix my issue. And then the black person at the counter walked over to their white boss and straightfacedly lied "She never got her bill." At that point, all I had to do was pay a late fee and, voila, my stint in DMV purgatory was over. (I had driven a thousand miles with expired plates to handle this debacle in person and was still hitting a wall until this person did that.)

That clued me that blacks routinely deal with "Fuck you, no, it can't be solved" situations that are not the norm for white people. It made me vastly more informed and sympathetic. It did not make me feel alienated.

I know far too many people on the internet who claim they want the world to be a better place, but by their actions it is clear that they take it as a given that the lord of the flies pecking order bs is just how the world works and cannot be solved. They just want to change who gets shit upon and gets to do the shitting.

Is it any wonder that people in privileged positions aren't very friendly to their proposition that "No, YOU should be the designated toilet of the world, and I should be one of the people who gets to shit on you!"

I would like to see a world in which we all agree that shitting on other people is not ok, no matter who they are.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by zepto on Monday June 12, 2017 @04:13PM (#14540682)
Seems like you think that the legacy of slavery and institutionalized racism is equivalent to unkind words on the internet.

Personally I'd only call one of these 'shitting on other people'.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @04:32PM (#14540859)
Words on the internet really caused this heterosexual male some serious problems: http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2014/11/having-sad.h...

Words on the internet and via text message probably helped drive this man to suicide:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/true-crime/wp/2017/06/10...

My mother always said "Two wrongs don't make a right."

I don't see how taking your anger out on random strangers somehow fixes anything in your life.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by zepto on Monday June 12, 2017 @07:19PM (#14541912)
By supporting your position with these examples, it sure seems like you are continuing to try to equate the two.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @07:22PM (#14541924)
By ignoring these two examples, it sure seems like you are continuing to justify a desire for revenge, which has nothing to do with trying to make life better in the here and now and in the future for women, poc, etc.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by zepto on Monday June 12, 2017 @07:34PM (#14541976)
For what it's worth - I think it's terrible when anyone kills themselves as a result of psychological suffering caused by another.

Not only that but there are clearly examples of straight up murder by PoC and women.

Claiming that because of this you get to dismiss the legacy of racism and institutionalized racism, is a straight up defense of racism and white supremacy.

Nice job.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @07:40PM (#14542001)
No, that isn't what I claimed at all. And you twisting my statements in that way belies your statements elsewhere that you aren't angry.

I am sorry for whatever it is you have suffered that you are so angry.

I have a very deadly medical condition. I am homeless. I was sexually abused as a child.

I am also getting healthier, paying off debts and I am the top ranked woman on Hacker News which is helping me further my personal goals. Because I spent a lot of years working to put my anger down and stop using every person I ran into as a scratching post to sharpen my claws.

Whatever other shitty thing you say to me next, I think I am done with this conversation. Because you are dragging me down to your level and failing to see that no one here wants to listen to your side precisely because you are being so consistently ugly.

And that is exactly my point. I am the top ranked woman here because I don't come in here and kick the shit out of every man here for simply being born male. I do, however, stand up for myself and give push back when I feel that is appropriate. There is a difference between those two things. They are NOT synonymous.

That is getting results and it breaks the cycle of "who gets to be the designated toilet in our Lord of the Flies society?"

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by zepto on Tuesday June 13, 2017 @12:19PM (#14545934)
You don't come here and kick the crap out of every man, but you happily do so to women and PoC:

This statement of yours is overtly sexist and racist.

"I am so sick of women and people of color being openly hateful to people who were born the "wrong" gender and color to be part of the unfortunate many."

Compare it to this version:

"I am so sick of people being openly hateful to people who were born the "wrong" gender and color"

I'm sorry you have suffered in your life, but that, and your Hacker News Karma score is not a license to make racist or sexist comments and not expect them to be rebutted.

You say that from your point of view there are 'sides' in this. It's clear which one you have chosen. It's actually not anyone else's duty to try to change that. If you don't like how you feel when people respond to what you say - that is your problem to solve.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by cname on Monday June 12, 2017 @02:19PM (#14539560)
How did you get from "very nice people" to "hateful" and "whiny"?
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Red_Tarsius on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:55PM (#14540525)
Thank you for pointing out that quote.

I can't imagine anyone saying that sentence in Italian with a straight face. Translating those words really puts things into perspective. It sounds self-hating and humiliating. I wonder what the long-term effects of this culture are going to be.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by thatwebdude on Monday June 12, 2017 @02:34PM (#14539735)
I think more of this levels the playing field for all.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by s73ver on Monday June 12, 2017 @05:40PM (#14541355)
Especially recently, for every one person who actually is sincere in their desire to learn and grow, there can be three or more people who are trying to be a concern troll or are otherwise asking in bad faith.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @05:56PM (#14541455)
That isn't news to me.

But a problem I face is that when I try to inform and empower women, I am often viciously attacked and accused of "blaming the victim."

I was sexually abused as a child. I have thought long and hard about this problem space. I don't believe we will see real progress until we can stop assuming that women are always the victim in any interaction with men, men are always abusive and men are the only ones who can change this situation.

And I find it baffling that people seem to not see that the position that the onus is entirely on men to change their behavior is an excellent way to make sure women remain disempowered victims.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by jolux on Monday June 12, 2017 @02:26PM (#14539647)
"I am so sick of women and people of color being openly hateful to people who were born the "wrong" gender and color to be part of the unfortunate many."

Really? So now being born white and male is the "wrong" color and gender? Those are identities that are near the apex of privilege in our society. As a white man, being afraid to ask questions for fear of being unintentionally racist or sexist is nowhere near comparable to the actual experience of racism and sexism. God forbid we hurt a white man's feelings while discussing social justice. That would be a true injustice.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by stouset on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:08PM (#14540085)
This is an infuriatingly unhelpful attitude.

Presumably the goal is to encourage people who lack awareness about issues surrounding racism and sexism to both become aware and to actually care about these problems. And to change their behavior, to the extent that it should change.

Unnecessarily attacking, humiliating, or embarrassing a person who is willfully admitting their own ignorance and seeking a better understanding of the situation is so obviously counterproductive that I can't believe I'm having to write this comment. This is not the way to win people to your side — in fact, it's completely the opposite. Doing so only causes both sides to become more firmly entrenched in their beliefs and less likely to try and discuss the issue further. By giving them a positive experience, you not only increase the likelihood of them seriously considering your arguments, but you also open the door for them to come back to the table for discussion again, even if you didn't win them over the first time around.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by didgeoridoo on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:52PM (#14540487)
> Presumably the goal is to encourage people who lack awareness about issues surrounding racism and sexism to both become aware and to actually care about these problems. And to change their behavior, to the extent that it should change.

For some, this is the goal. Unfortunately, they tend to be drowned out by those who find the experience of loudly attacking and embarrassing "privileged" folk to be cathartic and uplifting — a goal unto itself.

Evergreen College professor Bret Weinstein made a great point on a podcast earlier this week: "You have the real equity movement which are people who wish to end oppression, and then you have another movement that wishes to reverse oppression. And they don't know that they are different, because until you reach equity, they're pointing in the same direction."

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:56PM (#14540534)
"You have the real equity movement which are people who wish to end oppression, and then you have another movement that wishes to reverse oppression. And they don't know that they are different, because until you reach equity, they're pointing in the same direction."

I think the difference is pretty readily discernible. I don't think they point in the same direction at all. The difference is between "Can you help me up off the pavement and help me dust myself off, given that you are standing above me and have strength I lack?" and "Hey, lay down on the pavement so I can shit all over you because someone who looks kind of like you shit all over me and it's my turn. That's only fair."

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by zepto on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:17PM (#14540164)
Right - clearly it is the job of women and PoC to give positive experiences to white men otherwise they cannot expect to be treated well.

It is also clearly not the responsibility of white men to give positive experiences to PoC and women, because they can't be expected to understand how if they aren't first given positive experiences by PoC and women.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by stouset on Monday June 12, 2017 @04:15PM (#14540708)
It's not a duty or responsibility. And it's not unproductive as a sibling commenter suggests. It's straight up counterproductive and a form of self-sabotage.

If your goal is to feel self-righteous and superior, by all means attack those who are showing genuine interest in coming over to your side. If your goal is to actually bring about a positive change in society, perhaps it's worthwhile to consider a different approach.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by zepto on Monday June 12, 2017 @07:22PM (#14541926)
This is based on an almost ludicrously simplistic straw man: you conjure up the idea of someone who is "showing genuine interest in coming over you your side"

How are they 'showing' this exactly? What makes it 'genuine' that they want to come over to another side? Why are they on a 'side' in the first place, and what makes you think that the goal is to have them change 'sides'? Are you saying they are not already on 'our side'? What does that imply? How can you distinguish their arguments from those of people who simply want to argue their position and remain ignorant?

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by FT_intern on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:23PM (#14540208)
Attacking someone for ignorance is very unproductive
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by zepto on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:38PM (#14540351)
So why do white men do it to women and PoC, or is your claim that ignorance only exists on one side of this?

You imply that while men can do nothing for themselves unless given positive experiences by women an PoC.

This is obviously false, since there are plenty of white men who have a good understanding of these issues.

Stop blaming women and PoC for your own ignorance and go and learn something from people who have figured this stuff out.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by stouset on Monday June 12, 2017 @04:20PM (#14540743)
I can think of virtually no better example to prove my point than the contents of this exchange.

So thank you for helping me to demonstrate to everyone else in this thread that speaking from anger, constructing and attacking the flimsiest of straw men, and repeatedly misconstruing a sympathetic counterparty's points only serves to push away the people you might hope to see your point of view.

I genuinely hope it was satisfying for you, because that's about the only positive outcome that's likely to arise for you out of this.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by zepto on Monday June 12, 2017 @07:16PM (#14541900)
Try reading what I am saying without projecting anger into it. Just because it's not to your liking doesn't mean it's angry.

Also - there is nothing you have said that indicates you are a sympathetic counterparty. How do you expect us to know that? Therein lies the problem.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by jolux on Monday June 12, 2017 @04:35PM (#14540902)
I'm not actually saying we should attack people for being ignorant, I'm saying that if a white guy gets offended while trying to learn that it's less of a problem than the actual object of our activism.

Frankly if I have to argue with this person and tiptoe around their fragile ego in discussing these things I'm not sure we want them in the first place. Allyship is complex and defined finally by those you are allied with.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by stouset on Monday June 12, 2017 @11:34PM (#14542709)
> ...if a white guy gets offended while trying to learn that it's less of a problem than the actual object of our activism.

Nobody is arguing this.

Here's the thing though: it doesn't matter if one problem is worse than the other, at least as to the point people are trying to make in this thread.

When activists are openly hostile or otherwise inflammatory to people who are sympathetic to but not yet behind the activists' cause, they undermine that cause by pushing away and alienating the very people who are signaling that they're on the cusp of changing their perspective. Those people who held out an olive branch only to have it knocked aside are less likely to become allies in the future.

> Frankly if I have to argue with this person and tiptoe around their fragile ego in discussing these things I'm not sure we want them in the first place.

I'm sorry, but this is phenomenally short-sighted. This is how the human psyche works. Virtually any person who's been converted to your cause started from a position of disagreement, went through a transition period where they started to question longstanding beliefs and assumptions, learned to empathize with people who were harmed by the status quo, and eventually discarded or significantly amended those original beliefs. You will be hard-pressed to find a psychologist who will suggest that ridiculing or attacking a person in that transition period will do anything but turn them away and calcify their original position.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by jolux on Tuesday June 13, 2017 @01:47PM (#14546858)
>Those people who held out an olive branch only to have it knocked aside are less likely to become allies in the future.

You're still acting like people are doing us a favor by trying to understand us.

They aren't, and we deserve better than that: either deal with us substantively or dismiss us, but don't expect us to try and manipulate your biases in such a way that you end up agreeing with us. That's what you're asking when you say we should try to convince people.

>You will be hard-pressed to find a psychologist who will suggest that ridiculing or attacking a person in that transition period will do anything but turn them away and calcify their original position.

And yet, I've seen the opposite of this happen time and time again. When people are ready to learn, it looks a lot different than this. When people aren't ready, yeah, this is basically what happens. Not to mention that if you talk to a psychologist about rational argument they'll tell you it's a quirk of human cognition, not the rule, and that it's basically futile as a means of really convincing someone.

If they really support us they'll understand eventually and come around. If they don't, they won't. I say this because it happened to me, and here I am arguing with you about this. It takes a very mature person to want to understand these things, and not everybody is mature enough.

This whole concept that we have to be nice to bigots lest they become more bigoted is hugely abusive and unhelpful, and you've yet to justify it.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by gizmo on Tuesday June 13, 2017 @08:08AM (#14544173)
> they undermine that cause by pushing away and alienating the very people who are signaling that they're on the cusp of changing their perspective

You have repeatedly made this assertion, but you have made no effort to substantiate it. Why do you think you're in a better position to judge what works and what doesn't than the activists who deal with this stuff every day? Being hostile towards people who are ignorant and react indignantly when their ignorance is pointed out is a strategy, and one that seems to work. Sure, some people don't take criticism well and you lose them. But some people _will_ listen, improve their behavior, and will eventually become worthwhile allies.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Tuesday June 13, 2017 @01:12PM (#14546444)
You have repeatedly made this assertion, but you have made no effort to substantiate it.

(I am not the person you are replying to, but) I have actually offered myself as an example in this discussion, which has been repeatedly pissed on. I am the top ranked woman on HN, in spite of never having had a tech job. When I still had relatively little karma, I was noticing that men on the leaderboard were closing ranks and things were getting what felt kind of ugly on my end. I was getting remarks that suggested to me that I was "prominent" for a woman here. I gathered data to verify that and soon concluded that I was rather high ranking for a woman, in spite of my low score.

I have worked really hard to move certain people out of my way without turning it into a fight and to participate in good faith and so on. I am noticing in recent months that other women are benefitting from the changes here, which weren't simply wrought by me, it is far more complicated than that.

Of course, I have known lots of people in life who will simply dismiss whatever I have accomplished with some convenient explanation like "survivor bias" or "that's just your opinion" or even "It is wild coincidence, stranger things have happened." People seem to basically believe what they already believe. Confirmation bias seems to make most people interpret all events through the lens of their current mental models and getting people to consider others is quite hard.

I did not originally set out to become anyone of influence on Hacker News, but after discovering that I had fairly high rank for a woman in spite of zero ambition, I decided to run with it. And I went from something silly like 4k karma to currently above 19k karma in probably a shorter time than it took me to get that original 4k. Furthermore, I no longer see men on the leaderboard routinely closing ranks to exclude me and things like that. The atmosphere has changed and without a battle.

I am expecting this comment of mine to also be torn apart and pissed on, which is par for the course for this type of comment. Nonetheless, I am leaving it "for the record" in hopes that it causes some people to think, even though it is highly unlikely to change your mind at all.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by jolux on Tuesday June 13, 2017 @01:51PM (#14546899)
For what it's worth, I upvoted you.

Nonetheless, I think you're making a bit of a generalization here from messageboard karma to the real world.

The community here on HN is self selected for a particular kind of person, and the people that would be on my side in this discussion really tend to avoid this board for similar reasons.

I have no doubt that you'll get more karma for being cordial instead of abrasive, respectable instead of radical. But I care very little about how much karma I have.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by Mz on Tuesday June 13, 2017 @03:30PM (#14547842)
Eh, karma is far easier to point to than the things I actually pay the most attention to. I also cannot fathom why people make this sort of distinction between cyberspace and meatspace. People get jobs and work and meet future spouses and on and on via online forums. There are an awful lot of real world movers and shakers right here on Hacker News.

Best. Have a good day.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by jolux on Tuesday June 13, 2017 @04:13PM (#14548191)
>I also cannot fathom why people make this sort of distinction between cyberspace and meatspace.

I don't, in general, I just meant that randos online are not the target of my activism, and I'm not currently trying to conduct myself in such a way that they become allies. That's all.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by WalterSear on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:24PM (#14540212)
If the outcome you want is empathy, you need to demonstrate it. If you don't demonstrate it, you are essentially dehumanizing yourself in the conversation, making it harder for others to empathize with you.

Then again, >whatever< outcome you want, you will need more empathy: you are not demonstrating enough empathy here in order to outwit an adversary, let alone to foster productive egalitarian relationships.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by jolux on Monday June 12, 2017 @04:31PM (#14540847)
Yeah but empathy is not the outcome I want at least; the outcome I want is to reverse the material inequities that foster oppression. I don't care whether or not you have empathy for victims of racism and sexism, they don't just need empathy, they fucking need help.
Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by WalterSear on Monday June 12, 2017 @07:17PM (#14541902)
Empathy is not sympathy.

Empathy is the ability to model another individual's internal state. Sympathy is resonance with the emotional value of that state.

The more empathy you have for someone, the better you are able to anticipate and meet (or thwart) their needs. I can hope you will win a game of chess (sympathy) whether or not I can guess the next move you will make (empathy).

Empathy is the outcome you want. Racism, sexism - objectification is the inability to model another's internal state sufficiently.

Material restitution would not change these underlying dynamics, and, moreover, is hinged on an implied subsequent social egalitarianism that it does little to bring about. Reverse those material inequities without denormalizing the attitudes that put them there, and it's only matter of time until the inequities will return: nothing has been actually been done about the root cause. For that, empathy for the outgroup in question has to occur, to the point where people do not make the misapprehensions that are dehumanization, and treat them with the respect they deserve in an egalitarian society.

If you think this is impossible or unnecessary to achieve, then the reversal of material inequities you seek will only happen under the barrel of a gun - one pointed specifically at those groups who you consider responsible for the status quo. Moreover, in order to take that attitude, you implicitly judge them as incapable or undeserving of an egalitarian status in society. In other words, the specific discrimination of a group, based on their dehumanization. So, how is this not 'fostering oppression'? :)

Society exists under the tacit assumption that all our needs are being met appropriately. This may not be accurate, but only through empathy can that assumption be challenged appropriately.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by jolux on Monday June 12, 2017 @08:15PM (#14542148)
>Reverse those material inequities without denormalizing the attitudes that put them there, and it's only matter of time until the inequities will return: nothing has been actually been done about the root cause.

Yes, but this problem is not a lack of empathy. Racists have plenty of empathy, it's just conditional on race. This liberal doctrine that empathy is the real problem is completely absurd. Empathy is for little kids who hit somebody and need to be taught to apologize.

The kind of environment that we have which fosters racialized hyperviolence is a little beyond the scope of empathy. Stuff needs to change at a material and structural level, reducing this to empathy at an individual level is a key fallacy of liberalism.

>the reversal of material inequities you seek will only happen under the barrel of a gun

You do realize that this is a very key strain of radical thought starting in Maoism, right? I'm not saying I'm a Maoist, I'm just saying that yes, there are people who believe that, and yes, they have a lot of reasons for it.

>one pointed specifically at those groups who you consider responsible for the status quo.

And why shouldn't it be, metaphorically speaking? The responsibility for oppressive systems which were constituted by a certain class to benefit said class (white, wealthy, male, etc) absolutely falls at the feet of that class.

>Moreover, in order to take that attitude, you implicitly judge them as incapable or undeserving of an egalitarian status in society.

They are deserving of egalitarian status just as much as anyone else. Unfortunately, the culture we live in is currently structured such that they are the only people who are treated as equals. Everyone else is the result of an imperfect striving towards that ideal.

This is the difference between Black Lives Matter and All Lives Matter. Of course All Lives Matter, but certain lives are under direct threat for the color of their skin and nothing else.

If I sound like I'm dehumanizing white men, it's because white men took it upon themselves to dehumanize everyone else, and I consider that violently inhumane. Nonetheless, their humanity is not in question, and they are in a good place to defend it themselves, and thus it needs little protection from me.

>So, how is this not 'fostering oppression'? :)

Yeah, completely lost you here. Sorry.

>Society exists under the tacit assumption that all our needs are being met appropriately. This may not be accurate, but only through empathy can that assumption be challenged appropriately.

But that is a terrible assumption to operate under. Humans are shitty, shitty people in general (I'm no exception) and if history has taught us anything it's that oppression and violence are constants in human society to some extent.

I'm all for transcending this past, but I think you're severely mistaken if you think we can do it through appeals to an abstract concept of empathy. We've been trying that since at least the Greeks, and it doesn't seem to have worked out too well. Better solutions are needed.

Re:For an Inclusive Culture, Try Working Less by dqv on Monday June 12, 2017 @03:01PM (#14540018)
... I never thought I'd see the day that someone would argue that sensitivity to sexism and racism is white fragility and fragile masculinity.