But Microsoft mandated UEFI to rationalize the clusterfuck that is the "ARM platform" from the very beginning, and made it so that the carrier would have to explicitly disable an MS-pushed update, rather than the Android equivalent of the carrier having to prep the update in the first place.
They will keep not providing updates, because they don't come from Google anyway, even with Treble.
The only devices that are doomed are those that:
A. have no reasonable support for third party firmware B. have no user base or community to maintain security
The Galaxy S series since the S3, for example, is unlikely to ever stop getting some degree of support from community ROMs. Of course, those community developments don't have the resources of the OEM - they can't fix the proprietary parts that break, and security hinges on the willingness of volunteers to merge patches, which they don't always do.
I don't think its that black and white, though. Plenty of "supported" devices get updates and ignore security vulnerabilities. Companies can and will stop updating arbitrarily, and you have no way to know who is actually looking for vulnerabilities to fix. All you get is a set of known exploits elsewhere and the means you can test them yourself on your own devices, or someone else did and you already know unpatched vulnerabilities on your end.
You're automatically assuming that these third party maintainers apply all of the security patches released by Google. This would be an incorrect assumption.
But a big part of Android's headaches is the long tail of devices that have been functionally abandoned by all involved parties: the device maker, the carrier, and Google. These devices are trapped in time and in a cesspit of an ever-increasing number of vulnerabilities. It's like unpatched WinXP, except these devices were once bought new a mere two or three years prior. Because all involved parties have dropped the ball, and at the lowest end of the market, the consumer can't really punish the these parties because they're reliant on the exact same names to get access, this sad state of affairs continues until Project Treble ships for real.
At that point, all pre-Treble devices are still doomed, but post-Treble devices at least have a fighting chance.