> Sure, but it's not clear that forcing all of that thought to happen before the first draft actually improves the final result.
To that point, the essay "Shitty First Drafts" by Anne Lamott, 1954 is a great essay on the importance of shitty first drafts.
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https:/...
For anyone doing a double-take on the essay's title being outlandish for 1954, that's her year of birth and this essay is an excerpt from her 1994 book Bird by Bird.
Re:The Future of the Word Processor (2016)
by adrianratnapala on Thursday June 08, 2017 @08:15PM
(#14518249)
I have these monologues too, and they are far better written than anything that comes from my hands. So I am pretty sure I am composing in "mentalese" augmented with just enough English to fool me into thinking I am making good prose.
Speaking out loud while thinking is a good exercise, and more difficult than just thinking. But when I do it ends up in a conversational style, as if I was giving an talk to tech colleagues.
Also when I am in Germany, I find it very easy to "think in German" even though I can't speak properly.
Re:The Future of the Word Processor (2016)
by mirimir on Thursday June 08, 2017 @08:28PM
(#14518307)
When I'm starting a piece, I typically bang out whatever comes to mind. I keep at that for a while, and then rearrange it, as a crude outline. Then I flesh it out. Often, first thing in the day, blocks just come out, as if someone is dictating to me. Sometimes, I wake up seeing printed text. Then I go back and rewrite, and shuffle as needed.
I've come to like Geany, because it's simple, but has spell check. I don't have much need for layout, beyond HTML.
Re:The Future of the Word Processor (2016)
by nf05papsjfVbc on Friday June 09, 2017 @07:00AM
(#14520529)
If it is practical in your case, perhaps using a voice-recorder is a useful option.
Sure, but it's not clear that forcing all of that thought to happen before the first draft actually improves the final result. Many writers feel they need to bang out a shitty first draft and that much of the magic happens in later revisions.
> Tack on the issue, in the US at least, of thick regional accents and I really, really don't see Voice Input being the amazing game changer it can be advertised as from time to time
I often experience a funny phenomenon. A lot of times when I'm out for a walk or a long drive, I'll start thinking about fiction ideas. Before too long, my wandering mind drills down to what I think is an actual internal monologue of prose. In my head, it flows smoothly and sounds compelling.
I always mean to start writing it down when I get home but never seem to find the time or discipline or whatever to do so. Maybe already being in the middle of a 200k-word nonfiction book has something to do with that...
What I've always wondered is if I am actually narrating real words or just sort of imagining that I am in that way that it's always easier to imagine a drawing than it is to draw it. The real experiment would be to get a recorder and start dictating, but I never have. If I did, would that work?
If so, than it means I might "write" works in this way that for simple practical reasons would never come about at all without the speech recognition. Even if I were to summon the discipline to manually transcribe my inner monologue, would something be lost in the translation? Or gained? Or both?