This so much. Some how in the last 10 or so years we as a society have been moving towards holding beliefs that are rooted in nothing but an emotional foundation in which knowledge has no part of. Then when those beliefs are questioned by others the response of the person is to close up and get defensive, while coming to the conclusion you are ignorant or stupid for disagreeing.
When I start to disagree with people and try and have a conversation about our differences in perception on the subject, the other party always thinks I want to have an argument, but in reality I want to have a conversation. Arguments aren't about sharing knowledge, they're entered into to triumph over the other. It's as if we have lost the art of conversation.
Was it ever different? In particular, questioning religion used to draw angry emotional responses.
Alternatively, if you look at 1960ties, you won't find dry rational discourse. You will find people fighting and destroying each other.
When to argue and when not to is as important as knowing how.
I mean, I don't usually try to start arguments on purpose over a family dinner. But when someone, out of their own initiative, starts talking complete nonsense and expect me to take part in that conversation, then well... I understand social objects, but I believe accuracy of beliefs is more important than talking for the sake of talking.
And unrelatedly, it is easier to find flaws and nitpick then put on theory or explanation.
Ya know?
Do I get to vocally disagree with stuff like that even though it's thanksgiving?
Write them a letter the next day. Ring them, meet up?
Sometimes we need to celebrate our commonalities, our shared humanity regardless of deep differences.
Perhaps demonstrate your dissent softly and postpone your opposition.
Maybe. Perhaps it's best we all just keep quiet and don't say anything for fear of opposing each other.
Or maybe the whole point of having meals together is having interesting conversations.
I definitely give you that you have it hard.
I have been told that this also is impolite in many situations. My usual approach is asking questions. People get upset when they don't have answers because they aren't used to having their beliefs questioned and don't think defending them should be necessary.