News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by rosstex on Thursday June 08, 2017 @02:44PM (#14516184)
Me: Hey Siri, what cheese goes well with fruit?

Siri: Here's what I found on the web for "What cheese goes well with fruit..."

Me: Hey Google, what cheese goes well with fruit?

Google: "Edam"

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by snowwrestler on Thursday June 08, 2017 @06:50PM (#14517778)
"Is Obama planning a coup?"

Siri: Here's what I found on the web for "is obama planning a coo"

Google: According to details exposed in Western Center for Journalism’s exclusive video, not only could Obama be in bed with communist Chinese, but Obama may in fact be planning a communist coup d’etat at the end of his term in 2016!

(Definitive answering style is not always better...)

More:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2017/03...

http://www.businessinsider.com/google-home-claims-obama-plan...

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by stouset on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:12PM (#14516860)
At least Siri acknowledges that it doesn't have the information necessary. Google Assistant comes up with an answer, but it might as well have picked a cheese at random. It's not like there's a universal cheese that pairs with all fruit.

Would you have felt satisfied if you asked, "What wine goes well with dinner?" and heard "Zinfandel" in response?

An actually useful AI would ask you what kind of fruit(s) you want to pair it with. Not throw out an answer at random.

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by RJIb8RBYxzAMX9u on Thursday June 08, 2017 @08:47PM (#14518402)
> At least Siri acknowledges that it doesn't have the information necessary.

I've had two failures in recent memory where Siri recognized the queries correctly, but completely misinterpreted them.

"What's <time> Eastern Time in Pacific Time?" => time in Pacific, MO.

"Increase volume by 10%" => lowered volume to almost 0.

The latter failure took me a while to figure out: Siri had interpreted my query as set volume to 10 (out of 255?). Indeed, "increase / decrease volume by X" had the same behavior.

Also, asking Siri to play a particular song whose title's in Japanese might as well be asking it to play a random song. Setting its language to Japanese helps a little, but then of course I have the inverse problem. I wish I could switch Siri's language settings verbally, or be able to say "In <language X>, <query in language X>."

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by eridius on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:06PM (#14516813)
I assume you're trying to say that Google's answer is better, right? Google's certainly being more authoritative, but the answer to your question is actually fairly subjective, there's more answers than just "Edam", so IMO surfacing search results is better than just having Google pick one answer.

Google's also been known to produce completely incorrect "authoritative" answers.

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by beachbum8029 on Thursday June 08, 2017 @05:42PM (#14517395)
He didn't ask, "What cheese goes best with fruit?" he said "goes well with fruit." So Google's answer is technically more correct. The best kind of correct.
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by scott_s on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:19PM (#14516902)
I have an iPhone, sometimes use Siri, and I prefer Google's answer. Simply, if I asked a verbal question, I prefer a verbal response. If I ever ask Siri a question, and I get the "Here's what I found on the web" answer, I consider it a failed operation, and I take a different tack.
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by wvenable on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:12PM (#14516861)
If you are speaking to your device for this kind of question, the authoritative answer is what you want. You expect me, after taking to my device, to go over and pick it up and search through web results? If I wanted to do that, I wouldn't have asked the question by voice in the first place!
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by rspeer on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:22PM (#14516916)
An "authoritative answer" that may not be true, has no context, and may have been put there by SEOs or propagandists, is worse than no answer at all.
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by stouset on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:53PM (#14517110)
I believe you have failed to understand the original point you are replying to.

"Edam" might be authoritative, but it is not correct. The problem isn't simply that the answer is fundamentally subjective, the bigger issue is that there's not enough contextual information in the question to even arrive at an answer that one could consider subjectively correct.

I replied elsewhere, but it's like answering the question "What wine would pair well with dinner?" with "Zinfandel". Without having even a vague idea of what's on the menu, you're just picking a wine at random. Maybe it's correct, maybe it isn't. But being authoritative when there's not enough information to actually speak with authority is not the right answer here.

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by wvenable on Thursday June 08, 2017 @08:32PM (#14518326)
For the record, this exact search with Google Assistant did not provide an authoritative answer for me and instead gave a bit of a voice summary and a link for more information. This is still way better than just directing me to the search with no more voice feedback.
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by wvenable on Thursday June 08, 2017 @05:06PM (#14517203)
The agent should then ask for more information; not point me to a web search. In most cases, the authoritative answer is what I'm looking for and the question less likely to be this subjective.

The thing is Siri won't give me an answer either way.

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by stouset on Thursday June 08, 2017 @05:54PM (#14517468)
Nobody's arguing that sending you off to search results isn't particularly useful. We're just pointing out that authoritatively answering a nuanced question without enough context isn't any better, it's just differently wrong (and in some cases, strictly worse).

Whether or not Siri or Google Assistant correctly and authoritatively answers more (or more relevant) questions is a completely different topic than what's being discussed here.

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by adamlett on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:26PM (#14516940)
The authoratative, wrong answer is what I want? Or, what if I ask, say, which actor is the best in the world? Is there any authoratative sounding answer that is of any value?
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by rspeer on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:15PM (#14516877)
We've already seen the problem with Google confidently giving answers that it got from searching the Web.

"Hey Google, is this batshit conspiracy theory I heard about true?"

Google: "Yeah, sounds right"

Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by mirekrusin on Thursday June 08, 2017 @02:55PM (#14516261)
You: Hey HN, what cheese goes well with fruit? Me: Which fruit?
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by jjuel on Thursday June 08, 2017 @03:01PM (#14516307)
Siri: "Oh you have a question. Let me Google that for you."
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by joshstrange on Thursday June 08, 2017 @03:16PM (#14516415)
IF ONLY, instead it uses bing....
Re:Apple is struggling to become an AI powerhouse by willyt on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:05PM (#14516807)
Edam! Stilton surely.