Re:Mathematicians looking to make elections in the US more r...
by n4r9 on Thursday June 08, 2017 @04:16AM
(#14512717)
Cryptonector's comment makes very little sense. It's an obvious advantage if you can move the boundaries between two seats in order to go from 80-20/50-50 to 75-25/55-45.
Re:Mathematicians looking to make elections in the US more r...
by cryptonector on Thursday June 08, 2017 @11:37AM
(#14514912)
It's only a temporary advantage.
If you maximize seat safety, you minimize the number of seats you have because you bunch up all your voters. This means that the opposition need only flip a few districts to win back a majority (and then redistrict to their liking!).
If you maximize the number of seats you have then you spread your voters thin. This makes it easier to win in a wave: with many districts close to 50/50, you only have to flip a few percent of the voters state-wide or nation-wide and you win. And that's exactly what's been happening. We've had a number of wave elections recently.
Re:Mathematicians looking to make elections in the US more r...
by Ntrails on Thursday June 08, 2017 @06:07AM
(#14513081)
It's somewhat frustrating though when you can see that one area is 200k people and another is 50k people but the party negatively affected (someone will be) by re-drawing the boundaries to be "fairer" will scream bloody murder and claim Gerrymandering.
How is this self-limiting? Also, I don't quite see how it maps to the rather abstract phenomenon you are talking about?
Edit -- wikipedia seems to match up with what I was remembering: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerrymandering