News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by caryme on Monday June 21, 2010 @09:51PM (#1450651)
Why can't system apps go in the app store? They could be installed by default, but able to be uninstalled and then reinstalled from the app store. Think Apple's Remote app.

What Gruber says makes sense for apps like Mail and Safari, but Stocks and Weather feel so grandfathered in.

Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by Timothee on Monday June 21, 2010 @10:53PM (#1450773)
The thing is that some SDK functions are dependent on those apps and thus need to exist somehow. Because a third-party app can use the SDK to send an email from inside the app, Mail needs to be around. Same thing with Maps, Safari, Photos… (and of course, the App Store)

On the other hand, you're correct, Stocks, Weather, Calculator, etc. are completely independent, thus could be deleted without causing trouble, but I wouldn't be surprised if the decision went down to the simplest one (at least for now): no default app gets deleted, period.

If you don't like having the extra system apps, (I don't for some of them), to quote Steve Jobs on an unrelated topic: "not that big of a deal".

Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by commandar on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @12:20AM (#1450925)
This demonstrates exactly why Gruber completely misses the point every time he tries to nitpick the Android team's statements about not using private APIs. While Gruber wants to make it about hollow point scoring, what the Android guys are getting at is that they've made a conscious design decision to have a clear distinction between what is system level and what is application level specifically to avoid getting stuck in this sort of situation.

Yes, your Android phone has apps you probably can't uninstall, but that's a distribution decision rather than something that was forced on them by technical limitation.

Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by sandGorgon on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @12:33AM (#1450953)
http://www.engadget.com/2010/03/29/exclusive-android-froyo-t...

Android Froyo onwards, a lot of system apps are going to be downloadable separately, just so that you dont have to wait for your service provider to build an OTA update for you.

Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by commandar on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @12:40AM (#1450973)
Well, like Engadget mentions, they'd already broken Maps out like that a while back. The entire reason they can do this is because they've kept their first-party apps out of the system level and exposed the functionality they need publicly.

The official Facebook and Twitter apps integrate with system contacts, for example, not because Google integrated them at the system level, but because Google provided an API to allow this with the Android 2.0 release.

One of the things that continually impresses me about Android is the fact that Google took so much care to create a clean architecture that opens up the door to a lot of cool opportunities for any application developer.

Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by kenjackson on Monday June 21, 2010 @11:19PM (#1450822)
You can have the API's without having the apps. This is what MS had to do with IE, for example.
Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by Timothee on Monday June 21, 2010 @11:39PM (#1450847)
Of course they could be separated. What I'm saying is that considering that some of the apps are not completely sandboxed, the simplest decision to make is to just keep all of them.

Plus, it helps Apple's branding: as long as they're not forced into separating the apps and the APIs, like Microsoft was, they won't.

Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by jay_kyburz on Monday June 21, 2010 @10:15PM (#1450691)
No, I agree, even Mail and Safari could go into the app store.
Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by alanh on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @01:25AM (#1451037)
Safari really couldn't exist in the app store, considering that many third-party apps have links that open a page in Safari and thus it needs to be always installed. I take it this is sarcasm?
Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by notauser on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @04:17AM (#1451276)
They don't have links that open a page in Safari.

They have http:// URIs, which happens to invoke Safari as the registered handler on every iPhone.

There's no reason (other than Apple policy) why that URI handler couldn't be registered as Opera or Firefox. That's how it works on other platforms.

Even on the iPhone developers can register most URIs (e.g. myuri://) to start up their own apps as long as it isn't a protected one, unless they changed that recently.

Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by jonknee on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @09:27AM (#1451783)
I have third party apps on my laptop that have links which open a page in a browser. Doesn't mean I can't delete Safari or get updates to it outside of system updates. If I delete my browser and then can't get links to open it sounds like I'd need to install a browser.

There are reasons why you wouldn't want a browser though, which at the moment you can't do.

Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by megablast on Monday June 21, 2010 @10:24PM (#1450710)
I guess they are different to normal sandboxed apps downloaded from the app store, since they have higher access to the iPhone (reading emails, controlling settings), and can multitask (email, ipod).

They may in fact not be apps at all, but just part of the system, with access via the icons. They are just made to look like apps. They may have hooks that mean they can never be deleted (like new mail), but only hidden, since there code is needed.

Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by brown9-2 on Monday June 21, 2010 @10:29PM (#1450719)
Seems like the obvious solution. Along with being able to distribute updates to these apps independent of complete OS updates.
Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by mikecarlucci on Monday June 21, 2010 @11:23PM (#1450827)
We may be able to draw some insight from the Apple Store app as well. Like iBooks it was shipped separately. Like the App Store and iTunes apps the Apple Store app lets you make purchases from Apple.

Is it simpler to have all the "purchasing apps" together, bundled with the iPhone/iPad or to strip away more system apps? The iPad didn't ship with calculator, stocks etc. The answer might go right back to Gruber's point: the iPad itself shipped out of the OS release cycle while the Apple Store app shipped just before the new OS in part to aid with the purchasing of iPhone4. Maybe both of these will be included in iOS5 next year.

Re:Daring Fireball: Apple’s System Apps by tjogin on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @02:24AM (#1451130)
I think apps from the app store need to be individually signed for each user, which wouldn't be possible on a generic install. At least, not presently.