Speaking of "use what works best": I still have the MBP to run Photoshop, precisely for that reason.
I'm pretty sure most early Linux adopters switched from whatever proprietary platform they were using for political reasons (i.e. freedom). I'd argue that without the people who switched for political reasons, Linux would never have acquired its current level of awesomeness.
I couldn't agree more. I am primarily a .NET/Windows programmer, but I have an Ubuntu VM that I have been using to hack on OSS-based work I've been doing recently. Package managers make it super simple to get everything up and running quickly, and mean I can keep each of my machine's VMs up to date with whatever new thing I'm mucking around with.
I don't necessarily agree with him that OSX will inevitably go walled, but given that belief his behavior is sensible.
Where's the evidence for that?
Desktop OS behavior has been converging for years. Linux gradually gets more and more features that were formerly restricted to proprietary systems (e.g. iPod compatibility). Emulators have gotten better. The hardware has converged: Everything runs on Intel now. The OS has converged: Everything runs with Unix underneath now. The browsers have converged: there's Webkit browsers for Mac, and Webkit browsers for Linux.
What makes it harder to move from Mac to Linux (or vice versa) than it was, say, three years ago, or five years ago?
What I really don't understand is how you can simultaneously argue that Apple isn't going to continue introducing new Mac OS features and that Mac OS is going to get increasingly hard to migrate away from. Stationary targets are easy to hit. It's moving targets that are difficult to track.
The only thing that I have to move is my personal/family stuff. Movies, music, pictures, etc.
Fortunately for those switching from Mac to Linux, several people have made the switch already (or use both simultaneously) and have written free software to mimic much of the functionality they came to expect with Mac and missed in Linux.
"There are many mathematicians who are more or less honest. But almost all of them are conformists. They are more or less honest, but they tolerate those who are not honest.”
Apple not only "tolerates" walled-gardens, they build them and encourage others to do so. That is enough reason to not use a Mac.
However, one good reason he has to move now as opposed to later, is that later might be too late. Moving to a new platform can be costly and difficult and Linux can be trickier than most to pick up. He might want to have more experience with it when the time comes to drop Mac entirely if that's his goal.
I moved into Linux from a background in Windows. The way I did it was to start by gradually replacing the proprietary Windows applications I was using with FOSS equivalents that had good cross-platform support.
The next step was to install Ubuntu as a dual-boot onto my secondary computer and play around with it. I quickly determined that it was considerably easier to do most of the things I do on computers under Ubuntu than it was under Windows. Going back to my primary OS came to feel more and more like returning to prison after a weekend pass.
When it came time to replace my main PC, I bought a new box with no OS and installed Ubuntu as my primary system. Migrating my data was painless, since it was all stored in open formats by this time (moving my email was particularly nice - I just grabbed my Thunderbird profile and dragged it across to the new computer).
The final test was my wife, who is not that interested in technology and just wants the computer to work. The transition was painless for her, since she could use all the same applications on the new computer that she had been accustomed to using on the old.
It seems to me the better strategy would be to support the Mac until Apple tries to control Mac software development in the same way they do iOS development and then go to Linux. That way Apple can clearly see that people are rejecting the walled garden philosophy.