Re:Diversity in Technology and Open Source
by aeorgnoieang on Monday June 05, 2017 @11:24AM
(#14488234)
> CTFs were intrinsically male-oriented because women disfavored zero-sum competition (which was surprising for Erin, a roller derby skater, to hear)
Surely you and Erin both recognize that it's possible that both (a) women, generally (compared to men), 'disfavor zero-sum competition'; and (b) Erin favors 'zero-zum competition'.
[I'm not claiming that it's true or even that there's significant evidence that women 'disfavor zero-sum competition', absolutely or relative to men.]
I have seen very small variation on how people emphasis things to have extreme effect on the demographic of participants. To take a different topic than IT, a public bath house in the city have a goal that visitors should be 50% women and 50% men. When they first had special a sauna evening called "Relax" with a emphasis on adventure (ie, a few events had names like Everest), they had full booked for men but only about 1/3 ticked sold for the remaining 50% that was dedicated for women. A month later they held a second evening, this time called "Wellness", they also renamed the events. Everest was now called ice sauna, salt sauna was renamed to scrubbing, but other than the name they the exact same events. This time all the tickets for women was sold after just a day but only 2 tickets for men sold in total. A complete reverse. Later events has shown similar pattern where more "adventure"-styled marketing leads to more men and less women, and self-improvement styled marketing leads to more women and less men.
A small leap I will make is that people of both genders look towards gendered emphasis to validate their choice. If its for their gender then it is a safe choice, and if its not then doubt arise. The effect being a small bias that depending on what one is doing can have a rather extreme results.
Yeah, that happens with TV shows. I (male) can enjoy women-oriented TV shows if I happen to watch them, but I often choose to not watch a TV show because I guess it's aimed at women.
It also doesn't (at least in my opinion) help the cause of balancing the industry to be telling engineers that the only way to do so is to emphasize soft skills and deemphasize competition (and subtextually with it technical excellence).