Re:Whatever Happened to Voice Recognition?
by arethuza on Monday June 21, 2010 @09:32AM
(#1448718)
Some games do have voice control - Rainbow Six: Vegas on the Xbox 360 allows you to give order to your computer controlled teammates.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I remember Rainbow 6 III Black Arrow or something had very usable voice recognition for the solo game. You basically had a few commands like 'regroup,' 'go go go,' 'hold this position' which worked out better than button commands. It seemed to disappear in subsequent Tom Clancy games but glad to hear they brought it back for Vegas.
I think the key with speech recognition and natural language processing is to forget the HAL9000/StarTrek 'hello computer' nonsense, and focus on constrained domains augmented by other technologies.
Touchpad keyboards are blatantly less usable than hard keyboards but by the time you factor in a) portability and b) auto-completion of words/urls/search-strings, then they become a more than viable alternative.
People have incredibly adaptive linguistic skills, developers should harness this more IMO rather than be overly ambitious with NLP.
That said I was very impressed with the accuracy of Google's voice search app. But like Jeff Atwood says, it's easier just to search normally.
Having Microsoft and other platform owners to cover your back as a semi-big game also helps. :)
Re:Whatever Happened to Voice Recognition?
by dazzawazza on Monday June 21, 2010 @10:01AM
(#1448795)
I'd be willing to bet that they use the hardware vendors solution. I'm sure both MS and Sony provide libraries for XBox 2 and PS3 (not sure about Wii).