News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by dang on Monday June 05, 2017 @02:46AM (#14485701)
Inflammatory drive-by comments start flamewars. That's trolling, and you've unfortunately done it here before. We ban accounts that do this, so please don't do it again.
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by Mao_Zedang on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:16PM (#14493188)
I stand by my comment and I would love to know exactly how making a comment on exactly what happened is trolling. "Unfortunately done it here before" you clearly have an incident in mind care to share it?
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by dang on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @02:25PM (#14499726)
Now you're meta-trolling. What I explained is sufficient. If you continue to post flamebait, we will ban you.

If you don't want to be banned, that's easy: when you have a substantive point to make, make it thoughtfully, and when you don't, don't post.

Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by Mao_Zedang on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @07:02PM (#14502238)
I dont even know what meta-trolling is. The only definition I could find is this, http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=metatroll I cant see how this applies, there is nothing in the rules about meta-trolling so I am only guessing at what you mean.

I also disagree with you and as you can see from the rest of the comments on this particular post also agree with me that Palmer Luckey was miss treated, I dont see how having an unpopular opinion (is it really unpopular?) is flamebait, it isnt even off topic, one could make the argument that this new venture luckey is involved in is a biproduct of exactly the kind of ostracisation he was subjected too.

As for asking for clarification of your accusation that I have "trolled" in the past, I am actually genuinely interested in which comment you are referring too, So I can avoid making the same mistake. If you think that is meta trolling, I guess I cant convince you otherwise.

Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by dang on Thursday June 08, 2017 @02:23AM (#14512307)
Ok, on the chance that you're sincere, I will try explaining this in detail.

You posted an inflammatory drive-by comment complete with gratutious Nazis (not literal Nazis of course, but in the same bucket). That's trolling: it destroys good conversation and provokes others into posting worse.

I explained this well enough for anyone who sincerely wants to use HN as intended to understand. Insead of taking that information in and adapting to it, you responded with the very most popular troll ploy in such situations, the "How is this trolling?" trick. That's where people seek to replace a pointless argument with a pointless argument about the pointless argument. I call that meta-trolling. Sorry the term wasn't clear.

I interpreted your reply as insincere because "a comment on exactly what happened" is such a silly misrepresentation of your original post. Posting something outrageous and then meekly playing innocent is more classic trollery. So is baiting people into wasting their time on obvious falsehoods. I've learned to decline the bait because all of this is so boring, and the overwhelming majority of sincere users don't do them, or drop them right away when we ask them to.

The past comment I was referring to was https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12553831. It has the same combination of being unsubstantive and inflammatory. You post far too many of those to HN, though usually more unsubstantive than inflammatory, which is at least better than the other way around. That, plus what looks to me like sincerity in your reply here, makes me think that maybe we can convince you to use the site as intended after all; hence this long reply.

HN is intended for (a) the gratification of intellectual curiosity and (b) civil, substantive discussion. That means posting thoughtfully on topics where you have something meaningful to say, and otherwise not posting. Can you do that?

Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by Mao_Zedang on Thursday June 08, 2017 @07:15PM (#14517931)
OK, thank you for replying, I understand the issue here, my comments are too terse and my language isnt clear enough to explain my intent behind them, and that comes off as trolling.

Instead of saying stassi, I should have explained how palmer was unfairly targeted by people in the tech scene and tech media in the valley who have what most people accept as a very left leaning bias. In an attempt to condense all of that in a single word I can see how that came off in the wrong way. And I can see how the comment from last year you linked too come off the same way, it was an attempt to highlight how science and religion are at odds and how the current political climate is making things like blasphemy laws more likely, and how the substance of the article in a society with blasphemy laws could be consider a hate crime.

[dead]
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by nyolfen on Monday June 05, 2017 @02:06AM (#14485542)
so people who support politicians you don't like should lose their jobs?
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by adjkant on Monday June 05, 2017 @02:15AM (#14485580)
The big issue right now when it comes to the US is where you draw the line between "this person is a politician I don't agree with" and "this person is dangerous to the country and has completely unacceptable views".

If David Duke ran for president, and Elon Musk supported him (using both to illustrate a point, not implying anything), would you still think it just for Musk to maintain the power he has, or would you be concerned with what projects he would power?

Obviously, there two situations aren't perfectly parallel, but it's a question of severity. The point is that Trump is crossing that line for some, and not for others, which drastically changes the way people judge actions related to Trump. So no, I don't think the parent here is saying just any politician.

Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by FeepingCreature on Monday June 05, 2017 @03:23AM (#14485850)
I'm more worried about people who think they can decide what political candidates or projects are acceptable, than the actual candidates or projects.
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by unityByFreedom on Monday June 05, 2017 @10:16AM (#14487734)
Eh? Like people who think they can vote and voice their opinions about candidates?
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by FeepingCreature on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @01:52PM (#14508416)
People voting is fine. The problem is the people who think they should have the power to remove politicians from the ballot, because they want to assume control over the votes of everybody else.
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by rtpg on Monday June 05, 2017 @03:02AM (#14485763)
If you're actually funding the campaign on a massive scale, you are sharing the campaign's values. It's not that complicated.

Nobody writes sob stories about the Koch brothers.

Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by CMay on Monday June 05, 2017 @04:17PM (#14491393)
This isn't necessarily true. We don't have a system where a wide variety of viable candidates all get equal representation, since their representation is mostly controlled by for-profit businesses.

We end up with 2 imperfect candidates and if it is your duty to choose one and see to it that they win versus the other option, you might donate some money. An individual might donate for a pet cause that's important to them even if they disagree with other things. A company might donate, because it is actually going to help their business and they have a duty to their shareholders to increase profit.

You say it's not complicated as if the issue is settled and final, but there is a lot more subtlety to this topic.

There were enough issues with Hillary as a candidate that she deserved to lose regardless of whether the republican candidate was a controversial figure like Trump or not. For that reason, I expect many people donated to Trump as a way to avoid Hillary.

Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by the_cat_kittles on Monday June 05, 2017 @02:15AM (#14485582)
in general no. but maybe ask yourself, is there a politician you can think of in the last hundred years or so that you would fire someone for supporting? if not fire, at least not hire. surely there is at least one. the way you frame your question is not charitable.
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by charliesome on Monday June 05, 2017 @02:11AM (#14485566)
Speech and political action is not and has never been free of consequence
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by Jare on Monday June 05, 2017 @03:21AM (#14485843)
Consequence, punishment and revenge are very different things, and it's infuriating how so many otherwise well-meaning people have been taught to conflate them.
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by bdcravens on Monday June 05, 2017 @03:46AM (#14485943)
Just ask Kathy Griffin, Colin Kaepernick, and Tim Tebow.
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by averagewall on Monday June 05, 2017 @02:34AM (#14485656)
I'd expect freedom of speech should come with much the same rights as freedom of sexuality. However, popular opinion says it's bad to fire someone for being gay but it's OK to fire someone for offending the boss's preferred political party.
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by threeseed on Monday June 05, 2017 @02:16AM (#14485584)
Conservatism used to/still is the default political persuasion of business so it definitely isn't his views that are the issue. Rather it was the way he chose to express his political views. It wasn't intelligent, nuanced, principled, insightful or constructive.

It was the behaviour of a immature teenager.

Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by nextlevelwizard on Monday June 05, 2017 @02:25AM (#14485622)
From a 21 year old kid

I like how people now get thrown into trash bin for rest of their lives for one stupid thing, and what did he even do? He gave some money to a people making memes. Then he apologized and lost his position in his own company (yeah yeah he had already sold it whatever he was founder) and people still have a stick up their asses about this. I can't tell if it's plain old jealousy or if political climate is just so toxic in US now that you can't even express your opinion(s) without being forever marked (and then these same people dare to speak how we are going towards Orwellian society even though they are already living and implementing it)

Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by puranjay on Monday June 05, 2017 @02:37AM (#14485668)
That's because he was just two years out of his teens.

I'd love to see the people bashing him be 21 years old and have $500M in the bank.

Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by exolymph on Monday June 05, 2017 @01:58AM (#14485520)
People care(d) plenty about Thiel, and continue to.
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by jolux on Monday June 05, 2017 @02:02AM (#14485531)
not the right people, apparently
Re:Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveil... by throwaway-1209 on Monday June 05, 2017 @02:46AM (#14485706)
That's a dangerous slippery slope you're descending. You may at some point end up on the receiving end.