News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by aquadrop on Sunday June 04, 2017 @05:26PM (#14483607)
By that logic Sweden should be more worried about being attacked by USA or UK. All countries historically have been expansionist. Now we have modern world, and it's certain that there's 0 possibility of Russia attacking Sweden. I don't understand all that recent hype about Sweden being afraid of Russia's attack. Even Finland and Norway which border Russia don't care, but Sweden do. Seems like there's some local political game involving "scare of Russia" is going.
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by criley2 on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:44PM (#14484360)
This is actual disinformation?

Russia has a modern history of invading European countries and is illegally possessing the invaded region of Crimea and astro-turfing a 'civil war' in Eastern Ukraine.

They recently threatened NATO out-right over the acceptance of a new member.

But, in light of this, you think it's more likely that their strong ally for many decades, US or UK, would be more likely to attack them than the proven-aggressive adversary which self-titles itself enemy of NATO?

This has got to be actual disinformation.

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by eveningcoffee on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:49PM (#14484377)
It could be also a candid moment to peak into the mind (and belief system) of person living inside Russian cultural space (i.e. is influenced by Russian media, social networks and education system).
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by Swenrekcah on Sunday June 04, 2017 @06:06PM (#14483856)
Now we have the modern world, and in the last 10 years Russia has invaded and annexed a part of Georgia and a part of Ukraine, and probably more that I don't know of. Now we have the modern world, and 3 years ago Russia or Russian backed rebels shot down a dutch passenger plane. Yeah, why worry about Russia...
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by aquadrop on Sunday June 04, 2017 @06:29PM (#14484000)
Russia didn't attack and annexed part of Georgia, those are self-managed unrecognized entities. Also if you support that Kosovo shouldn't be part of Serbia, then Abkhazia and South Ossetia shouldn't be part of Georgia, it's absolutely de-facto separate entities (source: my grandparents lived in Abkhazia) and those small nations fought with Georgia by themselves. Yes, Crimea was annexed and that's totally wrong, but it has complex history and you need to look at the whole string of events which triggered this. Who exactly shot down the plane is still not 100% clear. Even though I think it was on DNR rebels, Ukrainain army wasn't angels as well. Also Russian backed rebels and Russia itself is a big difference (al qaeda was USA backed at some point). And even rebels I'm sure weren't trying to shot down passenger plane, same as when USA shot down passenger plane in 1988 (and George Bush said that he'll never apologize for that, even though it was clear they were responsible for destroying civilian plane). And speaking of USA, at the recent time they attacked a lot of countries (like with Iraq, on false pretense, 0 consequence later) and dropped a lot of bombs, so if we go just by numbers and don't look deeper in the each situation Sweden should be more afraid of USA, as I said before... Politics is hard and dirty, but my original point was, that there's no political or any point of Russia attacking Sweden.
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by Swenrekcah on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:05PM (#14484203)
Fair enough, I'll admit I don't know much about Georgian history, and it's absolutely true that many (most?) large countries have very bloody track records. And you won't hear me defending US oil wars. But Sweden doesn't have to fear the US or UK as they are allies and also neither US nor UK particularly need Sweden as a strategic location. Some people in this thread have provided a number of reasons why Russia could make good use of Sweden in the event of a larger conflict. So I don't think the Swedes are just playing some internal politics in beefing up their defences.
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by aquadrop on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:18PM (#14484260)
> Some people in this thread have provided a number of reasons why Russia could make good use of Sweden in the event of a larger conflict

I don't really think those are good use, Sweden is pretty large and doesn't really hold water passage alone, it's not like Panama canal or Turkey's Bosporus. But anyway, do you think, but really honestly, that large scale NATO - Russia war is possible? With all those nukes etc. It didn't even happen during cold war, so I don't see any possibility of that. (Also Russians are not that blood-thirsty as western media shows them, so there's 0 desire of that as well).

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by eveningcoffee on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:37PM (#14484332)
I am not a military expert but I my opinion annexing Sweden would be strategically reasonable:

1) attacking Sweden does not trigger NATO article 5 (because Sweden in not in NATO),

2) Sweden will give close proximity to Germany and to the rest of central Europe,

3) Finland would become cut out and would very likely just surrender (or surrender sooner),

4) complete control over Baltic Sea makes helping Baltic states considerably harder by other NATO members.

In many cases it makes seriously more sense for Russia to first attack Sweden than countries next to its border.

I am not saying that Russia will just do it, but it may seriously consider it within a larger conflict.

I therefore believe that there are serious reasons for Sweden to have considerable deterrence against it just happening when Russia just pleases it.

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by aquadrop on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:56PM (#14484399)
> 2) Sweden will give close proximity to Germany and to the rest of central Europe,

Russia already has Kaliningrad which is already very close to Germany and the rest of central Europe, for whatever reason you think it's good.

It also all involves some larger conflict with western war, large scale war. But it's a suicide for Russia, this won't happen. Russia isn't a blood-thirsty monster that each day thinks how to conquer the world or die trying to... There's a lot of problems with Russia, but mostly poeple of Russia are the victims...

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by eveningcoffee on Sunday June 04, 2017 @08:16PM (#14484465)
>Russia already has Kaliningrad

It was called Königsberg. It was once Germany but it is no where near Germany today - there is still this pesky Poland in between. Having control over Sweden also helps to deal with the Polish question...

Let me stress it again. At current state attacking Sweden probably (and hopefully) will be suicide for Russia, but only thanks to respectable deterrence by Sweden.

Otherwise, if Russia would consider attacking one of its western neighbours, it would make much more sense to attack Sweden first.

I hope it makes it clear why it is ridiculous to ridicule Sweden for having a serious army.

>mostly poeple of Russia are the victims...

... of their own delusions (i.e. NATO countries are trying to encircle them etc)?

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by rangibaby on Monday June 05, 2017 @12:31AM (#14485270)
In the event of an offensive war, Russia would go through Latvia and Lithuania to link with Kaliningrad. They could safely ignore Sweden. What is the point of opening a front there from a Russian perspective?
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by BoiledCabbage on Monday June 05, 2017 @01:01AM (#14485346)
> Russia would go through Latvia and Lithuania

The absolutely crucial difference is that Latvia and Lithuania are both NATO countries, and that would trigger Article 5.

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by kbart on Monday June 05, 2017 @02:40AM (#14485682)
"What is the point of opening a front there from a Russian perspective?"

The difference between attacking a country with sub-par military vs attacking the mightiest military alliance on the whole world?

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by dogma1138 on Monday June 05, 2017 @12:15PM (#14488768)
This isn't going to be Sweden alone, Russia doesn't have major force projection without ground troops, you can't pour into Norway without taking Sweden first.

If a war would break out and Russia would need to secure a passage for it's baltic fleet it would likely involve a ground invasion into Sweden and then Norway and Denmark likely through Finland.

Russia might also use it's Northern Fleet for which Severomorsk serves as it's home port, in that case Russia would need to circle the Scandinavian Peninsula, in which case the Northern fleet would be well in range of the Swedish (as well as Finnish, and Norwegian) air forces.

Russia's Baltic fleet is located in Kaliningrad a small Russian enclave between Poland and Lithuania, Kaliningrad would not hold out for long without Russia escalating to the nuclear options as such in any major conflict Russia would want to ensure the security and freedom of movement of it's Baltic fleet, this would involve pinning down Sweden to prevent a naval blockade of Kaliningrad, the use of it's air force against Russian targets in the Baltic and the Arctic and as a stepping stone into invading Norway and further.

On the other side of the Baltic Russia would undoubtedly invade the small baltic states, either annexing them completely or securing a land corridor from Russia proper to Kaliningrad in order to be able to keep it's naval base there supplied and operational.

As silly as it might sound, the world is a giant game of Risk especially when it comes to Russia since they have been always at a geographical disadvantage despite being the largest country in the world and one of the most resource rich countries to boot.

In general i think you have the notion that the fact that Sweden is preparing itself for a Russian invasion means that Russia have somehow singled out Sweden. It didn't, it's just another piece on the board that Russia would have to take out or severely confine in order to be able to move it's own pieces to where it counts.

Finland, the Baltic states, the rest of Scandinavia and Europe at large are all effectively planning for the inevitable if unlikely Russian invasion in case of a major conflict.

Sweden being close to Russia, having whilst a small but sufficiently sophisticated and relatively large for the area navy (5 decent stealth corvettes and 5 submarines all of which are more than capable of effecting a blockade against a merchant fleet escort or not), having a relatively large air forces for the region (about 100 Saab JAS 39 Gripen fighters, all equippable with anti-ship missiles) and being just across the baltic at a very short distance from the Russian baltic fleet home port and headquarters makes Sweden a strategic target for Russia as it poses a direct threat to it's interests.

If you still can't see that then I'm sorry but I don't know how to explain it in a more simple or detailed manner.

If anything else fails then go to https://www.google.com/maps/place/Kaliningrad,+Kaliningrad+O... and zoom out a bit.

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by aquadrop on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @06:35AM (#14496179)
That's all fantasy scenario for a military games or scary movie, it doesn't have any real possibility, it didn't even happen in cold war time with much more powerful at the time USSR. Russia just can't start large scale war with west, it doesn't have any capability to do that, only if Gandalf will come to save it :) (same level of fantasy as in your scenario) It also doesn't want to, nobody wants to attack Europe here, that's ridiculous, if you think Russia is some blood-thirsty monster thinking everyday how to conquer Europe, it's not. One of the popular toasts in Russia is 'For clear sky above our heads' which means so there won't be war (and no war planes, which bombed Russia in WW2). Russia is defensive, it has nukes to ensure that Europe and USA won't attack it and happy with this, and doesn't have nor desire neither ability for any significant war with western world.

Russia could win again Sweden alone, though it won't be that easy as well, as you said, Sweden is not completely defenseless. To attack big country you don't even border, with harsh environment and landscape and then control it is not an easy task. And that would be only Sweden attacked, that's my original point, why to do that? What's the point of attacking Sweden alone, you don't gain anything from it and then face the wrath of the world.

> In general i think you have the notion that the fact that Sweden is preparing itself for a Russian invasion means that Russia have somehow singled out Sweden

No, my notion is that it's Sweden who singled out itself. Lately I've seen abnormally many news about Sweden being afraid, and they even returned conscription, that's why I guessed that it's some local political play (though I don't know political situation in Sweden to be sure). And I'm worried about Sweden because I think it's waste of resources and people's time.

> If you still can't see that then I'm sorry but I don't know how to explain it in a more simple or detailed manner.

> If anything else fails then go to https://www.google.com/maps/place/Kaliningrad,+Kaliningrad+O.... and zoom out a bit.

No need to be condescending, I see what you say and I say it's not real scenario.

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by dogma1138 on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @09:14AM (#14496927)
A) You would assume that Russia would start the conflict, so far it's the west that is pushing it into a corner.

B) Yes this is a far fetched scenario, but as military scenarios go it's the only one that is applicable to Sweden no one else would invade, or attack Sweden other than Russia.

Sweden has a right to be afraid, it's not part of NATO so no article 5, Russia has been shown to respond to EU/NATO pushing into its sphere of influence with uncharacteristically direct responses.

Russia invaded Georgia effectively to kill the pipeline that the EU was planning to build after a Georgian provocation fueled by the west promising to back it up against Russian retaliation.

Russia went into Crimea again after western funded protests to oust a democratically elected government (corrupt or not) that both EU and US election inspectors concluded was elected fair and square simply because they didn't liked the results.

Russia is violating Swedish territorial waters and their airspace regularly, they deem waters that Sweden has claims too as their own, and effectively claim most of the Baltis as Russian territorial and economical waters.

So regardless of how far fetched this scenario is according to you the only 3 possible scenarios in which Sweden would be invaded are: Alien Invasion, Space Nazi's or the Russians, with the latter being the only one that might actually happen.

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by aquadrop on Tuesday June 06, 2017 @04:34PM (#14501057)
A -> Nuclear weapon is a giant no go sign. Nobody wants to be responsible for the end of the world.

B ->

> Sweden has a right to be afraid, it's not part of NATO so no article 5, Russia has been shown to respond to EU/NATO pushing into its sphere of influence with uncharacteristically direct responses.

Russia just doesn't like expansion of NATO in Europe in general, nothing specific to Sweden. When USSR put missiles on Cuba USA didn't like it a lot as well... But I don't know how much of that opposition is real, and what portion is just a political game. Because there's the same point as with Sweden being attacked by Russia - attack from NATO won't happen, as long as there's nuclear weapon.

Those issues you described are just local conflicts, that's the max what Russia can afford. And USA also do play with territorial waters, spy planes etc, that's all part of regular military routine.

> So regardless of how far fetched this scenario is according to you the only 3 possible scenarios in which Sweden would be invaded are: Alien Invasion, Space Nazi's or the Russians, with the latter being the only one that might actually happen.

There's much more than 3. But even you admit that it's a far fetched scenario, so it's not according to me, it's just far fetched, period. And that was my point, you can as well start preparing for alien space Nazi invasion, but will it be money well spent? It's like amputating your healthy foot because who knows, sometime in the future you can get diabetes. Returning conscription is a very serious thing to do, it's a large move which affects whole country. And there's no point in that. In 1 on 1 conflict it won't help and in case of large scale war (which Russia can't afford nor doesn't want) it won't matter, because Russia will be destroyed by the allies. And nobody here could come up with the answer to original question, "what is the point of attacking Sweden", alone, just Sweden, can you answer it?

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by eveningcoffee on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:04PM (#14484200)
>Even Finland and Norway which border Russia don't care, but Sweden do

Tell it to a random Finn and their eyes will not stop rolling.

Finland has modern reservist army with modern planes, tanks and very sizeable artillery.

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by aquadrop on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:52PM (#14484392)
I was referring to the fact, that lately I was hearing a lot of things specifically about Sweden being afraid and even returning conscription (that awful atavism of the past) because of that. I don't know about situation in Finland, but they seems to be welcoming Saint Petersburg visitors. If you ask random Finn how possible is war with Russia nowadays, what do you think he/she will answer? (I really don't know, just asking).
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by eveningcoffee on Sunday June 04, 2017 @08:31PM (#14484522)
>I was referring to the fact, that lately I was hearing a lot of things specifically about Sweden

I understand that Russian media really wants to ridicule Sweden for that. You do not have to buy this. Sweden has been very destructive to its military and they just started to realise it. I think it is good for them.

>Sweden being afraid and even returning conscription (that awful atavism of the past)

A reservist army is an only way to build a real defence for a small country.

Service time in a modern country is limited to reasonable time and is optimized to give reasonable military training.

If you compare it to the experience in the Soviet Army then it will be not comparable - it is not for painting grass or glueing leaves on trees.

>If you ask random Finn how possible is war with Russia nowadays, what do you think he/she will answer?

Do you mean on the street or after bottle of vodka (that is do you want to hear a politically correct opinion or the real one)?

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by mowenz on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:29PM (#14484307)
That's actually not true.

Russia has shown they have tendencies towards nationalism and imperialism. USA is fine with the globalism that is taking place, and has no problem flexing muscle abroad when it feels like it, i.e. profit motives for Iraq War, perceived threats against Germany if they provided Snowden asylum, CIA drug and weapons selling schemes for political or economic motives--i.e. Iran Contra or Gary Webb or US funding ISIS in Syria. None of this was ever to annex territory.

Last year the US dropped over 26,000 bombs. Zero territory gained.

The most bombed and devastated country in the history of the earth is... Laos. Definitely not for territory.

The plutocracy in the US simply would not attack Sweden because it does not need to do that to achieve their goals.

Even when it comes to torturing people, Sweden does this at the behest of the US--HRW has heavily criticized Sweden for this.

Why would the US invade such an obedient country? It's actually incredibly unlikely.

Russia on the other hand would take Scandanavia in an instance if it had the capability.

The biggest hope Russia has now is global warming. It appears to disrupt most of the world negatively while increasing water passages and even likely arable land in Russia.

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by pm90 on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:41PM (#14484346)
Yeah but they have a demographic crisis on hand for Pete's sake. Who will farm all that newly arable land if there is nobody left? I say that only slightly in jest, if there are no young Russians to support/replenish the ones leaving the workforce, the country will be in big big trouble. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_crisis_of_Russia
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by aquadrop on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:41PM (#14484348)
> Russia has shown they have tendencies towards nationalism and imperialism

"That's actually not true"

> Russia on the other hand would take Scandanavia in an instance if it had the capability.

No, not any person in Russia has thoughts like this. That's not even a topic for a discussion because nobody can think of such a thing.

> Why would the US invade such an obedient country? It's actually incredibly unlikely. Incredibly unlikely scenario: Assange returns to Sweden and start publishing materials about trump through Wikileaks. Sweden doesn't give him out. Trump orders marines to take him out by force. Yeah, I know it's pretty crazy unlikely, that's the point :)

> The biggest hope Russia has now is global warming. It appears to disrupt most of the world negatively while increasing water passages and even likely arable land in Russia.

Russia can't even use current water passages capabilities.

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by eveningcoffee on Sunday June 04, 2017 @09:22PM (#14484714)
>> Russia has shown they have tendencies towards nationalism and imperialism

"That's actually not true"

What about wide spread usage of George ribbons? What about cries about loosing Soviet territories? What about Nacy movement? What about constant shit talk in media? Etc, etc.

My observations are that Russia is spiralling into madness comparable to 1930 Germany. It is perhaps difficult to see while being inside of it but the sign are clearly observable from the outside.

I really wish that it is not like this. It is really saddening to observe this.

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by lambdadmitry on Monday June 05, 2017 @07:23AM (#14486774)
That madness spiral is sort of obvious for a sizable part of Russian population (hundreds thousands to single millions I would say), mostly new young (think millenials/Z) urban middle class. So there is a rift in the society, and there is hope that it's big enough to prevent whatever bad may come.
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by strictnein on Sunday June 04, 2017 @08:15PM (#14484464)
>> Russia has shown they have tendencies towards nationalism and imperialism > "That's actually not true"

It's not true in so much as Russia simply isn't powerful enough to be an imperial power.

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by Retric on Sunday June 04, 2017 @05:37PM (#14483678)
Russia has recently attacked a county on it's border and frankly there is only a short lit of such countries. Thus, it's vastly more likely that Russia attacks them than the UK.
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by aquadrop on Sunday June 04, 2017 @06:07PM (#14483875)
Sweden is not on the Russia's border. And Ukraine's situation is different and complex, it's not applicable to Sweden. Same not applicable as the fact that UK also not so long ago attacked Argentina. There's just no logic behind attacking Sweden. You gain nothing and face a lot of problems.
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by jbergens on Sunday June 04, 2017 @08:09PM (#14484445)
Russian spokespersons has multiple times said that if Sweden were to join Nato it would be a very serious thing that they would not like and almost see as agression towards Russia. They seem to be very touchy about what happens even close to their borders.
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by eveningcoffee on Sunday June 04, 2017 @08:40PM (#14484558)
Saying that they do not want Sweden to join NATO translates in my option to we want to keep possibility to invade Sweden open.

I think that it is a quite serious signal for Sweden to start taking again their army seriously.

Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by petre on Monday June 05, 2017 @01:43AM (#14485463)
They are. They've just restarted drafting.
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by Retric on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:44PM (#14484362)
Sweden is on Russia's border in the same way the US is. Aka it's a direct hop over an inland sea.
Re:Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play B... by aquadrop on Sunday June 04, 2017 @07:58PM (#14484402)
It's pretty large and hard hop, you can't easily do it.