Re:How to Call B.S. On Big Data: A Practical Guide
by candletot on Saturday June 03, 2017 @03:59PM
(#14478177)
I love this one:
'Mind the Bullshit Asymmetry Principle, articulated by the Italian software developer Alberto Brandolini in 2013: the amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it. Or, as Jonathan Swift put it in 1710, “Falsehood flies, and truth comes limping after it.”'
It summarizes my workplace experiences (yeah, confirmation bias). I've called bullshit on engineers a few times, but managers seem not to care. I gave up doing it, and instead whenever a engineer makes bullshit claims about a particular process/software/language I ask him "can you show us a working example?" Give them enough rope...
Re:How to Call B.S. On Big Data: A Practical Guide
by 1337biz on Saturday June 03, 2017 @12:02PM
(#14476978)
Great article! But when I saw the New Yorker Url my first reation was - let's see how they are going to make this into something negative about Trump this time. They still live up to my expectations.
Re:How to Call B.S. On Big Data: A Practical Guide
by elefanten on Saturday June 03, 2017 @12:22PM
(#14477068)
It was one joke said in passing. And it was directly relevant to the content of the sentence it was in.
I don't think your implied critique holds much water here. This isn't an academic paper anyway... it's an expository article written in the amusing/playful tone for which the publication is known.
Re:How to Call B.S. On Big Data: A Practical Guide
by 1337biz on Saturday June 03, 2017 @02:55PM
(#14477854)
Not sure if this was intended as a joke, or another one of those pedantic remarks. If they are serious about that argument they should start telling their advertisers not the total number of Unique Visitors, but the Unique Visitors in relation to the total number of Internet Users. I'd love to see how successful they became over the last 10 years...
Re:How to Call B.S. On Big Data: A Practical Guide
by sparky_z on Saturday June 03, 2017 @08:33PM
(#14479281)
It's not silly because the number changes over time. It could make the difference between an upward trend and a downward trend. (Whether that difference matters is up to you, but it is a difference.)
Re:How to Call B.S. On Big Data: A Practical Guide
by huac on Sunday June 04, 2017 @06:22AM
(#14480680)
But everybody faces the same trend in 'total worldwide internet users.' So if an advertiser has its choice of platforms to advertise on, it can compare the same metric, regardless of whether or not you do the division.
Re:How to Call B.S. On Big Data: A Practical Guide
by WillPostForFood on Saturday June 03, 2017 @05:38PM
(#14478640)
Did you really think it was great? The subject matter is critically important, but the article sadly lacking in substance. These are three of the bullet points, "Recognize that bullshitters are different from liars," "Watch out for unfair comparisons," "Remember that correlation doesn’t imply causation" - ok, so are they now passing off middle school science as college learning? This doesn't add much ammo to fight misuse of big data.
Re:How to Call B.S. On Big Data: A Practical Guide
by lovemenot on Saturday June 03, 2017 @06:37PM
(#14478868)
Well Google Flu Trends was debunked in the article. I guess they are just reiterating and updating some well-loved heuristics to also include some contemporary techniques / fallacies.
Re:How to Call B.S. On Big Data: A Practical Guide
by graycat on Saturday June 03, 2017 @04:18PM
(#14478280)
My guess about VCs and big data:
My guess is a special case of my guess about VCs and X for any new technology or
tech buzz word X, that is, just
substitute "big data" for X.
The guess is a special case of
the difference between the
sizzle and the steak. Or,
remember, sell the sizzle, not
the steak.
Well, VCs have Web sites
and there commonly
emphasize the X, the sizzle,
they are interested in.
In fact, for a VC, X or sizzle with a dime
won't cover even a 10 cent
cup of coffee. And a VC
won't invest even 10 cents
in X or sizzle.
So, why do VCs emphasize their
interest in X they don't care about?
Well, VCs want deal flow, that
is, entrepreneurs presenting their
projects so claim they are interested
in current sizzle X. Then entrepreneurs with a project in
subject X will eagerly contact
the VC.
Now what? Sure, the VC ignores
the X, the sizzle, and looks for
some steak, usually traction
significant and growing rapidly,
better still, revenue significant
and growing rapidly. They also
look at the founders, etc.
The one thing they do NOT look
at, understand, respect, evaluate,
or care about is X or the sizzle.
None of this effort means anything
for a VC unless they can
see enough steak to
start negotiations with the
entrepreneurs. Now we
see why the VCs said they
were interested in X:
During the negotiations,
they will pretend to
evaluate the business based
on X, not on the steak.
Then the VCs will denigrate, diss,
minimize, insult, run down,
criticize
X as of not very solid business
value and lower their
evaluation (pre-money)
of the business. And THAT'S
where the VCs get
their payoff for their
claims of interest in X.
So, selling/buying the sizzle
instead of the steak
hides the real value, the
steak, and the VCs want to do that.
There must be some explanation
for the very common practice
of VCs saying they are interested
in X. IMHO, no way are the VCs
interested in X, big data, AI,
ML, etc. -- those topics are just
sizzle to hide their interest
in what they regard as steak.
If can, then check out my
guess: Say, get a VC to
explain any of the value
of big data, AI, or ML
in a reasonably solid and
well informed way!
Uh, "X is eating the world"
is NOT good enough!
There must be an explanation,
and my best guess is above!
'Mind the Bullshit Asymmetry Principle, articulated by the Italian software developer Alberto Brandolini in 2013: the amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it. Or, as Jonathan Swift put it in 1710, “Falsehood flies, and truth comes limping after it.”'
It summarizes my workplace experiences (yeah, confirmation bias). I've called bullshit on engineers a few times, but managers seem not to care. I gave up doing it, and instead whenever a engineer makes bullshit claims about a particular process/software/language I ask him "can you show us a working example?" Give them enough rope...
I don't think your implied critique holds much water here. This isn't an academic paper anyway... it's an expository article written in the amusing/playful tone for which the publication is known.
It's an applied philosophy course, really, about how to spot misleading claims.
My guess is a special case of my guess about VCs and X for any new technology or tech buzz word X, that is, just substitute "big data" for X.
The guess is a special case of the difference between the sizzle and the steak. Or, remember, sell the sizzle, not the steak.
Well, VCs have Web sites and there commonly emphasize the X, the sizzle, they are interested in.
In fact, for a VC, X or sizzle with a dime won't cover even a 10 cent cup of coffee. And a VC won't invest even 10 cents in X or sizzle.
So, why do VCs emphasize their interest in X they don't care about?
Well, VCs want deal flow, that is, entrepreneurs presenting their projects so claim they are interested in current sizzle X. Then entrepreneurs with a project in subject X will eagerly contact the VC.
Now what? Sure, the VC ignores the X, the sizzle, and looks for some steak, usually traction significant and growing rapidly, better still, revenue significant and growing rapidly. They also look at the founders, etc. The one thing they do NOT look at, understand, respect, evaluate, or care about is X or the sizzle.
None of this effort means anything for a VC unless they can see enough steak to start negotiations with the entrepreneurs. Now we see why the VCs said they were interested in X: During the negotiations, they will pretend to evaluate the business based on X, not on the steak. Then the VCs will denigrate, diss, minimize, insult, run down, criticize X as of not very solid business value and lower their evaluation (pre-money) of the business. And THAT'S where the VCs get their payoff for their claims of interest in X.
So, selling/buying the sizzle instead of the steak hides the real value, the steak, and the VCs want to do that.
There must be some explanation for the very common practice of VCs saying they are interested in X. IMHO, no way are the VCs interested in X, big data, AI, ML, etc. -- those topics are just sizzle to hide their interest in what they regard as steak.
If can, then check out my guess: Say, get a VC to explain any of the value of big data, AI, or ML in a reasonably solid and well informed way! Uh, "X is eating the world" is NOT good enough!
There must be an explanation, and my best guess is above!
YMMV!!