It's pretty good in subdivisions. Then again, anyone can figure that out.
"Instant offers" is the online equivalent of those "we buy houses" signs that you see in some areas. It's a borderline predatory practice and makes you question the real reasoning behind doing it. They probably built it for some real estate state investment pool that bought up distressed property during the recession.
I didn't see what the package was, but when I recently refinanced, the bank used software that understood neighborhood overlays and could find comps on similar properties. It also listed similar but excluded comps and the reason why. (Ie bigger/smaller yard, garage, dead end, proximity to 4+ family, etc) The only input required was a questionnaire from a drive-by condition evaluation.
That appraisal was within a $5k error bar compared to informal assessments that I had done independently with 3 real estate people.
I sold my house for 750k. Today, months after the sale was recorded, the zestimate shows 657k.
I think buyers in competitive markets who rely on zillow will lose several times before they learn the market. I think sellers in competitive markets can just ignore it.
That said, I have never had good experiences with real estate agents. I didn't use one to sell 2 properties, and I havent used one when buying either (instead, asking to split 3% commission).
Edit: I ask because the populist-y invective on this site raises red flags for me, but I also don't know anything about this industry.