People don't like to have that conversation because they think it's inappropriate. However, it's more inappropriate for a founder to tell you that you're getting equity in lieu of compensation and explain nothing about the value of that equity and potential future value of that equity based on the current state and future state assumptions.
I mean, I was the first employee at a startup, involved with fund raising, and then founder at a startup, and even I would have a hard time with that.
Not to mention that even if you have a very solid understanding of what things are like when you get hired, it can all change dramatically in subsequent fundraising.
This is just one of many instances where the employee/employer relationship is heavily biased against the employee. And unless clear disclosure requirements understandable by the average worker are put in place, it'll stay that way. As an employee, your options are inscrutable lottery tickets which value can be redefined in many ways at many points in time, and there's not much you can do against that.
Totally - I've been thinking about actually putting on a "equity master class for engineers looking to join startups" type seminar in the bay area if people are interested.
https://goo.gl/forms/j70V7ew5Dds7AoOt1
If there's enough interest I'll put something on.
PS - By way of background, I work in tech M&A and regularly see cap tables, equity packages, salaries etc. both in and out of SV.
Yes, thanks for spotting the typo. Fixed.
If founders and investors really want to align their goals with employees, then start handing out rev share, otherwise, the employee is just deluding themselves.
The only thing I would value is participation in a trust designed to make it as difficult as possible for the founder to receive cash from their ownership stake without paying out to all minor participants. "If he's worth $1B, I'm worth $1M" is something I can value.
You've heard of this company.
You also trade off any ordinary protections as a consumer.
I really enjoyed the TL;DR stock option visualization earlier but for unicorns it would be a really interesting exercise to walk through various 'liquidity events' and their value and see the various percentages that went to which investors.
Where is the disconnect...?
As an aside, this is why I think that any effort of a prospective employee to divine the value of a stock option package is likely in vain. Without a detailed accounting of the ins and outs of the preferred stock that is senior to your common shares, it is nigh impossible to tell how much the common shares (and options thereon) are worth.