News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TLDR Stock Options by bumbledraven on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:17PM (#14464127)
From a purely monetary and risk-based viewpoint, whether to join a start-up depends on how much money you already have.

Suppose you regard tldroptions.io's probability distributions and outcomes as correct, and the only thing you care about is maximizing the long-term rate of goal of your capital. Then the Kelly Criterion (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelly_criterion , a.k.a. Fortune's Formula) says that you should try to maximize the geometric mean of your capital, which amounts to maximizing the expected logarithm of your capital.

To make this concrete, suppose you are choosing between two options:

- (Startup): Working at series C+ start-up for three years, where you receive 1% equity and $100k/yr salary, and have a 20% chance of getting ~$60 million in 3 years (according to tldroptions.io)

- (AmaGooFaceSoft): Working at AmaGooFaceSoft for three years, where you receive $300k/yr total comp (according to patio11)

For simplicity, I will ignore taxes and the time value of money. All monetary amounts below are in millions of dollars. If you have no money in the bank to start with, the geometric means of your alternatives after 3 years are:

- (Startup): exp(.2 log[60+0.3 ] + .8 log[0.3]) = $0.86 million

- (AmaGooFaceSoft) = $0.9 million

In this case, AmaGooFaceSoft is slightly better.

On the other hand, suppose you already have $1 million. After 3 years you will still have the $1 million, plus your salary and whatever money you get from your equity. Here the geometric means are:

- (Startup) exp(0.2 log[6+1+0.3] + .8 log[1 + 0.3]) = $2.8 million

- (AmaGooFaceSoft): 1+0.9 = $1.9 million

In this case, it's better to join the start-up.

The base salary matters a lot. If you have no money in the bank, but you get $150k year at the startup instead of $100k, then the geometric mean of the Startup option after 3 years is better than that of AmaGooFaceSoft:

- (Startup): exp(.2 log[60+0.45 ] + .8 log[0.45]) = $1.2 million

Re:TLDR Stock Options by anorwell on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:23PM (#14464194)
1% equity in a series C startup sounds wildly optimistic. You would most likely not get that much equity as a senior software engineer. It's interesting that your first calculation still favours the other choice.
Re:TLDR Stock Options by fnbr on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:38PM (#14464393)
Yeah, I agree. There's no way that an engineer is getting integer percentages of equity after seed round. Maybe if they're highly recruited, in which case Google et al. would pay more.
Re:TLDR Stock Options by morgante on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:36AM (#14467484)
You can get integer percentages right after a seed. (No way at Series C though.)
Re:TLDR Stock Options by ruleabidinguser on Thursday June 01, 2017 @10:41PM (#14467029)
Who would get integer percentages after seed round?
Re:TLDR Stock Options by kasey_junk on Thursday June 01, 2017 @11:44PM (#14467269)
C-suite hires that have other choices and capital investors.
Re:TLDR Stock Options by romanovcode on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:51PM (#14464560)
Yeah, I agree. No way someone in C round will get 1%.
Re:TLDR Stock Options by brianwawok on Thursday June 01, 2017 @08:14PM (#14466308)
A C-suite would I think, not an engineer.
Re:TLDR Stock Options by iamacynic on Friday June 02, 2017 @11:07AM (#14470419)
a c-suite would get more than that, probably closer to 3 or 5%, and also a signing bonus, as well as performance bonuses, a huge options package, and a termination clause / parachute clause. hell, throw in a relocation package and a credit card for entertaining customers and partners also.
Re:TLDR Stock Options by seattle_spring on Friday June 02, 2017 @11:06AM (#14470409)
On the other side though, $100k salary is widely pessimistic for a Series C employee who could command $300k total compensation at a FANG-type company. Realistically, their base salary would be closer to $150k - $180k.