News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by TeMPOraL on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @12:07PM (#14453562)
KSP is nowhere close to the limits of Unity, though, as proven by the modding community which (~1 - 1.5 years ago when I was last playing) provided better textures, atmospheric effects, better particle systems, and even shader-based atmospheric scattering. It would be entirely possible to incorporate all of that, in a more polished form, into the base game, given enough development time and will.

I mean, this is how my modded KSP looked back in time of 0.25C: https://i.imgur.com/yBahDMr.png. I could name AAA space sims that look worse (esp. in terms of immersion).

Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by ferongr on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @12:12PM (#14453612)
Graphics are irrelevant, I'm talking about physics. Stock KSP graphics are "good enough".
Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by CydeWeys on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @05:48PM (#14456201)
I disagree with you here. I think it's the physics that are "good enough", and the graphics are what really need improvement. I'm playing with lots of graphical mods now, and the game is just more fun. Going to different planets is more meaningful because they're just gorgeous. Landing on Kerbin is more fun because it isn't just a flat green plain with a repeating background texture and a limited number of different biomes. Better graphics also help to widen the appeal.

Say what you will about No Man's Sky, but that game was gorgeous, which contributed in no small part to its widespread interest. Now imagine how fantastic a game with those graphics but with KSP's mechanics would be.

Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by eriknstr on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @12:19PM (#14453675)
Your original comment read as if you were saying that Unity was to blame for what the graphics look like.
Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by Fifer82 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:11PM (#14454139)
Again I would say that if he did say that, he would be correct.

Sit me down in a room of 20 games, and tell me to identify unity games by simply playing each computer. On the 20% chance that I can't instantly tell by looking, a wee swipe of the mouse and the complete lack of responsiveness finalizes all I need for 100% success rate.

Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by TeMPOraL on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:29PM (#14454324)
I could do the same, and I could also tell you which games were made with Unreal Engine, which with Source Engine, etc. Game engines have distinctive traits that are hard to eliminate from a game but easy to notice while you play. That isn't an argument against Unity per se.
Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by Fifer82 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:53PM (#14454519)
It is with Unity because it equals bad performance. It isn't like other games which, if you throw a beefy rig at it, you get more performance for the most part. It has a "It is 2001 and my Flash Player Animation is running at 24fps and the fans are burning out" feel to it.
Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by adanto6840 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @05:37PM (#14456143)
It is most definitely possible to achieve great results, including performance, with Unity. It requires creating the game from the ground up with code, though -- and that does not seem to be the audience that Unity markets towards the most.

That said, it's not easy though it is certainly doable; it basically means you're using Unity largely as a "rendering pipeline" which may or may not be overkill, depending on the use case/game in question.

Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by Fifer82 on Friday June 02, 2017 @06:45AM (#14468941)
Finding any information on "Pure Code" setups for unity is impossible. As in, I think http://jacksondunstan.com/ has the only article on the internet.
Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by adanto6840 on Saturday June 10, 2017 @11:34AM (#14527698)
I know this is an old(er) post now, but thank you very much for the link. We actually had not seen that site before, and it's a treasure trove of fantastic information -- some of which we've found out ourselves, much of it new to us altogether.

You're right -- there's very little written on the topic. Though Unity has a fantastic community, and a large swath of information & user help to be found, a lot of it is directed at the newer/simpler developer (or mobile specifically).

Much of our work, and findings, has been derived from running our own tests & benchmarks as well as reading research/white-papers. In general, we've kind of found that many [advanced] game dev related topics are not well publicized or are fairly tightly-held. Our best source of information for things like highly advanced pathfinding, or low-level & high-volume multi-agent modeling/simulation strategies, have come directly from published academic research which has also been a treasure-trove of information.

We've read more research the last year or two than we did through all of school and the first ~10-15 years of our careers combined! =)

Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by andrewflnr on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:05PM (#14455057)
Out of sheer curiosity, what are the tell-tale signs of other engines?
Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by moron4hire on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:53PM (#14454517)
That has more to do with Unity being more accessible to beginners, thus more titles being released by less experienced people.
Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by LoSboccacc on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @04:59PM (#14455867)
I wonder how much of that is really true. there are unity games that show much complex physic than this, which has custom movement for orbital mechanic and uses physics mostly as a glorified stacking problem within connected rocket parts of which there aren't that many really.

I guess most of the physic slowdown is some improvised custom code around joints that makes the solver choke

Re:Kerbal Space Program Acquired by Take-Two Interactive by Fifer82 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:07PM (#14454097)
Lol @ this.

The very act of double clicking the icon to boot up unity === terrible performance.

"Maybe she's born with it" was a funny joke I recall when working in Dundee on a Unity Project. I remember moving to a temporary role (More to fill the team for the investors to smile) and they were using Lumberyard and what a total difference.

Unity is a poor mans game development solution and that might have perks, but a game the scope of KSP deserves way way way way more respect.