News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by TorKlingberg on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @06:19AM (#14451426)
It looks like Goldman Sachs is betting that Venezuela will sort it self out by 2022, and getting a good discount. I'm not sure how that is “making a quick buck off the suffering of the Venezuelan people”, or how the people would benefit if nobody buys the bonds.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by tyingq on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:12AM (#14451590)
The original letter has more detail as to why Borges believes that. I'm no expert, so I have no idea if it's plausible. On the other hand, if I were a citizen suffering under Maduro's regime, I'd be pissed at any sort of foreign investment that Maduro could spend as he wanted.

In short, "provides a financial lifeline to his authoritarian regime" and "desperate desire to gain resources needed to secure weapons and other instruments of oppression..."

Page 1: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DBAqsdZXkAEVKgF.jpg

Page 2: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DBAqtrDXYAABc9H.jpg

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by tgb on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:29AM (#14451649)
It's not directly useful for Maduro. They bought the bonds in the secondary market for a seventy percent discount. Maduro made no money off the sale. And at that large of a discount I don't think he'll have an easy time selling new bonds to anyone either.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by 1zq on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:55AM (#14451757)
From the article:

> While Goldman Sachs defended its trade by saying that it bought the bonds on the open market from a broker, bankers and traders say the money ultimately ended up in Venezuela’s treasury because the seller was an institution with ties to the government.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jevgeni on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:21AM (#14452247)
Which still doesn't matter, if it's the secondary market. You can't borrow $100 and get more than that.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by 1zq on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:40AM (#14452876)
But you can be the Venezuelan central bank and buy $2.8 billion in PDVSA-issued bonds and later sell those bonds at a 70 percent discount (i.e. around 840$ million) to Goldman Sachs.

Until the moment of the sale to GS the money had only been transferred between two entities associated with the government.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jevgeni on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:46AM (#14452919)
Yeah, but how does that generate free money for the Venezuelan state?
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by 1zq on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @11:02AM (#14453052)
It doesn't generate free money. On the contrary, it generates very expensive money.

For this operation, the central bank received about $840 million in cash from GS, and PDVSA must now pay back $2.8 billion plus interest to GS.

Whereas before this operation, PDVSA (owned by the Venezuelan state) had to pay back $2.8 billion plus interest to the central bank (also owned by the Venezuelan state).

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jevgeni on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @11:15AM (#14453157)
But where did the central bank get the 2.8 billion USD? Venezuelan central bank can't print USD. So, net the country owes 2.8 billion USD + interest either way. It's just that the ultimate creditors have changed.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by josefx on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @11:57AM (#14453487)
The 2.8 billion are PDVSA-issued bonds not USD, they only exist on paper and aren't worth a cent unless Venezuela can pay. Afaik Venezuela can print as many of those as it wants.

> So, net the country owes 2.8 billion USD + interest either way.

Venezuelas right hand owes money to Venezuelas left hand, both are Venezuela so Venezuela owes nobody. Now we have Goldman buying that dept from Venezuelas left hand and some more ( it can print as much as it wants of that ) for $5, Venezuela now owes 2.8 billion to someone else it has to pay back in the future in exchange for having $5 now. Those $5 benefit the current government and will affect any future government negatively.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by whatok on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @12:08PM (#14453577)
Venezuela cannot print USD and needs USD to pay coupons/principal.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by josefx on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @02:15PM (#14454715)
I may be missing something. They make USD by selling bonds, as long as they make more USD then the scheme has running cost they can increase the amount of USD they have right now by selling more bonds below value, leaving any future government in dept.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jevgeni on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @05:02PM (#14455890)
Venezuela cannot produce USD dollars out of thin air. If their monetary regime allows it, they may print Venezuelan bolivar at the cost of raising inflation in the country.

When we say "Venezuela issues a 2.8 billion USD bond" that means that the central bank sells new bonds denominated in USD on the international market (most likely an auction among bank players in London or NY).

What had happened here is that they did that and then unbeknownst to them one banker sold their bonds to another banker. The act of reselling that debt on the secondary market does not magically increase that debt. It just changes whom you have to repay it to.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by _r_o_y_ on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @11:03AM (#14453061)
The first one would be just like a transfer between accounts while what op suggest is that now they're receiving the money from Goldman.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jevgeni on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @11:09AM (#14453105)
Yeah, but they are not. If I sell you a car for $5000, I get the $5000 and you get the car. When you then resell the car to someone else, I am not involved in the deal in any way.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jessaustin on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:41AM (#14452380)
What stops Maduro from issuing a bond for $1000 and selling it for $100? After all he knows he'll be dead or in Switzerland when the bond matures. He just cares about the $100 now.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jevgeni on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:48AM (#14452928)
What's the difference between issuing a bond by Maduro and selling it?
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jessaustin on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:42PM (#14456799)
When he issues a bond, he takes a piece of paper (perhaps not literally...) and stamps "Venezuela will pay bearer $1000 on 1 January 2025" (or whatever) on it. When he sells it, he gives the piece of paper to someone else and in return they give him money, theoretically the present value of the bond. The discount between the two amounts is mostly an indication of Venezuela's creditworthiness, but of course a portion of the difference is just a reflection of the discount rate for assets to be delivered in future. This is exactly the same as when any other entity issues a bond.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by tgb on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:18AM (#14452221)
Good point.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by whatok on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:41AM (#14451703)
70% of par, 30%~ from where they were trading throughout the month.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by dagw on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:56AM (#14451765)
According to the article the bonds where bought from a group with ties to the government.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by chiph on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:21AM (#14452245)
At that quantity, I expect they just set a new price for them.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by tyingq on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:34AM (#14451669)
Makes sense, but I still see the reason oppressed people would make a stink.

If only to broadcast that it will be bad optics for any foreigner to support the current regime...or even appear to. Propaganda is likely going on both sides.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by whatok on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:48AM (#14451733)
The only reason why this is even made public is because Goldman is a big and easy target. There are mutual funds that I wouldn't be surprised a bunch of people here hold that easily dwarf GS in this space.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by tyingq on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:54AM (#14451751)
Sure, but that seems logical. If you want to make a deterrent, use a big name that will get press coverage, even if they bought on a secondary market.

For example, I'd be loath to buy Sudanese investments, even if I could prove it was a secondary market buy. The association just has bad optics.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by graedus on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @08:13AM (#14451834)
I agree, but GS appears to be resilient against bad optics so far. Some negative stories are written about them, some people on the internet call them 'criminal banksters', but no matter what happens they continue to make vast amounts of money and ex- (and likely future) employees seem to reliably find their way into top offices of government, central banks and other powerful institutions.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jevgeni on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:28AM (#14452297)
It isn't much of a deterrent, if you know that only a single competitotor of yours or just a few companies will be singled out for the outrage. Time and time again. There are fund managers, pharma companiess, and industrial conglomerates that acted way more shitty than most banks, but people tend to ignore that or forget that very quickly.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by tyingq on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:38AM (#14452356)
Well, it did give the opposition a podium that they didn't otherwise have. I would guess many of us wouldn't have thought about Venezuela today otherwise.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jevgeni on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @11:17AM (#14453172)
I like this idea. Although the economic arguments aren't particularly strong, they give the opposition an opportunity to be noticed.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by DarkKomunalec on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:53AM (#14452970)
"but people tend to ignore that"

You mean it doesn't get much media attention.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jevgeni on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:57AM (#14453002)
Yes. :)
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by conanbatt on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:23AM (#14452256)
I agree with you in general economic concepts but begin from argentina, I tell you, that all the money coming in for this will be poached by the current government in its corruption, and the next government will have to deal with that debt.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by privateprofile on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:49AM (#14452455)
Exactly what happens in Portugal and Greece with most of the money from the EU and the IMF, sadly...
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by DarkKomunalec on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @06:30AM (#14451457)
As happened in Greece, such purchases result in pressure applied to the country to pay off its debts, rather than help its people. It's good in the short term, but in the long term, government debt ends up as a massive transfer of capital to the lenders.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by bobcostas55 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @06:57AM (#14451530)
>As happened in Greece

Greece had the largest default in history[0], virtually all private debt holders were forced to take a ~70% haircut.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_sector_involvement

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by Retric on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:03AM (#14451558)
That 'haircut' is based on interest assumptions not actual costs. The actual haircut was only 53.5% of the face value so if you bought it from someone else at a higher discount you made significant profit. Assuming you sold it or there will be no second default.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by Spooky23 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:54AM (#14452497)
I'm all for knocking on predatory bankers, but that's not a very compelling argument.

The borrower sold a bond at par -- so they got their $1. As the entity who bought that bond, you're fucked... the borrower isn't making interest payments and the debt is looking like a bad debt. So you sell it at a distressed value, in your example $0.53, losing half your principal investment + interest, to cut your losses.

The entity buying the distressed asset knows it's junk, which is why they buy it at a steep discount. The fact that they may make a significant profit if the borrower starts making payments is irrelevant.

At this point people start whining about predatory Goldman Sachs, etc. Notice that there was no outcry when places like Greece and Venezuela were happily borrowing and squandering money based on German credit (Greece) or temporarily inflated oil revenues (Venezuela). In the case of Venezuela, they managed to also kill the golden goose by deferring critical investments in oil infrastructure and making dumb political decisions.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by Retric on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:23AM (#14452736)
Goldman Sachs has not and is not lending Venezuela any money. So, if they buy a bond from someone else at less than face value they have zero room to complain about an agreement that was not made with them. At best they are trying to make a quick buck off the person that sold them the bond and again have no room to talk with the issuer.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by Spooky23 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:58AM (#14453015)
That's not really accurate. Goldman bought the bond from the original owner and is now a creditor.

They can and will talk to the issuer about payment and have every right to demand full payment -- the obligation to pay is not diminished by the secondary market value.

In my personal case, I had an opportunity to buy tax exempt New York General Obligation bonds at a discount during the 2008 financial crisis. I did so, although New York isn't Venezuela and the discount wasn't 50%, the interest payments are based on the originally issued amount and if I hold the bond to maturity I will get the full principal.

As an individual with 1 bond I don't have the leverage of an investment bank, but I'm still a creditor and will be get paid in the event of some serious financial crisis.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by Retric on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @02:23PM (#14454773)
The idea that debt is transferable like this is a specific rule under a specific system. You can also loan debt so the recipient has right of first refusal on all transfers and then they could have simply bought that debt at that same discount.

I am not saying the second system is universally better, but there is a reasonable argument for and against it.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by whatok on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:29AM (#14452789)
The bond indenture kinda disagrees with your whole premise here.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by Retric on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:59AM (#14453028)
Suppose, I buy a bond at 5% interest over 1 year and it defaults after making most of the payments. If I effectively only get 1% interest the IRS says I still owe taxes on that 1% as profit.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by whatok on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @11:46AM (#14453400)
I don't understand what that has to do with your original premise.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by Retric on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @11:53AM (#14453458)
Profit and loss should be calculated from the actual investment not what you should get on paper.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by aoeusnth1 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:04PM (#14454078)
Just because Goldman Sachs would make an amazing profit if Venezuela actually made good on their debt doesn't mean they don't own Venezuela debt, right? "Goldman Sachs has not and is not lending Venezuela any money" is patently false.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by Retric on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @02:17PM (#14454729)
GS is buying debt that someone else had. That other group loaned Venezuela money and is now selling the debt at a discount.

Critically if GS did not buy the debt Venezuela would have exactly the same money and exactly the same obligations so the fact GS 'owns' the debt or bob the accountant owns the debt is only important in so far as GS can apply more pressure.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jessriedel on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @08:48AM (#14452039)
Sorry, are you saying that if a bond is supposed to pay a certain interest which isn't actually paid, that this isn't a partial default because the interest is only an "assumption"? And we should only count the face value of the bond?
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by ant6n on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:26AM (#14452277)
I think the point is more that by the time the default happened, the market already considered the bonds to be worth less then what they ended up being worth.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jessriedel on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:01AM (#14452557)
The fact that the market priced in the haircut does not mean there was no haircut. It just distributes the loss between different creditors. The bonds are just as much in default, representing a net transfer from creditors to borrowers.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by pyvpx on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:09AM (#14451577)
I humbly suggest reading the book "Debt: The First 5000 Years"
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by netsharc on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:25AM (#14452274)
Except, it has not defaulted to the ECB, Eurozone or IMF... these institutions are insane, when asked "We owe you x billion dollars at the end of the month. We can either pay you or pay our pensioners. What should we do?", the answer was, "Well, pay us!".
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by eeasss on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:09AM (#14451579)
The purchases happened at the secondary market. This means that this bond are already issued... this means that what you say above is not true.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by DarkKomunalec on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:14AM (#14451599)
Where the bonds were purchased does not affect Goldman's ability or motivation to pressure Venezuela.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jevgeni on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:24AM (#14452268)
Or any creditor's motivation for that matter. Debt must be paid back, regardless of who the creditor is.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by DarkKomunalec on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:50AM (#14452948)
Most legal systems disagree. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Default_(finance)

Society does not exist to serve contracts - it is the other way around.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jevgeni on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:59AM (#14453024)
I'm sorry, what? Most legal system recognize default as a breach of contract.

Also, contracts are between at least two parties. Which of these parties don't you consider being a part of society?

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by DarkKomunalec on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @11:48AM (#14453419)
Most legal systems have procedures in place for when debt cannot be repaid. That is why I take issue with the statement that it 'must' be repaid.

"Which of these parties don't you consider being a part of society?" - This is a strawman. Both are part of society, but the contract between them may do more harm than good in total. And blindly holding contracts sacred quickly leads to bad outcomes (non-competes, EULAs, some NDAs, etc.)

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by jevgeni on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @04:53PM (#14455832)
This is the same as taking issue with the statement "one mustn't steal" because there are mechanisms for dealing with theft.

Man, the straw man fallacy on HN is like the proverbial hammer... You are talking about externalities of private contracts. Thing is, this also is subject to specific legal regulations in most Western countries. It is not subject to whichever moral judgement you are trying to fit in here.

Construction, industrial emissions, things like that are when the state can limit the civil rights of contract parties. Buying and selling bonds is generally considered not to have externalities that endanger the common good.

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by raverbashing on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @06:33AM (#14451470)
Yeah. But don't bet on the current government doing that. Quite the contrary

Or even the next

This is pure speculation

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by xbmcuser on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @06:44AM (#14451502)
Banks control western politicians who will put who ever is in power under pressure to pay of the debt. I used to think people that talk like that are same as the ones that wear tin foil hats. But the last 6-7 years has made me realise that they are not completely bat shit crazy. And the world of power is power is most corrupted and the least in the news.
Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by arethuza on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @06:55AM (#14451526)
"And the Weak Suffer What They Must?" by Yanis Varoufakis (former Greek finance minster) has an interesting view on the mess that Greece (and indeed Europe and the rest of the world) is in. I don't think it's without flaws but it is certainly interesting - particularly his view of EU/ECB bureaucrats:

"a clueless, inefficient bureaucracy... working tirelessly for politicians with an infinite capacity to recite unenforceable rules"

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by CaptainZapp on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @08:20AM (#14451870)
On a sidenote (but likely interesting to HN readers):

Varoufakis worked as an economist for Valve[1]

[1] http://blogs.valvesoftware.com/economics/it-all-began-with-a...

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by raverbashing on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:13AM (#14451597)
That works if:

- The concerned politician has a slight sense of responsibility (even though paying banks first is less responsible to the people but has long-term goals)

- The concerned country has a minimal ability to pay

Venezuela has neither at this moment

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by greeneggs on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @08:40AM (#14451994)
Venezuela does have a minimal ability to pay. Eventually, default is likely, but they have paid all of their bond obligations so far. (The story you hear is that many of the bonds are held by political allies, so the payments transfer money to them.)

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/12/business/venezuela-oil-de...

Re:Goldman Buys $2.8B Worth of Venezuelan Bonds, and an Upro... by posterboy on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:24AM (#14451629)
For a second I read that as "western politicians who will put in power whoever ..."