News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Not To Write On Your Security Clearance Form by eob on Saturday June 19, 2010 @12:19PM (#1444850)
> He then got out a blank form and handed it to me, saying ``Here, fill it out again and don't mention that. If you do, I'll make sure that you never get a security clearance.''

That sentence perfectly sums up my experience with the security clearance process and demonstrates clearly how broken it is.

Re:What Not To Write On Your Security Clearance Form by hga on Saturday June 19, 2010 @12:53PM (#1444919)
In all fairness this was a particularly special case. And from a long time ago, way past the time anyone would be worried if he really had been a spy for Imperial Japan.
Re:What Not To Write On Your Security Clearance Form by rdtsc on Saturday June 19, 2010 @01:36PM (#1445002)
This happened in the 50s probably so it was after the war. Also the fact that he was 12 at the time obviously meant it was just a ridiculous coincidence. If he really was suspected of being a spy, the security officer wouldn't have torn up form and would have actually made him never be able to get a clearance again.

What has happened is that the security officer simply knows how the system is set up. It cannot handle 'ridiculous' spy stories. It can handle 'no spy stories' or it can handle 'real spy stories' -- ridiculous coincidences don't fit it. So he basically had forced his guy to lie because his story fit better into 'no spy story' bin.

Re:What Not To Write On Your Security Clearance Form by cabalamat on Saturday June 19, 2010 @01:47PM (#1445023)
This is true of bureaucracies in general. They each have a number of pigeonholes they want to put people in, and the trick of dealing with them is to decide what pigeonholes they have, decide what you want to be regarded as, and taylor your answers accordingly.
Re:What Not To Write On Your Security Clearance Form by ErrantX on Saturday June 19, 2010 @02:50PM (#1445142)
> They each have a number of pigeonholes they want to put people in

I'm not sure it's entirely fair to consider it that way. Bureaucracy work on Binary options because that generally makes things a lot easier. It's a hack. It might not be perfect for every individual to answer questions - but it makes organisation a lot smoother.

The officer was happy with the answer to his question about spying; so he decided it was not relevant to include it.

To me that sounds like bureaucracy working a little bit :)

It is when it goes wrong that it goes really wrong...

(It's like the gender question; if I ever have to ask for gender, which is infrequent, now I will consistently ask "what reproductive organs do you have?"))

Re:What Not To Write On Your Security Clearance Form by someperson on Sunday June 20, 2010 @12:26AM (#1445873)
It may be better to pigeonhole people depending on which sex chromosomes they have (and how many of each), rather than what reproductive organs they have.

This helps cater for aneuploid people, as well as people who have underwent gender changes.

Re:What Not To Write On Your Security Clearance Form by chr15 on Saturday June 19, 2010 @10:37PM (#1445760)
I think any process involving humans will be imperfect. There will always be the potential for loopholes.