News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by joshuak on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:00PM (#14446694)
That sounds a little better than the ridiculous Autodesk decision, however it sounds trivial to circumvent by simply putting a 'term of license' clause in the EULA.

I'd go so far as to say I don't think EULAs should be considered a valid legal instrument.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by phkahler on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:21PM (#14446857)
>> I'd go so far as to say I don't think EULAs should be considered a valid legal instrument.

Agreed. The EULA is not even mentioned at the point of sale. Most notably, the company that sold the software often has no idea who has entered into such an (alleged) agreement with them. I thought acknowledgement was a critical part of contract law, but somehow clicking a virtual button in private is claimed to qualify.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by awinter-py on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:39PM (#14446987)
contract-wise it seems from case law they're on pretty steady ground. Of consideration + capacity + intent, capacity is probably the trickiest when you're not in person with the counterparty.

I think the more interesting angle of attack is by calling this a contract of adhesion, i.e. saying that the vendor is using their superior market position to force a long and disadvantageous contract on customers.

At the point where EULA was being invoked for many or most buyers, you could probably file a class action claiming the product was falsely advertised (i.e. it costs not $9.99 but $9.99 plus 100 hours of legal fees).

The uniform code of commerce is very concerned about terms hidden in long contracts, which is the reason some parts of long EULAs are in caps.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by phkahler on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @02:19PM (#14447284)
What if I say aloud "No, I do not agree to the terms of this EULA, but I'm going to click this button in order to install the software anyway." How about that? You may say "but clicking the button indicates agreement" to which I say it does not unless I actually agree to the terms of the EULA. The EULA is the only thing defining the meaning of clicking the button...

Lets suppose a techo-archeologist in 2100 finds an old PC and some MS windows install disks. Wow! he says, I've found a major artifact from a hundred years ago in the heyday of the internet! He gets it to power up and loads the disks in. He finds the EULA and takes pictures and uses OCR software to document his findings and then says "Huh, I wonder how anyone would ever read all that or agree to it, I sure don't agree with it, but I've got my research to do." And he clicks "I agree". Did he just enter into a contract? With whom? Suppose Microsoft went under completely in 2075. How does this clicking a button equate to him entering a contract? It seems incredibly absurd to me.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by awinter-py on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:23PM (#14447771)
Or yeah, what if I speak a language similar to english except the word 'EULA' means 'none of the following applies'.

Or what if I dance around in a circle reciting green eggs & ham whenever I sign anything?

Let me know when you find the court that is willing to hear these questions.

Unfortunately the 'had my fingers crossed' test from SCOTUS US v every 5 year-old was recently struck down.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by tripzilch on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:34PM (#14454362)
Pretty sure that last one would go the other way, actually.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by awinter-py on Thursday June 01, 2017 @12:07AM (#14457946)
trey gowdy did say that james clapper only committed perjury after lying about the same thing 3 times. Fortunately congressmen's statements don't carry the weight of law.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by labster on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:18PM (#14447731)
He'd enter into a contract with whoever bought Microsoft's IP, presumably OracleApple or Teslabet. Old corporations never die, they just fade away.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by deong on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:18PM (#14447732)
Well, if you sign the contract and the contract is legally "fair" (i.e., you weren't coerced, nothing fraudulent took place, etc.), then it doesn't matter what you say. The EULA isn't the only thing defining what agreeing to the contract means. The general framework of contract law in your country defines it as well.

We can quibble over whether EULAs are enforceable contracts due to one reason or another, but you can't just say, "Well I don't agree with the meaning of the EULA, therefore I'm not bound by the agreement".

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by codedokode on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:55PM (#14448043)
The contract should be signed before buying the software, not when a consumer has already paid for it or wasted his time and Internet traffic to download it.

Imagine if you bought something and then learned that you have to pay again to be able to use the item.

A contract should be beneficial for both parties. But EULA only limits consumer's rights without giving everything in exchange.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by deong on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:26PM (#14455217)
It gives the consumer access to the software.

I agree that the fact that you only see them after the sale is a problem, though one that would be "solved" to some degree if every vendor could be reliably relied on to honor the terms that say "if you don't agree, return it to the vendor for a refund".

There are bunches of problems around EULAs, but the general concept of an agreement you must adhere to in order to legally use the product doesn't seem especially legally shady to me. Or at least not in the ways referred to by the commenter I was replying to.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by johncolanduoni on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:13PM (#14448177)
Most contracts limit a party's rights without giving everything in exchange.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by Retra on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @07:20PM (#14449370)
If you don't agree to the terms of the agreement then you don't have an agreement.

Half the software I use has EULAs that were "agreed to" by some other third party.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by deong on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:30PM (#14455244)
And if you don't have an agreement, you have no right to use the software.

The execution of the EULA as a thing you don't get to see up front introduces problems, for sure. But I don't see anything blatantly illegal about an agreement that says, "you must adhere to these terms to use this software".

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by Retra on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @11:30PM (#14457789)
Define "use." What is it that I do not have a right to do? Look at other peoples' phone screens? I didn't agree to the iOS EULA. Can I listen to the music coming out of my partner's laptop? I didn't agree to any music app EULA.

>But I don't see anything blatantly illegal about an agreement that says, "you must adhere to these terms to use this software".

That is not an agreement. I often cannot agree to those terms, because I do not know what they are. And I will use the software regardless, because "use" means nothing specific unless we have an agreement on what that means as well.

EULAs are "agreements" that do not require agreement, that often bind someone to do something they cannot reasonably do.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by arcbyte on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @02:50PM (#14447488)
It depends.

Law is generally meant to be "reasonable" and much depends on the particular facts.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by kevin_b_er on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @06:09PM (#14448956)
You have cited class action and the uniform code of commerce.

If EULA contains mandatory binding arbitration and a no class action clause, both your ideas are dead in the water.

Per the SCOTUS contract law supersedes class action. Your idea for a class action is dead. Mandatory binding arbitration is not required to follow any law but the AAA. The arbiter may ignore the UCC. The UCC concerns are now dead as well.

Even the _legality_ of a contract itself probably does not stop mandatory binding arbitration: http://www.law.com/sites/davidmgersten/2014/08/01/arbitratio...

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by awinter-py on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @11:22PM (#14450215)
I'm not a lawyer nor a consumer law expert.

My theory of the case is that if the goods delivered were known to be unfit by the vendor, consideration was not met and the contract wasn't formed.

Some of these contracts waive the implied warrant of merchantibility. Not sure which jurisdictions allow that. Not sure if the warrant of merchantibility is still 'implied' if a specific use is advertised and the product isn't fit for that use.

I suspect the unconscionability test in contract law is stronger in contracts of adhesion.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by awinter-py on Thursday June 01, 2017 @11:51AM (#14461330)
actually ignore the above. I just read your law.com/davidmgersten source and I clearly have no idea what I'm talking about.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by matt4077 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:17AM (#14451608)
To quote my law professor on EULAs in the EU: "I never read them. They are either fair, or unenforceable".
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by chmod775 on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:09PM (#14446774)
In the EU it is impossible for normal consumers to sign away most rights intended to protect the consumer.

Misleading the consumer in any way about that can even end in fines.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by doikor on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:50PM (#14447081)
EULAs in EU are a joke. A "normal" consumer cannot even sign away most of the consumer protection rights even if he wants to.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by jakc on Thursday June 01, 2017 @09:38AM (#14460097)
A funny joke, like, do they make EUlaugh?
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by Tuna-Fish on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @02:11PM (#14447225)
In the EU, that doesn't work. Specifically because none of the conditions of the EULA apply to the sale unless you were presented it before you paid for the product. If it's possible to purchase the product in such a manner where you are not presented the EULA before you bought it, you can ignore a lot of it's conditions.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by codedokode on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:59PM (#14448074)
If a seller wants to impose some conditions of course he should do so before selling his product rather than try to deceive a customer after purchase. Only a dishonest seller would do such a thing.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @06:57AM (#14451531)
IMO any company that is using words like buy, sell, sale, purchase, get, of a product and not specifying they are selling only a _license agreement_ are committing a heinous fraud and should be fined no less than a years median profit (or, let's say, 5% of revenue as an underpin).

Sure, advertise "get license to use Wandows for a limited period, further restrictions on use apply" but if you say "get Wandows for $100" then you sold it and no EULA or other additional restrictions can apply; and no, small-print doesn't count.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by brlewis on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @05:52PM (#14448853)
U.S. statute is supposedly the same. A valid contract involves consideration from both parties. After you've bought something the contract is set. One party can't subsequently say, "oh in addition you have to agree to this."

Unfortunately law isn't what got written into statute or precedent yesterday. Law is what happens to you in court today.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by kevin_b_er on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @06:29PM (#14449077)
Please stop talking about "valid contract" or "consideration" here. The EULA almost certainly contains a provision on mandatory binding arbitration.

The validity of the contract may be ignored.

Under "BUCKEYE CHECK CASHING, INC. v. JOHN CARDEGNA, ET AL." and "Rent-A-Center West v. Jackson" mandatory binding arbitration overrides a challenge to the validity of the contract. The arbiter will decide if the contract is valid.

Under "Hall Street Associates, L.L.C. v. Mattel, Inc." the arbiters "manifest disregard of the law" is not enough to overturn an arbitration award against you.

So, no, a valid contract is not required, so long as an otherwise invalid contract contains an mandatory arbitration provision, the "contract" will be decoded by mandatory binding arbitration. If you are a human vs a corporation, your win rate is 0.2% in the national arbitration forum.

A purchase is not required to be locked into a mandatory binding arbitration agreement, because a whether you'd made a purchase would be part of the validity of the contract.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by Confusion on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @02:53AM (#14450803)

  The EULA almost certainly contains a provision [..]
That's begging the question. The question is whether any provision in the EULA is relevant at all.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by politician on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @08:04PM (#14449579)
How does one avoid being locked into a mandatory binding arbitration agreement? For example, suppose I run a website that contains a TOS such that it requires visitors to deposit into my bitcoin account scaled by marketcap and a MBAA. When the Google crawler comes by, do I hit the jackpot?
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by politician on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @12:30AM (#14450430)
Well, I found this article which seems to present a case where the decision went against the idea of "drive by" mandatory binding arbitration agreements, so I don't think my get rich quick scheme will work.

Knutson v. Sirius XM Radio Inc. http://www.blankrome.com/mobile/index.cfm?page=resource&&vie...

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by stordoff on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:50AM (#14450641)
Per Rent-A-Center:

> There are two types of validity challenges under § 2: "One type challenges specifically the validity of the agreement to arbitrate," and "[t]he other challenges the contract as a whole, either on a ground that directly affects the entire agreement (e.g., the agreement was fraudulently induced), or on the ground that the illegality of one of the contract's provisions renders the whole contract invalid." Buckeye, 546 U.S., at 444, 126 S.Ct. 1204. In a line of cases neither party has asked us to overrule, we held that only the first type of challenge is relevant to a court's determination whether the arbitration agreement at issue is enforceable. [...] But that agreements to arbitrate are severable does not mean that they are unassailable. If a party challenges the validity under § 2 of the precise agreement to arbitrate at issue, the federal court must consider the challenge before ordering compliance with that agreement under § 4.

Could one not attack the agreement to arbitrate on the grounds that no binding agreement could ever have been reached in the circumstances? Even severing the arbitration clause from the remaining of the contract, it seems it could be argued that there was no agreement to arbitration, as there was never any intention to enter into an agreement of any kind (I'm assuming the claimant would argue that they knew the EULA was not valid as a contract and thus ignored the terms). This seems especially so as the FAA specifies "[a] written provision in [...] a contract" - there was never any intention to create a contract by at least one of the parties.

Even if the argument does not hold, framing in such a way would require the courts to consider it (the validity of the agreement to arbitrate) rather than it just passing it directly to the arbitrator.

Perhaps that's just a hopeful reading of the case; it just seems absurd to me as an English lawyer (degree, non-practising) that the arbitration clause can be plucked out and enforced when the contract itself is a farce.

Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by vixen99 on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:12PM (#14447661)
its conditions
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by EpicEng on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:37PM (#14446978)
My uneducated opinion is that it wouldn't matter, in the same way that you cannot sign away your right to warranty in the EU.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by kevin_b_er on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @05:52PM (#14448851)
A surprise contract that most don't pay attention to and severely limits the rights of the target human is an American standard.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by zurn on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @11:34PM (#14450256)
Also in most business contexts employees have no right to sign contracts on behalf of their employer.
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by moomin on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:40PM (#14446998)
Shouldn't be, but most definitely are as a matter of settled law in the US. :(
Re:SCOTUS: Patent Rights Over a Printer Cartridge Are Exhaus... by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:01AM (#14451551)
This is a good test of democracy surely. What proportion of the population want EULAs, want not to own stuff they bought? Yet the USA as a supposed democracy has laws that contradicts that position with arguably no benefit to society.