Re:Mossberg Final Column: The Disappearing Computer
by bluGill on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @09:28AM
(#14445174)
Is my dishwasher in the kitchen a robot? Justify your answer (either is acceptable, I'm looking for your reasoning).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mossberg Final Column: The Disappearing Computer
by wvenable on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @11:44AM
(#14446111)
I think a robot has to have an arm. If it doesn't have an arm, it's not a robot -- it's just a machine. The whole robot could just be a single arm or the arm can just be one part. But it has to have an arm.
Re:Mossberg Final Column: The Disappearing Computer
by JauntTrooper on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:24PM
(#14446878)
Haha. There is an anthropomorphic element to it.
When most people think 'robot', they think of something with human or animal-like elements. So for example a rolling delivery or security drone would be a robot, but an automated car would not.
Re:Mossberg Final Column: The Disappearing Computer
by wvenable on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:31PM
(#14446932)
Too human-like and it's an Android. Not creature-like enough and it's just a machine.
Re:Mossberg Final Column: The Disappearing Computer
by monkmartinez on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @09:50AM
(#14445325)
Yes. The dishwasher (DW) does not complete the entire dishwashing circuit/task, but certainly a major portion. That is, the DW can not load or unload itself generally, but it can sanitize, wash and dry among other tasks. Thus, meeting the general definition of a robot: carry out a complex set of instructions/actions automatically once programmed.
Re:Mossberg Final Column: The Disappearing Computer
by Eridrus on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @09:48AM
(#14445313)
Not the OP, but I think the answer is definitely no.
Robots are not well defined, but I think at the minimum they imply the ability to be reconfigured for a large number of physical tasks that involve interactions with an environment.
Re:Mossberg Final Column: The Disappearing Computer
by liotier on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @10:19AM
(#14445545)
My feeling is that the "robot" concept requires feedback loops and flexibility to adapt to a wide range of situations. As technology progresses, the required amount of magic required to warrant the title is a moving target.
Re:Mossberg Final Column: The Disappearing Computer
by RyanMcGreal on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @12:12PM
(#14446323)
In that case, is my clothes dryer a robot? In addition to its timed dry setting, it also has a feedback setting in which it runs until the clothes inside have reached a (configurable) specified level of dryness, at which point it turns off.
Re:Mossberg Final Column: The Disappearing Computer
by liotier on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:32AM
(#14450938)
At some point in the past, such automatic intelligence would have stunned the populace - but nowadays nothing short of sorting, folding and piling on the clothing shelves would let the punters cry "robot !"