* To innovate, the GDS only think about how the messaging should be differently handled.
* To buy a ticket, an airline/travel agent uses almost the same syntax throughout the world (this is a miracle, when you can't even order cabs in the same manner in the world).
* Airline companies implement similar interfaces (between different GDS) to handle ticket processing. Which is another miracle: think freight handling done with the same messaging protocol.
Now add to the mix modern protocols and you get nice APIs. The hotels CAN be the only one properly consuming the APIs (w/ gorgeous and easy to use platforms), but if they can't do it well, let tech-aware organisations do it.
Instead, these hotels are fighting for breadcrumbs and insulting companies which have done more to facilitate accomodation than any other hotel in the past 40 years.
That's massive revenue, not "breadcrums". Certainly hotels shouldn't avoid that revenue just because it might "insult" a different company.
Frankly the aggregators provide really low value to the hotel as a stakeholder in the process. They demand concessions and commoditize the hotel itself, which is obviously not in the hotel's interest.
This is a classic channel vs direct issue. The only reasons that travel agents and these aggregators exist is that they provided a way to offload inventory or increase demand. Now we have the internet -- so it is easy and cheap for hotels to engage directly with many customers. Why should my local Hilton Garden Inn give 20% of the gross to Expedia?
For the core customers of the business, the hotel can offer more value to the customer (things like online checkin, etc) while cutting out the commission to the middleman. Travel agents still offer value for complex itineraries, destination travel, integration with corporate ERP systems, etc.
It's really not.
> Why should my local Hilton Garden Inn give 20% of the gross to Expedia?
Because Expedia has the traffic to actually sell those hotels. Aggregators "are" the market.
It's all XML based and sometimes it's a bit confused but a lot of hotel booking sites work by forwarding OTA/HTNG schema messages to booking engines (e.g. Siteminder). A heck of a lot of hotels are already bookable through those engines.
> OpenTravel provides a framework where all companies in the electronic distribution supply chain can work together toward the common goal of creating an accepted structure for electronic transmissions using XML messaging. This enables suppliers and distributors to speak the same interoperability language, trading partner to trading partner.
Had you not explained, I would never imagine this is about hotels.
Meh. For that to be true, it would have to be the case that all consumers care only about price. I'm pretty sure that's not actually the case. As long as there are consumers who will pay more for $WHATEVER, there will be a market for $WHATEVER. The point is, you can still price discriminate, even if you make your data available as a simple JSON (preferably JSON-LD) file.
The current state of the airline industry makes a pretty strong counter-argument.
That's why we don't see a lot of competition and innovation in the airline industry.
Second, messing around with price & doing complicated, on the fly pricing helps them cut a little extra margin (price differentiation). One price for a regular business customer. Another price for last minute online booking engines. A whopper of a price for the couple deciding to take a date from the bar to a room. This is a low margin industry, largely. These things matter.
Third, they're afraid of commodification. Standardization & informational liquidity are the path to commodification. They like the idea of a travel agent recommendation, not a spreadsheet with a "book now" button.
And since the job of the aggregator is simple, more competition ?
A commoditized market has products, by definition, that compete on one factor, price.
If you care about cleanliness, quietness, or other qualitative features being areas of active competition, you don't want a commoditized market.
People don't just buy generic meat they buy Grade A (means something) Prime Rib (means something) Angus Beef (means something).
No, but it does mean that goods are perfect substitutes that compete only on price, although it is a condition which in practice is approximated more often than actually attained.
> People don't just buy generic meat they buy Grade A (means something) Prime Rib (means something) Angus Beef (means something).
Right. "Meat" isn't even approximately a commodity. A particular cut and grade might be approximately a commodity (though makers will actively seeking to decommoditize it by building brands; no one wants to sell into a commodity market, since basic economics mean that competitive factors will drive market prices in such a market down to producer costs and eliminate profits.)
Maybe it's different for recreational travelers, but for at least one business traveler my hotel room was just a place to park my clothes and stuff during the day, and to sleep at night. As long as the AC worked, and the bed was anything close to reasonable, the rest was moot.
Hotels seem to aim their products at their primary customers (business travelers), and the product they sell is designed to primarily meet their needs. They compete on non-room amenities (bar quality, workout rooms, etc.) and on loyalty points, which frequent business travelers can use to make personal trips to vacation destinations. None of these things have any value to a family that makes 1-2 trips a year.
AirBNB does target my needs, with detailed pictures of exactly the space I'll be living in, diverse housing options, with many of the amenities that I desire above. I also care a lot less about cleanliness when I'm traveling with family. Yes, I want clean sheets, towels and other personal items. However, I don't care about a little dust in the kitchen cabinets, some spots on the windows, aging/peeling paint, or a few spiderwebs in the corners. My kids are going to make a mess no-matter what, and I certainly don't clean my home to hotel-standards every night.
I have seen a few mainline hotel chains offer family-focused properties (The Hyatt House in Anaheim is one.) However, the family-focused ones aren't that common. An AirBNB apartment I can rent almost anywhere.
The one place where I do feel some brand loyalty, is actually on the airline side, where I have a strong preference for Southwest. And that was even more true back when I still had elite status with them and got free early-bird boarding. That was something I actually cared about since my company wouldn't pay for early-bird, seat upgrades, and the like.
The same thing is appealing for hotels, IMO.
Are you familiar with SABRE/AMEDEUS? The flight industry did exactly this and it's been a disaster for them. Heck, they even handle hotel bookings as well.
If it's a disaster, it's a much smaller one.
per query/booking/inventory update
The airlines own the GDSes but carriers are a commodity now.
Huh? Sabre is owned by TPG and Silverlake.
Airlines would like lower fees, but it's not as bad as hotels. They have shed most commissions over the years.
every single airline uses a common messaging format for reservations, routing and itinerary generation BECAUSE of SABRE/Amadeus and doesn't have to roll their own systems to do it.
please tell me how this is disastrous.
Airlines can't publish their inventory because they agreed to only allow GDSes access to that data.
Getting access to the GDSes as a small startup is extremely difficult, and the obvious value-add (searching many possible trips) is punished by the pricing structure.
Hipmunk came around this decade. But no clue on how good the acquisition is. Trip.com and HotelTonight are the last two properties I know off the top of my head and they were also founded this decade. Both seem to be doing decently.
I guess maybe you're right and now there isn't room anymore. But if things could come out 5 to 7 years ago, we could see some more pop up.
HotelTonight fills a niche but I think the market they play in is pretty small.
I agree, HotelTonight fills a specific niche and maybe that's what we'll see more of. A few sites filling niches. Trip.com itself also has to do some more superficial than substantial features to try to differentiate itself.
And maybe Hipmunk was always more hype than actually being big with it being a YC company and by a reddit co-founder.
This would make it far easier to build a hotel search engine, which would cause an explosion of competition and innovation in this area. This in turn would undercut the power of the leading agencies, and drive down referral pricing.
But they won't do this. You see the same problem in so many industries. Vendors act like data about their offering is more precious than the offering itself. They make it as hard as possible to build an aggregator, so the aggregation market gets tied up by a tiny handful of players who are willing to invest enough to build a scraping infrastructure. Then they panic that these aggregators have too much gatekeeping power, but rather than encouraging greater competition amongst aggregators, they respond by trying to put the genie back in the bottle.