News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by Baeocystin on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @12:19AM (#14442984)
>There's a ton of Stupid Computer Shit we all know, mostly from messing around on our own time

This, I think, is the core issue. Like most of us here, I started playing with computers as a young child, from a Timex Sinclair 1000 as a pre-teen to a Commodore 128 as a young teen, then an Amiga and beyond. It wasn't work, it was fun, a hobby. And more importantly, by the time I hit college, I had literally thousands of hours of practice just being immersed in how computers work.

I started tutoring other students in CS for some beer money, and it was a real shock at how awful otherwise very intelligent people were at what I considered utterly trivial questions. But they weren't trivial. They were only simple if you already had a complex, detailed and well-worn model of how computers work running in your head. Without that, even simple computer tasks may as well be written in cuneiform for all the good it does the genuinely new student.

I'm not even sure it is possible to take a young adult who is truly computer illiterate and have them succeed in a technical major. At least not in a standard 4 years. There is simply too much foundational knowledge you need to have before you can even begin the real work of learning what to do.

Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by uncletaco on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @08:50AM (#14444904)
So my story is a little different. I didn't write my first program until I was in college and didn't even own a personal computer until I was going into my junior year in 2009.

I had the advantage of having a department that assumed we were computer illiterate (I went to an HBCU in the late 00s: lots of low-income kids, very few had PCs of their own growing up, let alone college educated parents) so there were a lot of resources dedicated to tutoring, TA involvement in labs, and building a community around our department. It sort of felt like being in a sports club. Every freshman was assigned am upper-classman mentor and every mentor I had took their role seriously. If I didn't come around for a week I got a phone call. If I struggled I got extra help, and my relationship with my mentor was something that came up if I started slipping in a class. We also had advisors based on our interests who were constantly throwing REUs, internships, and events into our face.

When I went to grad school at a majority institution it was like night and day (no pun intended). Lower level students were often left hanging on a vine and were only paid attention to if they were already successful. The TAs weren't actively helping students, only passively so. I left there thinking there were probably a lot of kids who got turned off to the major because they didn't get the help they needed. Poor kids especially had it rough because they often came from a situation like mine, households with one computer that they were only allowed to use if they were using word write a paper or something.

I say all that to say I think you can teach a young adult to succeed in a technical major in 4 years, but it takes a village. If you immerse them in a community built around that technical major, it becomes a lot easier to get them up to speed.

Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by xeromal on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @12:30PM (#14446479)
Agreed. I think what's more important than tinkering with computers as a child is to just have willpower to stare at something for hours with no end in sight just to have a small breakthrough. Those breakthroughs, for me, almost seemed to reward me with little releases of endorphins like solving a puzzle.
Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by uncletaco on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @12:42PM (#14446557)
I lived for those "a-ha" moments too. I remember when the theory of computation clicked and the rush of understanding that washed over me that put everything I'd done in that class in perspective. It was probably the best feeling I ever had in my academic career.
Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by Baeocystin on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @05:56PM (#14448866)
Thanks for sharing your story. It makes me genuinely happy to hear.

It really bothered me that I wasn't able to successfully tutor more CS students, and many folks that I know would have (eventually) loved it and thrived in the discipline dropped out due to their inability to get over the hump.

It sounds like from your experience direct, constant mentoring (along with a highly motivated student!) does work.

Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by YZF on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @12:43AM (#14443041)
I should have thought about beer money. But I was such an introverted geek.

I do remember watching other people trying to figure out how to use a mouse or the most basic stuff. I've already studied algorithms and data structures and had a paying programming job. Most of the CS work seemed trivial but I did learn some math. The math did get hard so the degree was definitely not a breeze. Even with CS there were areas that were less trivial like computational geometry or numerical methods but I had the advantage that coding was a non-issue so I could focus on the essence.

Many many many years later, I still often make the mistake of assuming things that look trivial to me are also trivial to others. It's just so hard to tell whether something is universally trivial or just trivial because you've done it so many times.

I wonder if the current generation's "playing" with their phone/computer/tablets gives them an advantage over the previous generation. I do work with quite a few sharp young people but I don't know whether they had programmed before going into CS or not, I guess I should ask...

Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by tsukikage on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:23AM (#14443695)
If anything, it's a disadvantage IME: the implicit lessons of the iDevice are that the world is made of non-user-serviceable black boxes that cannot be recombined to make anything substantially different than what you started with, and if one does ever manage to peek under the hood (and why would one do that, any more than they do with their fridge or their TV?) one sees only immutable non-deconstructible complexity.

Contrast this with the 8-bit era: devices made of multiple clunky components large enough to manipulate and simple enough to fully comprehend, shipping with "user manuals" that look like today's programming textbooks or service/maintenance manuals (where those exist today at all), a readily available developer environment giving full access to the hardware, tinkering with hardware and software as a matter of course to get anything interesting done at all... The experience is very different indeed.

Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by rjbwork on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @05:20AM (#14443949)
I totally agree with this. The mass produced handheld computers such as smartphones and tablets, which outnumber desktops and laptops in personal ownership worldwide, will absolutely not help the newer generations with learning how computers work.

When I was a tween I was building my own desktop, installing drivers, trouble shooting driver issues, trawling log files, and even dabbled in a little bit of python here or there when I had no idea what I was doing.

None of that is even a thing on the black box of of a touch screen device.

Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by sqeaky on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:17PM (#14446828)
I am so glad that there are enough people around to support a healthy PC components market. I build 1 or 2 per year and I haven't felt the supply dwindle yet.

It is a shame that this is no longer the default option, but it can be done for people wanting to get an educational experience. I wonder how easy it would be to build a computer with a little kid?

Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by Baeocystin on Saturday June 03, 2017 @03:36AM (#14475427)
My six-year-old nephew sat with rapt amazement as I assembled a standard PC in his living room while hanging out with the family. It was a very straightforward build- just motherboard, CPU & RAM, no addon cards, hard drive was already in the case. His mind boggled a little when he saw all the wires from the power supply, but as I pointed out how each group of wired to key into only certain ports, I could see the 'aha!' in his eyes.

(He also just about jumped for joy when he saw the color-changing LED fan I put on the case.)

Obviously at that age he doesn't quite have the manual dexterity to do the work himself, but I let him touch the RAM as I installed it so he could feel it click in to place, and showed him how to close & latch the CPU lever.

He appeared to really enjoy the experience. The next time one of the offices I work for retire some desktops, I may clean some up and partially disassemble them, so he can 'build' one himself. I really want to impress on him the fact that things that look complicated can be understood, if you just break down the task into bite-sized chunks.

Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by fivestar on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:17PM (#14446830)
You forget that Arduino and Raspberry Pi exist now and fill that void quite nicely. If anything, I think it is far, far easier to learn the intangible CS skills today than at any time in the past. The one problem I see is with kids' motivation to do so, not with access to information or materials.
Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by thenanyu on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @04:31PM (#14448301)
I think the subtlety is the change in defaults. Having access isn't even half the battle. Speaking from experience my motivation came from spending hundreds of hours making the only computer in my family work.
Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by rjbwork on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:34PM (#14447873)
Naw, but I don't think they fill that void. Regular families don't really need/want desktops like they may have in years past.
Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by theorique on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @10:34AM (#14445644)
Exactly. And the UI of a phone has become increasingly elementary and unsophisticated compared to even a keyboard and mouse. Being an end user of mobile games or Snapchat or Tinder (swipe-swipe-tap-swipe) simply doesn't prepare you for Emacs or vim.
Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by alasdair_ on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @02:18PM (#14447271)
My son is five and recently put together one of these: https://kano.me/

It's a great little system. It teaches the commandline and python programming and it lets kids do things like play minecraft then change the code to make it run differently.

Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by wcummings on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @08:12AM (#14444662)
This is why I think it should be mandatory for CS to use free software.
Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by smeroth on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @03:46AM (#14443559)
I don't think they have an advantage, as I've noticed that kids knowing their way around their phone are often completely lost when put in front of a computer. They never use the computer, they have everything in their phones. Compared to a computer, a phone is simple, and you aren't actually solving any problems while using it (you're just downloading and running apps). When you have a phone, however, there's no need to learn the computer. This means that they're missing out on the computer learning curve that we experienced.
Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by fivestar on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:19PM (#14446841)
Again, Rasp Pi and the whole "maker" movement are mainstream. My daughter is in a STEM Middle School and she has done more things at age 11 than I did when I was 18! They're teaching Android game coding to kids age 10.
Re:Why do so few people major in computer science? by CydeWeys on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @04:06AM (#14451021)
I think your daughter is lucky to be going to an exceptional school that teaches programming at age ten. The vast, vast majority of American students do not have these kinds of courses. May I ask what school system your daughter is in?