News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by otterley on Sunday May 28, 2017 @03:41PM (#14435768)
How is it that Southwest Airlines -- which is also a publicly-traded company -- continues to offer low fares, while remaining laser-focused on customer service in this environment? It's unfortunate that the reporter doesn't take any time to explore this long-standing exception.

It's easy to blame the public market system, but when exceptions like this are readily found, it's worth investigating whether there are other factors in play than the income statements alone.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by tw04 on Sunday May 28, 2017 @04:09PM (#14435885)
I've admittedly not done extensive research, this is mostly from memory, so if someone else remembers differently please correct me.

BUT - the reason Southwest was the "low fare" leader was because they locked in fuel prices back before we had the massive spike in prices in the early 2000s. That gave them a tremendous advantage over the other airlines given fuel is such a massive part of their overall costs. That combined with standardizing on a single plane (less impactful but still helpful) allowed them to both claim and honor the "low-cost leader" title.

Now that fuel prices have returned to a more "normal" state, their prices had to revert to the mean. They may be cheaper on some legs, but it's not universal anymore.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by brianwawok on Sunday May 28, 2017 @04:24PM (#14435945)
Its worse than that. A hedge on oil price is a bet on the way it will swing.

When oil prices went up, Southwest got to make record profit. When oil prices went down, Southwest got to make record losses.

Southwest also just offers no service to many unprofitable markets. If Southwest were the only carrier, many smaller airports would shut down. There would be maybe 40 larger airports, with high volume flights.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by Retric on Sunday May 28, 2017 @04:40PM (#14435996)
Southwest has been profitable for the last 43 years: http://investors.southwest.com/news-and-events/news-releases...

So, if by record losses you mean lower profit than normal then sure they got hammered in 2008.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by brianwawok on Sunday May 28, 2017 @06:11PM (#14436315)
Yes it was a bit in jest. But the same amount they save as price goes up, they lose when the prices go down. And yes stability is good, but it's not as big of a deal as ppl make it out to be
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by Retric on Sunday May 28, 2017 @07:12PM (#14436508)
Hedging can be a net win.

A simple example suppose if price of commodity increases by x your company fails and that has say a 10% chance of happening. If you usually profit 10 billion per year and you can hedge for say 1 billion per year then money wise it seems like a break even. However, failure costs not just this years profits, but every year after that. So, your expected profit over the next 10 years increases even if the hedge does not save you any money over that same 10 years.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by dude_no_come_on on Monday May 29, 2017 @08:36AM (#14438782)
"A bit in jest"? You made a strong and easily falsified statement. Why is it so many people on this message board are incapable of admitting they're wrong?
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by ssanders82 on Sunday May 28, 2017 @05:14PM (#14436115)
"A hedge on oil price is a bet on the way it will swing."

Well I mean it's implemented that way (buying long-term futures) but it's really just locking in a set price. Oil prices skyrocketing doesn't make them infinite money, because they have to either take contract delivery at the price they originally bought at, or use their futures profits to buy at the spot market. In the same way, falling oil prices doesn't cost them huge amounts of money, they just won't be able to take advantage of the fall in prices like a non-hedged carrier would.

I assume they try their very best to hedge to actual predicted usage and not try to profit from swings either way. If they could do that they'd be better off running a hedge fund.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by gommm on Sunday May 28, 2017 @06:00PM (#14436262)
And this is what happened with Cathay Pacific who lost a lot when oil prices went down...
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by echaozh on Monday May 29, 2017 @10:49AM (#14439357)
Well, why shouldn't some small airports close if they're not profitable?
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by noobermin on Sunday May 28, 2017 @04:32PM (#14435968)
>How is it that this one exception differs from majority of sample which can be explained by hypothesis X, that clearly disproves hypothesis X.

This is a similar argument to "this year is cooler than the last year so climate change is a hoax." Taking a single exception as a stand-in for the mean IS an invalid argument. At best, it points out that the world is more complicated than explanation X, but it certainly doesn't invalidate X for the sample it is predictive for.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by SilasX on Sunday May 28, 2017 @04:56PM (#14436055)
Well, it depends on what the claim is.

If you're claiming that overall temperate (or energy content etc) of the atmosphere is on an upward trend because of specific drivers, then one anomalous year doesn't refute that (so long as the rest of the years and samples are in line with the claim/theory).

If you're claiming that a certain ubiquitous dynamic exists that forces all providers in one market to do X to stay profitable, then it would refute that claim to point to one provider that is able to consistently, year after year, stay profitable without doing X.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by noobermin on Sunday May 28, 2017 @05:12PM (#14436107)
No one is making the argument with ∀. It would be preposterous to do that in the real world because "for all" quantifiers only work in mathematics. Almost always when someone says "all" in common conversation they either mean some form of "almost always" or "a good majority"; Otherwise, they are thinking too simplistically if they really think it applies to a true "all." Taking exception to "no true Scotsman" arguments of course.
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by SilasX on Sunday May 28, 2017 @05:17PM (#14436121)
I know they didn't say "for all", but it's functionally equivalent when the claim is that the very nature of the market forces providers into these patterns. That explanation would indeed be refuted by a persistent counter example.
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by noobermin on Sunday May 28, 2017 @05:39PM (#14436192)
Yes, I grant that a persistent counter example would point to other factors that could exist. Counter examples usually point to "the world is more complicated" rather than disprove X if X applies to a majority the set it talks about, as I said.

I'd imagine if X explains a good fraction of what you're talking about, you'd want to pursue X as an explanation over chasing explanations that effect the exceptions.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by SilasX on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @01:03PM (#14446719)
Again, depends on the claim. If the claim is that "factor X dominates to the point that it can't be ignored", then a persistent counterexample refutes it. If the claim is that "factor X makes it so that the most reliable business model is to do Y", then it wouldn't. My reading of the article is much closer to the former.
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by cbanek on Sunday May 28, 2017 @04:07PM (#14435879)
Well part of it is that there's an oligopoly in the airline industry that prevents competition.

First, it's a hard market to get into for new carriers (regulation, high capital costs for planes, etc.). Airports also only have a certain number of gates, and until expansion of the airport, it can be hard to accommodate new flights. This is how we get to the 'hub and spoke' model of airline carriers, where it can be cheaper to fly through their hub city on a longer flight with 2 planes, than to fly direct.

And if you're not competing with another airline, you're competing with yourself. This means lowering costs and trying to increase your margin, knowing it's a race to the bottom and people will have to fly anyway, no matter how bad it is.

Basically, you may or may not be on a route that has competition between two cities. Or another way to put it, if Southwest does great (and I do love Southwest), why aren't they in every airport and on every route stealing market share by doing it better?

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by bradknowles on Sunday May 28, 2017 @04:27PM (#14435950)
One factor is that employees own a significant fraction of the available shares in the company. So, as the company does better on Wall Street, they get a benefit.

In part, this helps each employee have a deeper investment in each and every event that happens in relation to a flight -- they work harder and more efficiently, get better turnaround times, more on-time flights, and better customer satisfaction.

When I fly, I choose to fly Southwest whenever that is possible. If that's not possible, then I might fly JetBlue, because they usually also do a decent job in these areas. I loved Virgin America as a second choice, before they got bought by Alaska Airlines.

But ever since my first flight on Southwest many years ago, they have been my favorite airline.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by tyingq on Sunday May 28, 2017 @05:18PM (#14436125)
They have profit sharing, but rank and file employees don't individually own stock unless they choose to buy some.
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by tacomonstrous on Sunday May 28, 2017 @04:34PM (#14435975)
The fares on Southwest aren't really low any more. At least, comparing them with United for flights out of Chicago, I don't find any real difference in prices, even on regular Economy fare. The only advantage that Southwest has at this point (and it's a very important one in some contexts) is that it doesn't have any change fees.
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by tyingq on Sunday May 28, 2017 @05:29PM (#14436160)
No baggage fees either.
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by tyingq on Sunday May 28, 2017 @06:01PM (#14436267)
There's many things Southwest does to remain profitable, but many wouldn't scale out to be useful for every airline.

Not listing your fares on any channel other than your own, for example. People assume you're the cheapest, even when you aren't. And, no big fees to pay the sellers.

Picking only profitable airports and routes. They avoid airports with high fees and slow procedures that keep aircraft on the ground. And they avoid routes that don't support fares or load factors they want.

There's only so much space for other airlines to do the same. Sure, things would correct over time, but no airline has been willing to try it and bleed cash waiting for the normalization.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by NotSammyHagar on Sunday May 28, 2017 @04:21PM (#14435933)
southwest used to be the low fare leader, but not anymore. now they are just average. the only advantage they have is the easy ability to cancel a flight and reuse the money later, without paying a pointless 100 or 200 dollar fee.
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by ma2rten on Sunday May 28, 2017 @04:08PM (#14435884)
This is how Southwest Airlines differentiates itself from other airlines. Since Southwest exists already, other airlines can't differentiate themselves anymore in the market by doing this.
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by drfuchs on Sunday May 28, 2017 @04:05PM (#14435870)
SWA hasn't offered lower fares from SFO, SJC, or OAK in many years now, as far as I've noticed. And good luck finding a direct flight that's both from and to your preferred airports. YairMMV...
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by smelendez on Sunday May 28, 2017 @04:16PM (#14435911)
It may depend on the airport! I live in New Orleans and regularly fly to SFO/OAK, and to LGA and ISP(Islip-MacArthur, on Long Island). Southwest is usually cheapest, even before taking free bag check into account.
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by wtvanhest on Sunday May 28, 2017 @03:59PM (#14435840)
Southwest has lower payroll expense due to being newer and gambled successfullt when they hedged their fuel prior to gas prices going way up.

They also cherry pick routes (smart).

They will eventually revert to the mean.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by tyingq on Sunday May 28, 2017 @05:21PM (#14436133)
This is not correct. Southwest actually has the highest labor costs in the US airline industry, as measured by percentage of revenue.
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by wtvanhest on Sunday May 28, 2017 @05:56PM (#14436249)
% of revenue is not the correct measure since they are low cost. You need to compare costs independent of rev.
Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by tyingq on Sunday May 28, 2017 @07:11PM (#14436500)
Define low cost. Their actual costs per seat mile are closer to AA and Delta than they are to Spirit.

You may be thinking of a time long ago.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by wtvanhest on Sunday May 28, 2017 @09:54PM (#14436981)
I am saying that revenue has no baring on employee cost structure. They have a much younger workforce, didnt have the issues with pensions that the other major carriers had and still pay their people less on average.

Their only real advantage was a speculative bet on fuel prices.

Again, they are already reverting to the mean and will continue to do so.

Re:Route to Air Travel Discomfort Starts on Wall Street by chrismcb on Tuesday May 30, 2017 @11:45PM (#14450288)
If you factor in all the fees, they will almost always be cheaper